News & opinion on Greater China and the even Greater Beyond: by Biff Cappuccino.

Wednesday, February 16, 2005

Review of The German Generals Talk (1948), by B.H. Liddell Hart

This book is a concise, sensible, readable summary of oral interviews conducted by Hart in 1948 with those of Hitler’s generals who survived the second, and counting, Great War to end all wars. It covers all of the major campaigns and is good as its word, offering "Startling revelations from Hitler's high command." (probably not the hyperbole of choice the late Hart would have gone for, but then again, one regularly reads blurbs for worthy books that depart from the tone of the book itself so far as to not only be misleading but likely to repel the author's intended audience. As is so often the case, the publisher is a Philistine and his crew of education-burdened information-workers are jakes hawking paper & ink widgets to the lowest common denominator in the commode reader marketplace. If Orwell was to really Turn Over in his Grave, rather than due to the double-speak somberly denounced by the (nearly) eponymous documentary, it would more likely be due to the dreadful testimonials on the Penguin editions of his works that make him out to be a latter-day Messiah hybrid of Oprah Winfrey, Christopher Hitchens, and Spencer Johnson (author of Who Moved My Cheese: An A-Mazing Way to Deal with Change in Your Work and In your Life). Orwell, when not feeling our pain, was inflicting it. In those early less civilized days, in addition to beating 'niggers' as a cop in Burma, he punched out the occasional friend when they got too much for him. Norman Mailer seems to have limited himself to head-butting his literary nemeses (ex: Gore Vidal); Bill O'Reilly's reduced to hate-sex and self-affirming barks of "Pinhead" and bellows of "Shaddup!")

Progress, progress. But I digress. As usual.

Anyway, this is a difficult book to review because it is so overstuffed with novel explanations for a grab-bag of main events, despite being written in 1948. For someone like myself who picked up most of his WWII impressions from school books, newspapers and maybe PBS, as usual I made the mistake of assuming the core issues were well-understood, well-ventilated, and old news indeed.

But, as usual, the mainstream edition of events is not shepherded by inventors of novel ideas, as there are too few of these freaks to go around. Instead events are stage-managed, in a manner most politicians would recognize, by diploma-bearing parrots of respectable (i.e. uncontroversial, lawsuit and scandal-proof) exegeses of events. If one holds one’s breath to delve into the low-oxygen works of the more respectable historians, especially if one flips through the tomes of those poor doomed clowns who win literary prizes, such as the appalling Pulitzer (a sort of literary albatross around the neck of good taste), one finds that most respectable authors have only a handful of ideas to market, which they then proceed to bulwark with 300 pages of impressively indexed and annotated facts and figures, examples, anecdotes, and quotes, mostly if not entirely borrowed from the works of other respectable factotums; i.e. by tossing in bale of packaging and a truckload of recycled filler which, to the connoisseur of the field, is indistinguishable from literary oatmeal. For me, a frank ignoramus of the events of WWII, anything would serve to impress. But this book almost overwhelms with its cataracts of ideas and heretical views clearly expressed. I emerged from several days reading this work with my head spinning and three pages of notes written in excitable ink, all of which are refer to specific original ideas which in turn beg further exploration and extrapolation. However, doing so would probably result in a 30 page review which I'm no more prepared to write than you're prepared to read.

Perhaps the best way to introduce this book is to let it speak for itself. This is from chapter 10, titled "How Hitler Beat France -- And Saved Britain"

The real story of any great event is apt to be very different to what appears at the time. That is especially the case in war. The fate of millions of people turns on decisions that are taken by one man - who may be influenced by the most curious of motives in reaching a decision that changes the whole course of history. The way he makes up his mind is known only by a few men behind the scenes, who usually have good reason for keeping it quiet. The truth sometimes leaks out later; sometimes never.

When it emerges it often bears out the saying that "truth is stranger than fiction." The novelist has to appear plausible, and would hesitate to make use of such astounding contradictions as occurred in history through some extraordinary accident or twist of psychology.

Nothing could be more extraordinary than the way that the decisive events of 1940 were shaped. France was overcome by an offensive in which few of the higher executants had any faith, and the invasion only succeeded through a belated change of plan on the German side that happened to fit the situation produced by rigidity of plan combined with overconfidence on the French side. Stranger still was the way that the British Army escaped, and Britain itself was preserved from invasion. The truth here is quite contrary to the popular picture. It would have seemed incredible to the British people at that time, and equally incredible to most of Hitler's ardent followers in Germany.

... The escape of the British army from France has often been called "the miracle of Dunkirk." For the German armored forces had reached the channel coast behind the back of the British army while this was still deep in the interior of Flanders.... Those who got away have often wondered how they managed to do so.

The answer is that Hitler's intervention saved them -- when nothing else could have. A sudden order from them over the telephone stopped the armed forces just as they were inside of Dunkirk...Rundstedt and other generals concerned, as executive commanders or on the higher staffs, gave me accounts from their different angles of the staggering order and its effects.

Hitler turns out not to be the three-testicled psycho and sociopath whose arch-fantasy was to have German heifers dollop Aryan turds on his mongrel Bavarian snout. Well, no surprise there. And surely the whole mystique about Hitler’s allegedly inscrutable personality is easily understood as the inability of the unintelligent to understand someone who can think for himself: i.e. an entirely removed species from themselves. Most of these dunderheads are like the sort of Christian who opines in a knowing way that God works in mysterious ways, a face-saving camouflage for “I don’t care to think about it” which is usually a patent admission of “I’m incompetent to think about it.” Reading the works of bold Christian thinkers such as Thomas Aquinas or Tertullian, one is at least impressed by the entertainment value of their colorful inventions, their over-stretched casuistry, their tortured attempts to plug round holes with square pegs in their fearless rationalizations of the implausible.

Either way, Hitler proves to be much like any other highly adept politician. Like Lincoln and like Churchill, because he's thoroughly familiar with political trends and economic developments, not only domestic but foreign, he sees farther and much more clearly that his generals, who were professional soldiers and aristocrats who took pride in their distance from politics and disesteem for the mob.

It’s perhaps worth prefacing that it took Lincoln two years to find a general that could prosecute his war, having passed over various political appointees (politicians, wire-pullers, and CEOs who canvassed for the job) and incompetent professional military commanders before he stumbled across the oft-drunk Ulysses Grant, whose primary strength turned out to be his willingness to throw his men into the slaughter without hesitation, thus earning himself the nickname of "the Butcher" from his own troops. Hitler, likewise, found his own generals to be lacking in foresight, timid (like Lincoln's General Mclellan, they also consistently overestimated the strength and difficulty of defeating enemy troops, while sneering at their political handler as being no better than a monkey), and tactically and strategically conservative.

Hitler's generals were also very politically unaware which greatly hampered their ability to prosecute strategic warfare. His generals were often very competent with the nuts and bolts of military tactics and quick studies therein, but they had very little sense of how European politics worked.

For example, Hitler's generals were overwhelmingly opposed to launching an attack against France in 1940. So opposed were they that they established a cabal of generals to lead their armies on Berlin to overthrow Hitler and the Nazis in a military coup, thus reviving the ancient Roman tradition begun by Julius Caesar and which threatened to take place figuratively speaking with McArthur and Truman. In the end, the leading general refused to cooperate believing, probably correctly, that Hitler's popularity with the masses was too great and that they would not survive the coup. But equally surprising is that Hitler himself was very worried about moving on France. He saw it as a gamble, one that he could lose easily. He went into France apparently, not because he wished to expand his empire into France, but because he was unable to secure a peace treaty with France or England. The enemy he feared most was Soviet Russia. He felt he could not fight both France and Russia at the same time in 1942. Thus, he had to take out France first. (I had previously presumed the Hitler peace overtures were a ruse.)

The miracle of Dunkirk took place apparently because Hitler was opposed to invading England. He felt that England and the Catholic Church were pillars of stability in Europe. He believed Germans were racially not constituted for living in the tropics and that the British colonies were thus of no interest to Aryan Germans. Thus, he let the British troops depart from Dunkirk unhampered for three days. Similarly, he prosecuted the Battle of Britain with little fervor and apparently only attacked England by air after first being pushed by Churchill's repeated bombings of German cities. Most of Churchill's government wished to sue for peace with the Germans, but Churchill was adamant about going to war. Churchill could not get the Germans to sink British shipping, so he tried getting Hitler's goat by ordering the secret bombing of Hamburg, etc. (FDR of course pursued a lite-version, via trade wars and contrived international incidents, of the same tactic with the Japanese)

Apparently Hitler was not interested in attacking North Africa either, but he worried that Mussolini would change sides and join the Allied countries. This was the only reason he participated in the North Africa campaign at first.

The list of surprises goes on and on. The German military apparently, like the Americans and British, first prepared for the Second World War by amassing cavalry. Rommel, for example loved horses and disliked tanks. He initially knew nothing about armored divisions and his successes were due primarily to tactical brilliance (example: driving truck caravans towards Allied bases from different directions to create a misimpression that they were being attacked by a vast armada of tanks). Rommel was held in such high esteem by the British troops that a positive accomplishment was termed by them "a Rommel."

In contrast to the standard notion that Hitler acted in the manner of an Oriental despot, one of his generals, Zeitzler, often lost his temper with him. He tendered his resignation on numerous occasions and it was only in 1944 after committing himself to hospital and faking an illness that he was relieved of command. In other words, Hitler's generals, this was not the only one, could be contumacious and retain their positions. Indeed, it could be difficult to get fired.

This is not to say that Hitler didn't make numerous mistakes. He fired good generals over sex scandals because he was a prude. He was also in the habit of ensuring loyalty to his command by promoting younger generals over those more qualified. This of course led to disgruntled senior staff and incompetence in the field. Towards the end of the war, because of Hitler's great successes overruling the judgment of his generals, he tended not to trust their judgment in anything. He micromanaged battles with results that his generals were like Hollywood rent-a-directors slavishly following film scripts. He refused on many occasions to let generals retreat and this led to avoidable losses on innumerable occasions. It turns out that, rather than offense being the best defense, that in fact the best defense is defense. Apparently, German divisions holding good defensive postures were often able to fend off allied troops up 18 times their own number. This is one of the reasons it took so long to defeat the Germans after D-Day despite the Germans being vastly outnumbered and never having anything approaching air superiority.

Hitler also put Gestapo spies on all of his generals which did nothing for morale or creative thinking, as one can imagine. And, the nature of military orders changed for the worse. In WWI orders were deliberately brief to permit flexibility of execution by field officers. With Hitler on the throne, propaganda was written on high and then inserted into orders for the troops below and micromanagement became the order of the day. Hitler envied Stalin, including his purge of the Russian military because, post-purge, Stalin's generals were so completely obedient. On the other hand, what he did not realize was that the Russians, more fearful of Stalin than the Germans, were terrified of taking any sort of risk and dared not deviate in any form from their orders. As a result, they tended to attack in a cyclical fashion enabling German generals to predict like clockwork their attacks. It was this sort of dogmatic manner which led to so many deaths in the First World War, where generals would operate in an honorable fashion and launch attacks after giving the enemy sufficient time to down its breakfast, for example.

Apparently, German troops were prepared for the winter conditions in Russia after the end of the first winter. So much for the prevailing cliché. Russia's strength was Stalin's ability to drive large numbers of men like slaves into battle, as was the case with the Chinese Nationalists and Communists and with Vietnam's Ho Chi-min. With sufficient cannon-fodder much can be achieved, though surely the achievement is usually not worth the effort if one dispassionately weighs the pros against the cons. The Russians, like the US soldiers in the Civil War, were gunned down by their own officers if they tried to run in the heat of battle. Again, was the US really improved by the Civil War? A topic of discussion which leads profitably to some highly provocative and searching conclusions when the bilge of patriotism is purged from the podium.

Last but not least, Hart mentions that French Communists, Gaullists, and Girandists (the primary French resistance groups) constantly ratted to the Germans about each other's activities like the anti-Roman revolutionary splittists of Monty Python's Life of Brian. This mockery went on until 1943 when the British secret service walked in and forced them to act like adults, supplying them and directing their operations. This was successful because French resistance bombing disrupted trains carrying supplies and reinforcements after D-Day. Additionally, allied air supremacy and the unexpected long-range, power and accuracy of Allied Navy artillery led to significant German losses and tactical failures.

There’s this and much, much more. Highly recommended.

Biff Cappuccino

Saturday, February 12, 2005

Patriotism - another Mark Twain knock-off. I haven’t changed the original story (“Political Economy”) much at all really. Just run through it with a rake and clippers, pruning verbs and adjectives and grafting my own on. Hard work for my brain’s not in the habit of manufacturing metaphors and off-color verbiage on demand like this. But practice makes for perfection… Sort of like practicing rap. After a few weeks of mumbling to yourself in step as you clip down the sidewalk, it becomes second nature to speak in rhyming couplets. I prefer creative stuff, building from scratch, to this spade and shovel drudgery, but it's got to be done as I see it... Biff Cappuccino

Patriotism is the basis of all good citizenry. The ablest men of all ages have brought to bear upon the subject the...

[I was interrupted and told that a stranger wished to see me down at the door. I went and confronted him, and asked to know his business, struggling the whole time to keep a hold on my thoughts, which were wriggling mischievously and ready to bust loose at any point and flock off to the netherlands. Privately, I wished the stranger would be sullied by a mob of pariah dogs and chased away to hell which, given the heat these several days, was reasoned to presently be due north. I was all hot and bothered; he cool as a cumquat. He was dreadfully sorry to have disturbed me but on passing by the premises he ventured that I'd profit from the satellite TV dish paradigm. I said, "Yes, yes good man -- go on -- what about it?" He said there was nothing about it, nothing in particular -- nothing but that he would like to install one for my education and edification. I was new to housekeeping, sojourning in hotels and boarding houses all of my life. Like most anyone else would in my station, I try to appear (to strangers) to be an old housekeeper; consequently I said in an offhand way that I had been wanting for some time to have a parcel of TV dishes planted, but -- and the stranger started, and looked inquisitively at me, but I was tranquil. I thought that if I chanced to make any mistakes, he would not catch me by my countenance. He said he would rather have my bidness than any man's in town. I was warmed by his enthusiasm and said, "Well all right then," and went off to do battle with my great subject again, when he called me back and noted that it would be important to know exactly how much "flatware" I wanted put up, what parts of the home I wanted adorned, and what quality of gear I preferred. He threatened to catch me out at this point, given my unfamiliarity with the customs of domiciles in these parts; but I went through creditably and he probably never suspected that I was new around here. I told him to put up eight "pots," and plant them all on the roof, and use the best quality of ceramic. He said he could furnish the "plain" article at 20 dollars; "glazed," 25 dollars; "Teflon-coated all-weather coaxial cable," at 30 dollars, that would fetch a signal at any time, no matter where it was emanating from, and "persuade it that further wandering was surplus to requirements; plus a decoder to dephlogisticcate and domesticate it." I said dephlogisticcate was no mean designation, emanating from a man of his professional persuasion, but, the study of pragmatics aside, I liked the Teflon-coated all-weather coaxial cable and would take that model. Then he said he COULD make do with two hundred and fifty feet; but to do it proper, and make the best job in the borough of it, and entice the admiration of the vulgar and profane alike, and compel all audiences to admit they never saw a more shambolic and hyperborean display of TV flatware since they came into this world, he supposed he really couldn`t get along without four hundred, though he wouldn’t hold it against me if I was squeamish, and trusted he was willing to try. I said, go ahead and use four hundred, and engineer any kind of project he pleased out of it, but let me get back to my work. So he was off my hands at last; and now, after half an hour spent in getting my train of patriotic thoughts coupled together again, I am ready to go on once more.]
-
gallantest lights of commutarian sensibility, their empirical wisdom, and founts of learning. The mystery-workers of deep folk-feeling, the mighty protectors of anointed realm, and the sacred apostles of chauvinistic multiculturalism, of all ages, all civilizations, and one nation undivided, from Confucius down to Mao Zedong, have --
-
[Here my train of thought was uncoupled, and I was required to go down and confer further with that TV flatware man. I hurried off, bubbling and frothing with precocious mind-pictures swaddled in words of such grace and fascination that each one of them was in itself a rolling juggernaut of polysyllables that might be ten minutes passing by an applauding audience, and once more I confronted him -- he so mild and phlegmatic, I so roiled and agitated. He was standing erect with the reflective composure of a face in Mount Rushmore, with one shoe amidst my orchids, and the other steady among my poinsettia, his palms fixed akimbo, his hat-brim tilted forward, one eye shut and the other contemplating critically and admiringly the jungle of excrescences embellishing my rooftop. He said now THERE was a state of things to make a man glad to be alive; and added, "I leave it to YOU if you ever saw anything more deliriously picturesque than eight co-axial dishes on the southwest corner of a building facing northeast?" I said I had no present recollection of any artwork that transcended it. He opined that nothing in heaven or earth but the Buddhas carved into the living stone of the Three Gorges was superior to it by way of natural scenery. All that was needed now, he verily believed, to render my house a balanced esthetic was to kind of touch up the other corners a little, and thus "add to the generous coup d`oeil a soothing uniformity of spiritual propriety which would harmonize the excitement naturally consequent upon the first coup d`etat." I asked him if he learned to talk out of a book, and if I could borrow it anywhere? He smiled amiably, and instructed me that his rhetorical form was not taught in books, and that nothing but familiarity with the mysteries of applied science could prepare a man to manage his style of palaver with impunity. He then calculated an estimate, and said that about a dozen more pots distributed about my roof would about do me proper, and he guessed five hundred feet of cable would serve the purpose; and added that the first eight had got a head start of him, so to speak, and he’d used up a mere trifle of material more than he had figured on -- a hundred feet or round abouts. I said I was in a fearful rush, and I wished we could get this project configured once and for all, so that I could get on with my proper business. He said, "I could have put up those eight pots, and be done with it -- some men WOULD have done so. But no; I said to myself, this man is new around here and I will perish before I do him wrong; there ain`t pots sufficient to their appointed purpose on that rooftop, and I for one will never sleep proper again unless I`ve done as I would have done to me, by the Lord’s eternal grace, and told him so. Stranger, my obligation is fulfilled and I breathe easier but for a tightness due to a pang of unavoidable regret; now if the satellites should suffer seasonal rearrangement for the peregrinations of the magnetic north pole or daylight savings time, leaving your signal beyond the pale, and if --" "There, now, there," I said, "plant the other dozen -- add five hundred feet of coaxial cable -- do anything and everything you feel is wanted; but calm your intimations and premonitions, and try to keep your feelings where they remain accessible to the dictionary. Meanwhile, if we have achieved an understanding, I shall return to my work again."

It took a full painful hour this time just to resuscitate the frame of mind frustrated by the last interruption; but I had accomplished it at last and ventured to proceed again.

…scrapped with this wondrous subject, and the worthiest among them have found it a great opponent, and one that always comes up fresh and smiling after every knockdown. The great Confucius said that he would rather be a patriotic philosopher than a congressman. George Washington related that professional patriotism was the grandest profession that the patriot was worthy of professing; and even our own GW has said obscurely, but manly-like, that "Patriotism --
-
Biff: That's as much as I can stomache for now. Off to try my hand at working up something completely fresh story-wise by my own hand, but which operates in a similar vein to tickle both fancy and funny bone... (judging by that last infelicitious phrase...haha...this is going to take a few more days...)

Thursday, February 10, 2005

My Scooter (a knockoff of Mark Twain’s My Watch)

The following crude imitation of Twain’s work is going to suck, and suck badly no doubt. But, you have to bust a few eggs to make an omelet. Mine are still scrambled. This is some rocky cornball, but I have to start somewhere. Bottom is usually where that somewhere lies. Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Either way, it’s going to take a couple of weeks to figure out how to do this sort of stuff. But I shall…

My Scooter: An Instructive Little Tale

My new scooter had been a buck stallion these six months. She was infallible and reliable, a trustworthy and boon companion, her constitution and anatomy imperishable. But at last, one day I had to take her to the repair shop. Nothing adventurous, just to tap up the tires, which I’d put off for a while, and which were now soft and become twin fish-tailing accident-generating disasters in tandem. I had dithered and put the thing off, gripped as I was by a premonition of doom featuring my beloved machine anatomized by death merchants going chop-chop in a chop shop.

But by and by I got it together and commanded my concerns to depart and made for a certified repair outlet. A grubby personage trotted over. I kicked the tires in the casual way of the connoisseur and suggested “Top ‘em up, sir, if you will please.” The head of the establishment took a personal fancy to my machine, preambled over and looked her up and down knowingly. With a sonorous gravitas he said, “Why fellah, what she needs is a new spark plug.” Before I could digest the import and implications of this declaration, he snapped his fingers and his No. 1 grease monkey was having at her with his profane hands.

I broke out in a sweat. I tried to remonstrate, to have the headman understand there was nothing the matter with the mechanical operation of my pet. But no; all this human cabbage could see was that it had a touch of blue smoke and so just HAD to have a new spark plug. I danced around him with anguish and implored him to let her alone. But like Caesar’s crossing of the Rubicon, the dice was cast and came up craps.

I put my foot down. I refused to pay for services unrequired. But he would have none of my requirements. Waving me down from his modest height, he informed me that I was freshly arrived and an American to boot and proudly stated to all and sundry grubby fellows in attendance that he was providing his services gratis; that it was a free courtesy and a fine karmic gesture to a stranger from a strange land, a hale and hearty welcome from the sons of the Yellow Emperor as it were. A round of huzzah! went up from his crew.

But as for I, well I trembled with exasperation. I inquired if I could have the privilege of perusing the operating manual. "Manual?" he inquired. I explained, "For the spark plug, my good man." He replied that for a professional of his years and experience, manuals weren’t for reading but for writing. “Is that a fact,” I responded. And he looked at me strangely, snorted at his boys, placed his arm over his chest and began hooting with a sudden pain. I slunk away with my scooter, launching her into the colorful twilight smog, I looked back to find him settled in his Buddha-bead boss chair, still chuckling, but tired now, the unusual exertion having tuckered him out, leaving him a sort of snorfling and crying himself to sleep as it were.

My scooter ran faster now, but unpredictably, like she was on the laughing gas. She launched from the sidelines with gusto, whooshing like a rocket, blowing sparks out the back end, thrusting me violently into turbulent traffic and threatening to fetch me to my Great Reward before I had time to enjoy it. During the first day, the damage was limited to an old crone, her groceries scattered hither and thither; it cost me my lunch money to compensate her. The following day, my pet chose a taxi, pitching me over the hood and beaching herself alongside the vehicle where I found her, a picture of mechanical serenity. The taxi operator thumped me with a baseball bat and filched my wallet while I was still snatching at stars. The next day we soared like a missile into the backside of a bus, rattling my teeth and my confidence. Then a red light tempted her and we got broadsided in the intersection by a gravel truck, the driver considerate in the usual way of his vocation, backing up and driving over me again to be sure I was feeling no pain.

Things were getting out of hand, so I took her to another dealer. He took a look and pronounced authoritatively that the carburetor was in need of winding up. The float was drowning and needed First Aid. I took her back on the road, and now she huffed and puffed like a paralytic, despondent and unable to build a respectable head of steam. She wheeled pathetically along, her spirits sunk. We were passed by wrist rockets, pocket rockets. Then busses and then even the rag and bone man, the greybeard peddling past in shorts and skinny shanks, waving as he passed us by. Pedestrians felt sorry and offered to push. I was never going to get anywhere in life. I missed appointments, went hungry, was late for dinner.

So I got me to another industrial specialist. He opined that the carburetor was fine, but that the seals on the shocks were losing their tether. They was frayed. He pointed to a leak. But now I was fond for the former days when I took the damaged scooter slow-poking around. Now she bottomed out in every pothole, jarring my bones and knocking me half-senseless.

I hunted up another professional opinion. This one offered that the tires were scalloping. I smiled in a knowing way, not wanting to be mistaken for a newbie in the vehicular arts. He planted new steel-belted studded radials on her and I felt satisfied. But then I discovered that every time I aimed the handle bars in the direction of a left turn, my pet kept plowing straight ahead. Whenever I wanted to go straight, she insisted on a right turn. Formerly, getting to a destination was an easy navigation. Now, I perforce I had to aim by a circular route, going counterclockwise and taking into account wind speed, humidity, and ambient temperature. I apprehended that I had to look at my destination and then point my pet 180° in the opposite direction of the one I was aiming for. She’d take me in a long camber, wandering royally across lanes, scaling sidewalks like it was nobody’s business but her own, and just generally breaking all the legal laws and busting out a myriad infractions of common sense. By and by, though, she did her best to get me somewhere proximate to my destination. Whereupon I hailed a cab.

Getting impatient with taxi drivers, also frequent victims of vehicles that refuse all by circuitous routes, I took the poor suffering scooter to another doctor to have the tires diagnosed, anatomized, and entered into the surgery clinic if need be. This splendid gentleman informed me with great majesty and generosity that he’d fix the tires for free, but that the clutch plates was unfortunately worn a tad. I emerged on the street again, this time with a creative transmission whose gears took uncalled for liberties with artistic license. The automatic transmission now automatically shifted from first to third gear, from third to fifth, and from fifth into second and then from fourth into first gear, with the impressive precision of a musician running through his scales. My loyal pet took on the mien of a bohemian rascal. With all this shifting and jerking I could neither hold onto my groceries or my lunch. I lost my wife off the back, leaving me lonesome and holding on for dear life itself. I have never seen her since and do not quite know who abandoned whom or whom abandoned who. But then I realized this was a capital favor of magnificent magnitude and I returned to the smiling doctor and gave the good man a bonus. But too much of a good thing can make it a bad one. I plain got to missing my wife, my gears, my groceries and my lunch.

I took the scooter to yet another expert, priding myself on never allowing the sacred flame of hope extinguish in a valiant breast. When I looked him over I recognized a seedy former acquaintance from Atlantic Canada, but, who, unlike myself, was unreconstituted and unrevaluated and just plain unrepentant. Living overseas hadn’t cured him of his pastoral afflictions, but spoiled him by infecting him with a new crust of city ones. I never had a particular high opinion of him and was not surprised to discover the slacker had departed the high and mighty art of English teaching for Zen and the increasingly low, as I was beginning to see it, art of motorcycle maintenance.

Fortunately he was too busy getting acquainted with my pet to recognize me. He looked her over with a lascivious grin and pronounced, "Well Holy O Martha! If she ain't just defective all around? Even a gravelroader goaler knows this here's a gonner. By gum, she needs to be fixed up and replaced, root and branch, hook and sinker, whole hog I tell ye. Hmm… But maybe this here mother-scratcher's got potential. Sure. Tell ye what I’m going to do, Sir. I'll make it my personal mission to save her from the heathen’s junkyard. She just needs an overhaul, a tuneup, and a life insurance policy. Follow me into my office sir and let’s see if we can’t find us a contract to be signed."

I picked up a crow bar and brained him on the spot. I had him cremated, his ashes placed in a pristine Buddhist urn overlooking a mountainous heap of fengsui at my own expense.

Chinese friends of mine often wonder what happens to English teachers when they get old. Do they just retire and fade away? Or is there a special fate for them in heaven? I've never had the heart to tell them.
-
Biff: Yeah, I know this is crap. I hate it too. But, it's a start.
Parsing Nonsense

“Would you send your child to die in Iraq?” was a question posed recently by straw man Michael Moore to stuffed shirt Bill O’Reilly. O’Reilly countered that the issue was better settled by asking whether he personally was willing to risk his life, trying to bring a wholesome manliness to the issue and sensing somehow that Moore was trying to spin the question for emotional effect. Moore sensed that he might lose some tear-pulling momentum and tried to return the spotlight to sending in the children, as opposed to saving them, given the awesomely tedious predictability of the emotional tug this would have for most folks. It has none for me, and injections of manliness usually serve to squeeze sense out of the picture, and just leave me looking for the door. But these are other issues for another day.

However, on the bike in traffic, on a doomed quest to get to the south of the island today during Chinese New Year, and in between taking the bike boldly on to sidewalks and otherwise ignoring the elastic traffic laws to the south of Taipei City, this question entered my mind a few times:

Would you SEND your CHILD to DIE in Iraq? Something was wrong with the question. Some buffoonery was afoot.

To DIE? Nobody sends children to die in Iraq that I’m aware of except for the parents of Muslim martyrs. US soldiers go to Iraq to achieve military ends but with the goal of returning alive. This is why grunts wear body armor; why armored divisions have – what else? - armor; why evasive maneuvers are designed to evade incoming bullets and missiles. In other words, one doesn’t send one’s children to Iraq on suicide missions. They go there to accomplish military objectives, to live and fight another day. Ergo the rapid rotation of experienced troops out of Iraq to train fresh recruits back in the US. Who in the US military goes to Eye-rack to die?

CHILD? Are there any children serving in the US forces, as opposed to Third World militaries where they’re often to be found? No. But of course Michael was referring to adult children. But one doesn’t send adults to war. Adults aren’t children. Adults make their own decisions. Bill can no more send his adult children (if he has any) to war than my father could have prevented me from enlisting in the reserves and possibly being called up to serve in Beirut during the early 1980’s. My father was adamantly opposed to my weekend warrior service. The hell with him, I thought. I’m not a child. I can do what the fuck I want. So I joined up. I also applied later to serve as a regular in the Canadian Air Force and was tested and accepted but turned down the position offered (navigator; I wanted to be a pilot). In other words, nobody is sending any children, either juvenile or adult, to any military theater. If adult children go, it’s of their own accord. After all, the military is not conscript-based, it’s professional.

Which brings us to the next issue: SEND? How do you send your children to die in Iraq? Clearly Mike doesn’t mean putting kids in a box and mailing them there. And you can’t just show up as a Rambo vigilante character with grenades, rocket launchers and an M-16 because you’ll be arrested and probably sent to a loony bin for R&R. Mike means send your (adult) children to join the US Armed Forces and send them to Eye-rack. But if you sign up, there’s no guarantee that you’ll get there. The Armed Forces decide, not you. You could be posted to Korea or Japan or a myriad other locations. You could be deployed to Iraq. But there you’d probably not see action, as most of the military works in logistics (everything from accounting to running warehouses to kitchen patrol). In other words, Bill doesn’t have the power to send his adult children anywhere dangerous if they’re in the military.

So, NOBODY growing up in democratic America is likely to be in a position to SEND CHILDREN to DIE in Iraq.

So ‘would you send your child to die in Iraq?’ is a moot question for it implies the impossible on three fronts, at least.

So maybe Mike phrased it badly. But the key question, if rearranged, is still valid, right? No. Watch. Mike’s hard question, when tempered with a dose of reality, translates to this: Bill, would you encourage a relative of yours to make up his own mind, as an adult, and apply to the US forces, apply for deployment in Iraq, apply for non-logistics-related duties in patrol or active military theater that would place this relative at a low risk for suffering bodily harm. (As I understand it, it is a low risk) In other words, Mike is asking Bill: “Do you support the war and are you willing to encourage other adults to support it in their own way?”

Well, this dispassionate mainstream news phrasing of the question doesn’t sell mockumentaries like Fahrenheit 911. No zip. No pizzazz. If it doesn’t bleed, how can it lead? So, it’s much better for corporate sales and ad revenues, much easier to get the customer’s attention, by asking: “Would you send your children to die in Iraq?”

Mike seems guilty of more of that best-selling wishful thinking and populist fustian that’s made him such a household name and a multi-gazzilionnaire who travels by private jet to feel our pain in person. And Bill’s no-spin zone seems to have met its match and been spun by a whopper, the Big Lie, in this case three implied ones, at least.

Thus are the issues debated and decided by the elect. More times than you might think.

Biff Cappuccino

Tuesday, February 08, 2005

More On IQ:

How about the key role of methodology in the modern conception of intelligence, or at least in my amateur notion of it? Most of our habits of thought, particularly those which distinguish us from the Third World, are culturally derived. This seems obvious I'm sure, but bear with me for a moment.

Take the ability to work with logic. Logic, in the sense of syllogism, is by no means intrinsic to the human brain as demonstrated by the difficulty with which logical propositions are expressed clearly only to be followed by the additional uphill battle of persuading the largely sentimental population at large.

For example, key to thinking and speaking logically is firewalling oneself off from the emotions of your audience, singular or plural. If you care about the other person's feelings and worry about the impression you're making on them, you can't focus on that trickiest and most elusive element: logic. It takes full concentration upon following syllogism, context, points of reference, and so forth to be logical.

The brain's like a computer with too little RAM. Run one program at a time, and it's quick. Run a parcel of programs and it's slow. In debates, rather than try to interact with your opponent across the board, if you remove emotional involvement this frees up RAM and you're back to being quick again. Of course it means that you have to be cold; it means that you have to adjourn the usual protocol, instincts, and so forth. A very unnatural process. Which is why so few people do it. But you'll see, if you watch, that the better grade of logician does this. They're indifferent to you. You mean nothing to them. They only care about what you say, not that you say it.

But it works. I've been doing this since my teens. Not because I'm intrinsically smart, but because I picked it up from a Scottish father whose relatives do the same thing. In other words, I got it from culture. When I was younger, I thought it was because I was smarter. I made the easy mistake of confusing cultural acquirements with genetic advantage.

Similarly, to be logical, one can't invest emotional capital into perspectives. The way to proceed rapidly, deftly, and successfully through the maze of logical propositions that constitute modern life is to never be loyal to any of them ever. When you discover a handsome, cherished proposition is wrong, abandon it like yesterday's newspaper and immediately move on. Even better: never cherish a proposition. Never allow yourself to feel embarrassed, ashamed or regretful. Not because you're too tough to admit that you're just as dumb as the rest of us, but because these emotions are not helpful. They slow you down and distract you. The point of debate is the pursuit of truth, not the pursuit of comeuppance, revenge, and ego gratification. Chase those three, and you'll get your butt kicked by any logician worthy of the name. Just as you would be able to kick his arse where he to chase these three.

Again, a very simple methodology. But when you think about it, how many people actually do this? They usually do the opposite.

Invest emotional capital and it becomes critical whether or not you're right. The correctness of a perspective becomes entangled in one's sense of self-esteem. Divest yourself of this emotional capital and you can be very nimble and intelligent, even wise because you can plow rapidly through logical propositions and figure out what's most likely to be correct. You're never in defense mode. Only in offense mode.

Furthermore, one has to be almost pathological about the pursuit of truth. Only through doing so, for whatever reason, can one develop reasonable logical propositions and be in a position to explode unreasonable ones. Again, it's a very simple methodology. Anyone can do this.

However, I don't think I've ever met another person who's scrupulously honest. Who does not fudge. Who is not polite when telling the truth will be deemed offensive. And yet, the only way to test your own views is to give them as expansive a hearing as possible. You never know who is going to cut the legs out from under one of your arguments.

Again, this sort of approach goes against the grain of normal human interaction. But only through doing so does a person have a chance of becoming intelligent. Again, we're talking about adherence to an unnatural methodology. A methodology that has nothing to do with genetic superiority, but entirely to do with the serendipity of being born into a culture and era which tolerates, even values, such eccentricities as penetrating intelligence. Many cultures, of course do not.

Cultures which are oppressed by martial law tend not to esteemed penetrating intelligence. On the one hand, it's of course because of the control of free speech and punishment of dissidents. On the other hand, it's a matter of parents not wanting their children to get in trouble and discouraging them from airing their views. This is often done to the point where parents do not tell their children what they themselves think for fear of being accidentally incriminated by their kids or because their kids may speak up and get in trouble. A couple of generations of this and the grandkids are feebs.

Again, in many, many cultures and for many, many reasons, intelligence of the penetrating kind is by no means encouraged. It's discouraged, and actively so. Can imagine how penetrating intelligence goes down in modern theocracies, for example? Think back to all the thinkers burned at the stake during the Christian Middle Ages. Ask yourself what the average IQ must have been in those days? Pretty depressing I'm sure.

There are many rules of thumb whose digestion and application are required for membership in the First World mindset. Adjourning violence in favor of respecting the opinions of others and their right to disagree with you. Time management. In other words, a three o'clock appointment means meeting someone at three o'clock and not at 3:30 or 4 p.m. The adjournment of superstitions. In other words, the abandoning of prohibitions on fishing on certain days, the forbidding of planting on others, and so forth. Adjournment of the notion that lending money at interest is evil. Thou must covet, for otherwise the global economy collapses.

There are many others. Again, membership in the modern world is mostly about adherence to a set of rules and guidelines which work in our commercial era and information age, where time is money, knowledge is power, and, I personally find, honesty is still the best policy. I might make a capable liar if I was to devote myself to the craft, but rest assured my IQ would drop precipitously. No thanks.

Biff Cappuccino

Monday, February 07, 2005

PostScript to the review of Race - The Reality of Human Differences:
-
Amy Chua's World on Fire: How Exporting Free-Market Democracy Breeds Ethnic Hatred and Global Instability sheds light on the behavioral genesis, as opposed to genetic provenance, of IQ. In reading the following, you might want to ask yourself which of the correspondents will have children who perform well at school and on IQ tests, and which, unfortunately, will not.

From pp 106-107, World on Fire: I recently posted on the Web the following question: "why have the Kikuyu been more economically successful than other Kenyans?" (In Kenya, the term "Kenyans" is still understood to mean black Kenyans.) Many Kenyans, including self identified Kikuyus,Luos,and Kalenjin respondents. Here's a sampling of their comments.

W.: the Kikuyu, of which I'm one, have become successful economically due to various reasons. One, civilization came early to our community when the colonial settlers settle in our land and introduced the start of the Kenyan economy. Second, the Kikuyus have a different attitude. They like to invest and try ventures, however small they are. They believe that being a small-business owner is better than being a manager here or there... in my family, there is no one who is an employee. We believe that the worst offense you can do to yourself is to remain an employee. Rightly so, wealth is created by those who engage in business.

K: It Is Out Of Hard Work. Hard Hard Work and Confidence. The Same Reasons All Other People Become Strong Economically.

S. [responding to K]: you are a sick puppy. If I remind you of Kamaliza [a Swahili name for "exterminator" and a nickname used by some Kenyans to refer to presidents Kenyatta], you will realize that your fathers and mothers have an unfair advantage vis-à-vis other Kenyans. During Kenyatta's reign, he transferred all the "white settlers" lands to Kikuyus. Please don't give me that BS of I work hard and own my own business. If you don't care to learn history then stop spouting ignorance... you should at the very least to stop corrupting this media with misinformation. Please acknowledge the sins of your ancestors, then propose solutions. Non-Kikuyus sat on the sidelines while Kamaliza and his Kikuyu henchmen raped the country, denying other Kenyans jobs and land. We are all hard-working folks and don't think for a moment that your likes have cornered the market on success, by virtue of being Kikuyu.

J: this is what you say to a stranger, with no idea about Kenya and how Kikuyus got wealthy! You say that Kikuyus were outright thieves?! Next time check your words!!! I insist, Kikuyus are not thieves. They were aided to their wealth, but nobody makes it to financial success without help. That is why banks offer loans. The difference is that Kikuyus appreciate the little they have and have a drive towards enterprise like no other tribe in Kenya. I was brought up by my aunt, she fed us by selling the local brew, and now she owns a restaurant!! Am I not allowed to be proud of that??? She was never a relation of a certain minister and neither did she finish her formal education!!... you being a Kenyan should have some sensitivity on what you write!!! The Kikuyu bashing has to stop!! I am tired of everyone picking on Kikuyus because we happen to be the first at the top!!!!!

S: what I'm trying to tell your kinsman is that hard work is not a genetic trait of Kikuyus only... you have to accept facts such as outright stealing favoring Kikuyus that was perpetrated by Kamaliza henchmen -- like the series of Kikuyu governors and department heads that are in charge of the central bank. Moi and his henchmen [who are Kalenjin] may be stealing now, but is he doing anything different from what Kamaliza did? You don't have to defend Kamaliza because you are a Kikuyu.

P: Guys, calling each other names IS NOT going to resolve anything. I suggest you respect each other's opinions or positions, and stick with ONLY THE FACTS.

M.: it is as simple as having self-determination and being afraid of poverty. To be poor means being hopeless to Kikuyu. You are not accorded respect by other men. They can even swindle your wife, they regard you like garbage. These are some of the reasons that make Kikuyus economically strong. It is like part of the culture of the people. But not anymore, not under Moi.
-
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
-
Concerning the scandal over Ward Churchill, an ethnic impersonator (fake Amerindian) and professor at the University of Colorado, a fellow professor, Paul Campos, at UC wrote the following:

Anyone who reads widely in the collected works of professor Churchill, and especially anyone who listens to his speeches, will, if they are not blinded by certain ideological commitments, recognize the essentially fascist tendency of his work. If a white American were to speak of any foreign people or nation in anything like the way Churchill discusses America and Americans, the fascist character of his work would be obvious to everyone.

Most interesting to me, and with regard to the above dialogue between Kenyans, was Campos' working definition for fascism:
-
As a political inclination and an aesthetic style, fascism is marked by, among other things, the following characteristics:
-
• The worship of violence as a purifying social force. This often manifests itself as an aggressive and romanticized militarism, that produces a kind of cult of the warrior, and that advocates violent action as a mechanism for social change, and an appropriate way of crushing dissent.
-
• A hyper-nationalistic ideology, that casts history into a drama featuring an inevitably violent struggle between Good and Evil, and that obsesses on questions of racial and ethnic identity.
-
• The dehumanization and scapegoating of opponents, who are characterized by turns as demonically clever conspirators plotting to undermine the possibility of a virtuous society, and soulless automatons mindlessly carrying out the orders of a vast and evil bureaucracy. This dehumanization often leads to demands that the evil in our midst be eradicated "by any means necessary," up to and including the mass extermination of entire nations and peoples.
-
• The treatment of moral responsibility as a fundamentally collective matter. The supposed virtues and sins of a nation or people are ascribed to all of its individual members, so that, for example, one speaks of "the Jew" (meaning all Jews collectively and each Jewish person individually) being responsible for the decadence of modern culture.
-
So again, which mindset will produce children with higher IQ's? The whining, self-indulgent, entitlement chasing, blame-game, violence as holy climax and catharsis paradigm? Or the pro-active, can-do, keep your nose clean, take responsibility for your actions, positive-think business paradigm?
-
Biff Cappuccino

Sunday, February 06, 2005

Review of Race: the Reality of Human Differences by Vincent Sarich and Frank Miele (2004)

Don't know what I was smoking when I wrote the first draft of this review this morning. When I'm away from a given style of writing for a while, in this case, critical prose, I completely fuck it up the first time or so when I get back to it... So, I'm taking the bastard down and re-doing her.
-
Second Attempt follows (I only looked at the first fifth of it, if that much. I've got too much stuff on the go. No time!!):
-
Review of Race: the Reality of Human Differences by Vincent Sarich and Frank Miele (2004)
-
This was quite an interesting and well-written book, one that I will read, quote, and refer to again, without a doubt. But, first a couple of throwaway paragraphs, apologetics for having read and, even worse, enjoyed this profane work.

First of all, I have my doubts per the significance of IQ. So much in life depends on methodology. We all meet sluggish people who get along well in life by being steady, nose to the grindstone. We all meet fast maniacs who seem in a rush to dig their own graves. Slow can lead to pensiveness and focus, just like speed can lead to frivolity and shallowness. Along the way to watching a couple of hundred videos of authors being interviewed, I was surprised not to find any correlation between intelligence (or at least the intelligence required to speak well and not waste the audience’s time) and mental quickness. Acuity, at least that which works for writing, doesn’t seem to correlate with manifestly high IQs. Some writers of high-quality content-jammed, insight-infested books yet speak so damn slowly that I literally can’t suffer to watch them on video or listen to their radio interviews.

Another problem is the lower speed and probably lower IQs of the average urban Taiwanese vs. other urban Chinese around the region, Indonesia and north China in particular. Taiwan is the butt of jokes all over Greater China. I was mocked endlessly in Malaysia for speaking Taiwanese Mandarin. The slang in China for the Taiwanese is the replacement of ‘taibao’ (Taiwanese compatriot) with ‘daiboa’ (Dumb compatriot). And yet the Taiwanese are among the wealthiest and probably are the happiest Chinese in the region. And surely it is this often dimwitted happiness, due to the relative ease and simplicity of the local lifestyle, that doesn’t require people to be that smart. The same phenomenon can be seen in the English ex-colonies (Canada and the US for example. Simple, happy ex-colonists.) Are the IQs of these ex-colonists lower? Probably. But is their racial stock different? I doubt it. Environment, social environment especially, makes such a difference.

To the book: On page 24, the authors start pulling apart a PBS special entitled Race: the Power of an Illusion which promotes the PC message that race is a social contract. A social contract? Who would have thought? Who could have thought?

How does such nonsense gain currency?

Via the ambitious wordsmith. This species of academic takes a dubious pleasure in pushing and pulling at facts – in this case, the existence of racial characteristics – by claiming that skin color, hair type, facial morphology and so forth are only skin deep. In other words, skin deep is only skin deep and is therefore only skin deep and thus only skin deep.

I have little argument with racial characteristics having negligible impact on intelligence (they’re certainly not negligible with regard to sports, altitude acclimatization, immunity to disease, inherited disease, alcohol and lactose tolerance, etc.). But to claim that racial characteristics are in fact wholly imaginary; worse, a sort of deliberate ploy and endgame of a huge conspiracy of ignoramuses, such as myself, well that just leaves me flummoxed and tired.

Besides, why all emotional racket about inherited IQ? Most of what constitutes intelligence today is in fact just disciplined adherence to a methodology well-suited for our age of commerce and information overload. These methodologies are usually filched from someone else, mine certainly is: as far as I can determine it's a mongrel welter of Scottish/English/Greco-Roman/Philosophe methods and principles. All of this was pioneered by various high IQ genius and pioneers who cleared the way for the naive, the inert, and everyone else.
-
Take the genius of capitalism. It works great because it’s so simple. Even a moron, to cite a common exempler of the captains of industry breed, can run a corner store. Many morons do in fact and earn more per annum than many top-flight white-collar wage-slaves. So which person, if income is the arbiter of things and given that most of us work mostly for monetary ends, is the most intelligent when all is said and done? The corner store running philistine with a new Lexus or Yours Truly, getting wet in the rain on a second-hand scooter? I’m poor as a church mouse. I'm 40 years old. How intelligent, really, has my decision-making been so far?
-
Back to the 'social contract' hustle. Was I just dreaming the whole time? Or are certain professorial herds dreaming borrowed lavender dreams awash with the usual lofty rhetoric that deliberately defies parsing and which aims, given today's transformation of the victim into the morally correct hero (in effect beatifying failure and translating it into something reverential), to induce good feelings at the expense of common sense.

It's all so very familiar, in the eternal manner of the manufacturers of religions, patriotic slogans, and ideologies for the chic. 'Race as a social contract' becomes another preposterous entry into the cannon of ever-failing mirages and monkeyshines that respected professors drum into credulous students. Every season a new cannon of thought ends up peer-pressuring its way through the faculty, though not before a mess of doubtful blinking and trembling accompanies the fearful apostasy of departing the old faith, last year’s or last season's cannon. The formally overeducated emerge at the end of the day armed with a grab-bag of logical inversions and worthy slogans: i.e. fully conversant with what passes for this season's intellectual fashions, the new improved faith, the revealed truth. Until that same truth is falsified by next year's hirsute apostle and fellow traveler.

Organizing a faith, parochial or secular, is mostly got started by hawking rhetorical, theoretical, and ethereal goods in an effort to troll for herbivores, already lowing for a leader, their udders painful if not milked. To boldly mix metaphors: Having tickled the fish, one must get oneself into the saddle and ride herd. Inspiring belief, i.e. parochial or secular faith in the incredible, is mostly about fetching fidgety crowds with freshly-scented salvos of moving rhetoric: i.e. it’s about passing off the same old bill of goods but in new packaging. It's about lining up the modest blank-cartridges and proud stuffed-shirts that compose the majority of every population the planet has ever known. This crew of eternal followers and movement-joiners lacks the wherewithal and self-assurance required for pugnacious grappling with new ideas and new idea-mongers. For without putting claims to the fire, there is no way to distinguish between fact and fiction.

My point is: this book is essentially doing battle with academic cant: the cant makers, its franchises and account executives.

This is another book in which Stephen Jay Gould gets caught overreaching himself in polemic and founders horribly comfortably in the eternal American uplift. It's worth remembering that the uplift has been responsible for such prodigies as the banning of cigarettes on the theory that fags, as opposed to pipes, inspired masturbation and other citified debaucheries; plus Prohibition on the theory that just one sip of hooch and it's a straight tumble down to Gin Lane, beating the wife along the way. It also gave us the Drug War which operates on the theory that the sight of a pill of raw opium is a temptation beyond refusing which shall turn us all into Chinamen prostrate on teak beds, pipe in hand, the house triple-mortgaged, the children sold into slavery.

Stephen J. made a name for himself writing monthly articles on paleontology and evolution, spoiling good work by dumbing it down with baseball metaphors and personalizing it with anecdotes from the proletariat. But the formula worked and he blossomed from a young professor and writer in the wings, into the Lord of popular science and, finally, the avuncular Patron Saint of the field. He went out with a glow, and the glimmer of his ghost keeps marching on amongst us still. I used to be one of his biggest fans.

However, following the footsteps of many a successful Hollywood actor and actress, he began to feel his public duty: to lead the untaught masses to a New Canaan. Like many another Messiah, in the interest of truth, he promptly abandoned the facts. In the interest of leadership, he abandoned the aforementioned sense in favor of the aforementioned good feelings, lavender rhetoric, the technique of turning of unpalatable truths on their head and, most importantly, of righting wrongs by packaging them as rights. The masses can't be trusted to think on their own: this is the old left-wing do-gooder mantra, predicated on the healthy supposition, shared by both sides of the political aisle, that everyone else is stupid. The difference is that part of today's right wing, or, more accurately stated, the entirety of the libertarian wing, is in favor of letting people make their own mistakes in their own time on the theory that everyone is capable of learning. That's the theory.
-
The social contract nature of race, i.e. that race is an illusion (ex: Michael Jackson), was proven beyond a reasonable doubt on PBS via a panel of expert witnesses (i.e. high-priced, high-class fact-checkers) and the testing of mtDNA. On the PBS show, tissue samples were gleaned from the inside of the cheeks of several students. From page 24 of the book I'm reviewing: Then the students examined six selected mtDNA markers and used them to guess which other student's DNA would be most like theirs. The authors counter that the PBS experiment, in effect, stacked the deck. First, the number of markers used in the experiment was below the standard of 13 required by the FBI crime labs for even an individual identification. A good analogy would be political opinion polling. In order to get a valid result, the pollster must sample enough people.

Then the authors question why mtDNA was even used, when this is a form of DNA that only passes through the maternal line, thus not reflecting the potential racial characteristics of the paternal line.

Page 25: The usual pattern found in recorded history is that a small number of intruding males in a dominant position, either as powerful conquerors or rich merchants, mate with a much larger number of indigenous females. The top prize in this regard, perhaps, goes to Genghis Khan and his Mongol Golden Horde. One Y-chromosome study has shown that one every 200 males alive today, mostly in Asia, is descended from the great Khan.

This caught my attention because Mencken mentioned the same sort of thing back in the 1920s, offending readers yet again with a commonsense observation. In other words DNA can now be employed to demonstrate what was obvious to observers a century ago. Now, even that majority of liberal arts academia which is flummoxed and harried by information, facts and figures, schools of thought, politically correct shibboleths and other fashions of the season into chronically doubting its own senses can relax a bit. With the publishing of this book, as with the publishing of The Bell Curve, several truths are out. From the perspective of some, they've escaped, they're on the loose. However, all and sundry can take a breather, relax, take a load off. For the lightening rod is working.
-
For as usual with the liberal arts, truth has reemerged not due to the fearlessness of academia and its famed protections for the campus heretic, but because the majority of that supreme herd of pedigreed blanks long ago chucked up intellectual courage in favor of letting the occasional heckler up to the podium, pump an awkward truth into the air, and take his salvo of rotten tomatoes. With someone else scandalizing the audience and become infamous, the hacks can begin to state plainly, first double-checking the coast is clear, what has been obvious to even itself for ages.
-
In the UK, the best example of this in action that I can think of is best-selling amateur historian David (alleged holocaust denier) Irving. He stated decades ago that Hitler didn't order the killing of the European Jews, that Hitler's anti-Jewish bias was a political tactic to win votes. That Hitler's loony underlings commissioned the dreadful business. That Hitler, like Marx, like many other ethnic Germans from the south of Germany or from Austria, reserved his murderous contempt for the people of the Balkans. Well, after years of being attacked as a proto-Nazi by those who knew better, his peers in academia, guess who now agrees with his assessment? A growing number of his peers in academia, as a reading of pertinent book reviews reveals. (No one was more surprised to see this than me, I must say.) As far as I can tell, the major names conducting related reseach in academia were only bold when it became safe to do so. I.e. when European anti-Israeli sentiment began to peak during the late 1990's and newspaper-readers could now accept the false premise that denying Hitler killed the Jews was tantamount to being anti-Jewish. In other words, with the public's revival of racism, David Irving, an avowed non-racist, was now acceptable to the public.
-
On page 27 the author states, "the same ethical philosophers have shown much less interest in disabusing their readers off "the moralistic fallacy," that is, arguing that since, according to many moral codes, humans ought not be aggressive, rapacious, or prejudiced, therefore, we are not - the scientific evidence be damned. We have already noted the recent tendency of proceeding from what one thinks ought to be to what is. One corollary of the moralistic fallacy has been the argument that since "race" is really a social construction, and a very evil one at that, used to justify European colonialism and the enslavement and extermination of native peoples, the study of "race" inherently leads to "racism" in both thought and deed."

This illogical, feel-good or feel-bad manner of thinking is naturally most common in the serially dishonest. Being in the habit of trimming and hedging one’s own opinions, it is only natural to expect others to do the same. A lack of transparency, i.e. personal honesty and integrity, makes it next to impossible to challenge the ideas that these pathological types cherish. But this paranoid pathology is less and less mainstream. These days, the media increasingly aggressively attacks any and all received wisdoms and is more and more fact-driven.

And given the broad range of expression from the mainstream media to blogs, the very public success of respectable personalities such as Oprah Winfrey and Bill Cosby, the steady increase in interracial dating, and the exposure through Internet porn that penis size does not directly correlate to a woman's pleasure during sex, makes it seem quite unlikely to me that an open discussion of race would lead to racism. For that matter, Internet porn has led to a significant drop in the frequency of sex in many nations, Japan in particular for example. One of the long-standing causes of tension between blacks and whites in America was sexual. Now that many men derive sexual release primarily from Internet porn, and only secondarily from women, and the fact that anyone with eyes in their head can see that porn stars impaled on 14 inch penises still masturbate to beat the band, suggests to me that sex as a source of inter-racial tension is far less than what it was before.

Furthermore, the United States has come a long way over the last 400 years. IQs have jumped across the board in American schools (probably a result of TV, a savvier culture, and improved nutrition, and despite public education's decline) something upwards of 30 points since the end of WWII. These days, truth has a much higher value and esteem. Rhetoric, the opiate of the yokel, is in decline as evidenced by the growing popularity for nonfiction works, as opposed to novels. These days, the former is just as likely to become a bestseller as the latter. And, notably, biography has become a consistent best-seller. Much of biography consists in deconstructing glory and media spin, and in unearthing the dirt on individuals. This popularity is in part motivated by the already growing skepticism of the reading public and in turn reinforces and deepens that skepticism and embellishes it with understanding, pragmatism, and an Olympian mindset.

In other words, it is only the inert, untutored, and childlike mind which can accept the notion that race might inherently lead to the racism of yesteryear. And yet, it is precisely this mindset that one finds throughout humanities graduates. So much for liberal arts programs as finishing schools for ironing out the crudities of high school graduates. They're not even up to that challenge anymore.

Yet another example is the reaction of the US government to the 9/11 attacks. Within days, GW Bush visited a mosque to demonstrate ecumenicalism. That the United States would stop on a dime and return to the South of the 1960's seems so unlikely as to suggest that the advocate just wants to stir up the animals.

From page 32: in the case of race, the consensus view in contemporary social sciences that Western European culture, and it alone, falsely and self-serving constructed such a view of human variation and then imposed it on the rest of humanity until our minds were liberated with the advent of deconstructionism. An outgrowth of postmodernist philosophy, deconstructionism denies that any signs can establish ultimate meaning. It "deconstructs" scientific statements, claiming to reveal their hidden, underlying racial, sexual, and political biases.

In other words, the age-old trick of the media maven and politician: invent a bogus issue and propose to cure it via a bogus nostrum, in this case, deconstructionism. The latter is a remake in terms of its operating philosophy of the ancient inscrutable arts of Kabbalah, decoding Bible codes, numerology, astrology, animism and all the other failed worldviews and exploded eschatologies, bully-ragged and hunted to near extinction by the workers of the Information Age. Marxism and Communism were invented to save us from the evil of greed by a Messiah who faked his statistics and made mooching off others a well-paying life-long obsession. Christianity, a collective pilfering and 3rd century AD committee-edited welter of timeless Fertile Crescent myths, professes to save us from a devil which does not exist while it's conceptions of human immorality and wickedness reached their executive climax in that great success known as the Dark Ages. Adherence to Commandment Ten, thou shalt not covet, squelched European economies for a thousand years and continues to impoverish the votaries of Islam. Capitalism is founded on thou shalt covet. Which is why Great Communicator, GW, commanded the faithful after 9-11 to go shopping.

Page 72: the author points out that Stephen J. Gould, in his book The MisMeasure of Man, a history and polemic gallantly opposing what had already been defeated, racism, Gould points out that Samuel George Morton, a 18th-century researcher had botched measurements of cranial capacity employed to account for racial differences in intellectual ability. For example, Morton had written that "52 Caucasians skulls he measured had the highest average cranial capacity (87 in.³); his 10 Mongolians were next at 83; and 18 Malays at 81; 147 American (Indian) at 80; and finally 29 Ethiopians skulls at 78 in.³.

The PBS documentary states that his measurements more than "made systematic errors in favor of his assumptions" that whites should have "decided and unquestioned superiority over all the nations of the earth." Gould accused Morton of bungling. However, William Stanton, off the American school anthropology, concluded that Morton's measurements were "painstaking" and taken with "great care" to "ensure accuracy." The skulls have been re-measured recently as well and the errors made in measuring attributed to Dr. Gould, since called to his rightful place in Heaven, and not to Morton, who can presently be reached in Hell.

In other words because Morton's innocent pursuit of the truth might mislead the masses, a group inflammatory and unfortunately liable to orgies of bad thinking when granted access to the facts, Gould headed Morton off at the pass. He trumped up authoritative professorial opinions and juggled counterfactual facts, sonorously priming the pump of PC and greasing the pole of truth. In his own mind, he fought fire with fire, but to my mind, in so doing he reduced himself to the level of the professional patriot, the blathering pedagogue suspicious of his own teachings, to being just another tinpot Messiah gloriously leading a people he privately suspected were not worth the leading and who would achieve nothing worthwhile once they got there. In other words, more accidental comedy.

Anyway, time to wrap this review up. This is actually quite a good book, one that does not insult the intelligence of the reader, and which has the supremely ironical role of being a polemic from the fringe which argues for the accuracy of platitudes. Platitudes such as: there are differences between races, just as there are differences between individuals and these differences constitute larger differences than those which separate sub-species of chimpanzee or subspecies of gorilla.

What could be more obvious? Are there blond-maned chimpanzees? Ruddy-skinned chimpanzees? Chimpanzees with folded eyelids? And how could these exterior differences not be matched by interior differences, i.e. to the various organs, to the immune system, the skeletal structure, and so forth? Humans have prospered over a much broader range of territories and climates than the great apes and the historical success of our species as a whole has quite clearly produced varying physiology and morphology, just as it has with all other species. To deny that these differences could exist is tantamount to denying evolution. Either God make people in divergent forms or they evolved that way. And, evolution means change, means difference.

Unlike many, I do not believe that two wrongs make a right. Fibbing, whether minimizing or exaggerating, about racial differences is silly. Decision-making should be based as much as possible on facts and not wishful thinking.

And besides, what are people so worried about out? To suggest that in this day and age the scientific assessment of these differences would somehow lead Western society to a moral collapse and a revival of the barbarism of racial discrimination is tantamount to suggesting that all of the advances that have been made in terms of relieving sexual discrimination would be set back to Day One by a book revealing there are differences between male and female physiologies.

But is it really all that ridiculous? Hardly. I was a good student and swallowed much of the same reassuring blather at one time, and that time was not so long ago. Just a handful of years in the past. That a book is vigorously attacked (and it's chief author briefly in danger of losing his tenure at UC Berkeley) for attempting to demonstrate the truth of platitudes is surely an absurdity. But I suppose we can take solace in the fact that all other ages have had, and will continue to have, absurdities peculiar to theirs.

A tempest in a teapot. Life goes on.

Biff Cappuccino

Monday, January 31, 2005

I've been pulled back into the office this week, so the short story down below will have to wait to be stretched out and plumped up.
-
Have hung my shingle, or hoisted my petard, choose your cliche, at Writersnet: http://www.writers.net/writers/37755
-
Biff

Sunday, January 30, 2005

Firebrand (these 800 words of speech software inputted stuff are just the outline. The point is to churn out a story in two sessions of morning writing and then move on to the next story. I need to practice writing plots. Note to myself: create brand-new metaphors such as ‘birds swooping like burning rags, floating in the air like scraps of glittering white paper’ (unlike these two examples, the first is from Rick Bragg, the second from George Orwell)

"Are you ready?"

"As ready as I will ever be."

"Are you sure?"

He sighed, measuring his words. Thoughts, memories, phrases were running through his mind. But he calmed himself, and simply said, "yes."

The morning was chill, birds squawking, vehicles honking, the city up and about. He saw none of this, he kept his eyes closed. It was cold, and he felt colder and colder still, despite the rising sun, but he steadied himself. Soon, he too would be warm, hot, too hot for words. He sneezed, the smell of gasoline strong in his nostrils. Taking a couple of breaths, he began to feel woozy. He stopped breathing so deeply, slowing down. Calm was what he needed now to get the job done.

He asked the young man beside, Luwei the fellow protester he’d come to know well over the past couple of months, "Any sign of police?"

The young man was looking around. The old man could tell by the crunch of Luwei’s shoes, the gravel and grit of the square squeezed beneath his shoes. "Nothing! It's still early. Probably on their coffee break.”

“Even thugs need a break from busting humps.”

In a tone of concern, his voice lowered to a conspiratorial whisper, “Are you sure about this?"

"You needn’t ask. There is no other way. I have no where to go from here but forward."

He thought back to his early days protesting back in the countryside where he was from. His lazy country farm, with heated kangs, drying peppers and corn in the rafters, smoke swirling out from chimney. He’d envied others then, others whose children had gone off to the city. His children had stayed and then the neighbors had complained their kids never came home. For a while his existence had seemed idyllic. A whole family under one roof. Poor, but harmonious.

His land had been rezoned, and by using eminent domain, the county government had snatched it up and given him a pittance in exchange. Even this pittance, issued in the form of a check, was not redeemable. He was left landless and without a way to make any money. This had been going on for quite a while, and I had been a growing protest movement. He had originally ignored it, figuring that it cannot happen to him. Figuring that it was best that he keep his nose clean.

But it caught up with him. He joined the ranks of the protesters, tying a bandanna around his forehead, written with the words, protest! Protest! After well, you change this to "down with the and county government". At first it is that up with a cordon of police that kept him away from the County government headquarters.

And then, someone had the wise idea of contacting the tabloid paper located in the provincial capital. A couple of reporters shut up, wrote up a story, and it appeared as headline news of a corruption scandal in the county. Although the county contacted the provincial government and closed and a new story, there was still the matter is issuing revenge.

He was rounded up and. In the prison cell, it was demanded that he write a confessional statement. He refused, he was beaten, the urine leaking down his pants, the turd getting squashed in his shorts. His ribs were cracked but still he wouldn't talk. And in the end, the statement of confession and when he was released his family took care of him and admonished him not to get involved in political protest again.

After visiting the Beijing central government and not finding any satisfaction, he comes back home. His family is starving. his kids are in rags begging on the streets. His daughter is a prostitute. He goes down to the county government in a rage and complains. This time it's a real walloping torture treatment. He gets linked up to a car battery with wires and so forth.

So that it makes a decision to head to Beijing and make a grand statements. He realizes this is not an age for heroes, as there are no heroes in prison dungeons. This is not a time for grand statements as there's no free press. So, he makes a final decision to go to Beijing.

The clock struck 9 am. The city square was filling up with people, the crowd was growing.

The old man asked, "there's so many people. No police yet? That's ought." He controlled his breathing, to keep the fumes of his lungs as much as possible. To remain keen, aware, acute for the job which was to be done.

"They're coming!"

The old man pulled out his some of the distraction, and his heavy nickel plated lighter, as he popped open the top, it played "the red sun sets over China."

Saturday, January 29, 2005

Prologue to letter below: I get the feeling that I'm going to learn about Chinese history, not by limiting myself to the study of Chinese history and plowing my way through the banal output of various Sino-experts, but instead by locating competent books in other fields and applying the heuristics I find therein. And, if there are any decent books on any given subject they're going to difficult to find here in Taiwan given the low standard of partisan scholarship (in this case Chinese) and the few English works to choose from. It wouldn't surprise me if my jerkwater college in Canada has more English works on China (it has a shocking number actually) than can be found in the libraries of all of Taiwan's schools put together and yet my alma mater doesn't even have a department of East Asian studies.
-
Hi T: moving back to North America is indeed tempting, and I would take the idea seriously if only I had a notion of what I would do moneywise. Do you have any suggestions for what options would be available work-wise in the South or South-West for someone like myself? Clearly there's freelance translation here and there. But does anything else come to mind, other than Walmart?
-
As to reading, for me it's still difficult to find books worth the time, that actually have something to say and/or are presented in a captivating manner. The more I read and write, the more I find that style is not about style but more about content and it's intelligent presentation. At the moment, I'm mostly reading academic tomes in preparation for grad school here in Taiwan. Most of these tomes appear to be built around a few core ideas, usually filched, which are then worried to death and filled out with 300 or more pages of facts and figures which offer little insight into anything other than that the author read an impressive bibliography without really learning anything. The more I think about grad school, the less it appeals to me. I have a hard time imagining that I would agree with much of what my professors had to say after a few months of performing my own research. I have an even more difficult time imagining that the graduate students would be able to test my ideas and help me weed out the bad ones that, based on my experience, constitute at least 75% of my ideas overall. Darryl is already encountering various issues and I can only imagine his situation would be magnified several times over in my case.
-
On the other hand, sticking with the writing of fiction and essays gets me going, gets me out of bed in the morning, makes me feel good about myself and makes me feel like I'm doing something worthwhile. At first I couldn't stand writing fiction, then I got to see there was some room for fun with it, and now I'm into doing it wholehog.
-
Dr. Howard (i.e. T.S. XXX) was very generous and gave me NT$100k to sponsor my master's studies. But since cracking a few jokes about me being a cheap whore, I've come to realize that the metaphor is sticking a bit faster than I might like. The problem is I'm having second thoughts about going to grad school and I'm not going to take the good doctor's money and run. And yet that 100k has had a significant impact on my book purchases and so forth. This is part of the reason I'm poring through these academic tomes that I was complaining about above. Sometimes I feel like I should just give him the money back and get on with my writing life. Other times, I figure I should take the doctor's advice and do grad school because I'll be getting paid to do what I want to do anyway. Decisions, decisions, decisions.
-
By the way, came across a writer yesterday who you might also appreciate, Rick Bragg and his memoir: All Over but the Shoutin'. It's written in a sort of Mark Twain fashion, with lots of metaphors that work and a pace that keeps those with short attention spans in their seat. I've only read the prologue and a bit of the first chapter so far, but it appeals to me quite a bit for a variety of reasons. He gives a presentation as part of his book tour on C-SPAN:

If you're a fan of Norman Mailer:

Stay in touch,

Friday, January 28, 2005

Preliminary rough comments on Thunder from the East by Nicholas D. Kristof & Cheryl Wudunn.

The authors claim the Asian financial crisis left Indonesian villagers confused and vengeful, with the result that they ended up blaming traditional bad guys, i.e. sorcerers, for their problems. They called these evil doers ninjas and went around beheading them. From page 9:

"How do you tell who the ninja are?"

"It begins when people see someone suspicious and try to chase him. Sometimes the ninja turns into a cat, and sometimes he stays human. If he stays human, then they cut off his head." Sukiando paused, sighed at the thought of all the beheading that remained to be done, and added: "There are going to be more heads chopped off. Because in every little neighborhood, there are seven or eight ninja who go out every night, and they've got to be stopped."

It sounds like some quaint savage practice, some avatar sprung from the remote human consciousness of the barbarous prehistory of mankind. And yet, this nasty business seems awfully familiar. In Stalin's Soviet Union the sorcerers were called capitalists, kulaks, and counterrevolutionaries. Stalin ordered the execution of individuals in a similarly random fashion. In other words, modern monsters goosestepping to ancient rhythms. A certain percentage of each district's residents were deviants and subversives. Stalin would order the rounding up of, for example, 2% of the population of each district across the country and have them liquidated. Because local party bosses had no idea who the baddies were, they grabbed people at random. Boy Scout meetings, book clubs, what have you. Gathering in groups and associations made it easier for the police to make a conspiracy charge and also made for less trouble than grabbing people at home where the neighbors might intervene. According to Solzhenitsyn, millions of innocents died in these lunatic purges.

Ditto for so many other other socialist paradises. Mao’s ninjas were the landowners and Chinese Nationalists. Pol Pot's ninjas were the educated. If you had glasses, if you could read, off with your head or a bullet in the neck.

The methodology employed in Indonesia for determining who was a ninja is also reminiscent of the British witch hunts of the Middle Ages. The accused were tossed in a river. If you drowned, you were innocent. If you retained the natural habit of doggy-paddling, this was proof positive you were a witch. You were scorched at the stake under a pyre of flaming faggots.

On page 18: "Still, important changes can be pretty awful. In the West, the great depression produced not just Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal, but also Adolf Hitler and World War II."

I beg to differ. It was a generation of creeping corruption and the policies of President's Herbert Hoover and Franklin D. Roosevelt, and the spectacularly dunderheaded New Deal in particular which produced and sustained the Great Depression. The Great Depression was not the failure of capitalism, it was the failure of corruption and informed innovation, and finally it was the failure of America's first great attempt at socialism.

Take bank failures, which featured so prominently in that day and age. Not one bank in Canada fell during the Great Depression because Canadian banks were not restricted in how they did business. They were evil corporations, cabals of self-interest, commercial elites strangling the little guy. In the United States, to protect mom-and-pop banking operations of small country towns, congress, in it’s infinitude of wisdom, keeping its ear to the populist ground and watching the polls, did not permit large banks to move into rural areas.

In other words, government intervention; state protectionism; the boosting of local pride.

The result of these good intentions, of keeping large banks out of rural areas, was that when there were runs on these small banks they were quite unnaturally unable to draw on assets from other parts of the country. Why? Because they were small, local banks. Any idiot could have seen this coming. Small banks were already failing throughout the pre-Depression 1920’s at the rate of a couple hundred a year. Evil large banks, by virtue of being large, more efficient, better managed, and diversified, did not fail. Nevertheless, myriad small banks of unblemished virtue went bankrupt prior to the great test of the Great Depression. When the test came, they failed. Had the pious small banks not been protected, the evil large banks would have moved into rural areas and pushed out all of the inefficient in competently run chemically pure small banks. The result would have been that the nationally famous bank runs would not have produced nearly as many bankruptcies and perhaps none at all.

The New Deal paid farmers not to raise crops in order to enhance the price of farm crops. Of course, this made it more difficult for the unemployed who lived in cities to pay for food. Thus, the government had to pay out welfare payments to enable the urban unemployed to purchase the farm crops that were rendered artificially expensive by the policies of the same government. Clearly this is inefficient to the point of being idiotic. But this and many other damn fool policies were formulated by Roosevelt (who, born with a silver spoon in his mouth, despised businessmen) and the so-called Brain Trust.

The opening section of this book is weakened by this all too typical habit of reporters to cover a great many topics without ever developing a profound knowledge of any of them. Rather than retail in ideas, ideation and trains of logic are replaced with the usual sort of reporters stories and vignettes to humanize the situation, to demonstrate the author's oneness with the people, to demonstrate to all that they feel the pain of humanity.

An excellent example of this is the reversion to received wisdoms when the author discusses China. For example on pages 26 and 27 the author writes, "Why did the West triumph over the East in the last millennium? For most of the last thousand years, Asia was far more advanced than any other part of the world. In that time, it would have seemed far more natural that Chinese or Indians would dominate the world in the year 2000 than that Europeans would."

However, the Chinese Empire did not compete with or encompass any democratic state during the last 2500 years. This is naturally quite different from Europe's history which sported a number of democracies such as ancient Greece, ancient Rome, those of many Germanic tribes, and all through to the modern age there's been partially democratic rule and a relative degree of freedom of expression in one part or another of Europe, within the various city states of the Middle Ages for example and so forth. This has been critical to modern intellectual development, movement which has led directly to modern prosperity and technological development. Thus though China was often more advanced technologically, it was retarded in many critical areas such as democracy, freedom of speech, rule of law, and so forth.

2500 years ago, ancient Greece had trial by jury. The heroes of the Icelandic sagas, of the Norsemen, were lawyers, not warriors. The Icelanders invented an ingenious legal system which let the free market set the price of fines and other penalties. And given that the dominance of the state over the individual was far greater in China that in Europe, it is hardly a surprise that free-market economics, democracy, free speech, and so on and so forth developed in the West and not in Asia.

On page 28, the author compares the vast scale of the Chinese fleet of Admiral Zheng He with that of Columbus. The former has 28,000 sailors on 300 ships whereas Columbus had 90 sailors on three ships. But this is an error confusing quantity with quality. Throughout history, in the realm of the military, democratic nations have consistently defeated autocratic nations with far smaller armies. This is because democratic armies to be of much higher caliber. They fight much harder, have far fewer deserters, and tend to be much better informed and intelligent in their combat because of the greatly increased flow of information throughout the ranks which comes about via traditions of freedom of speech, the stress upon individuality, and the greater degree of informality between men and social divisions.

Admiral Zhengho may have had a great number of men under his control, but at the end of the day it was only himself and perhaps a few advisers who made all the major decisions. However, had this same vast fleet been split into 30 fleets of 10 ships each, much greater by way of exploration, discovery, and diplomatic works could have been achieved. What the Chinese expedition suggests to me is the perennial folly of state rule and weakness in the face of societies whose norms stress individuality and personal freedom. Columbus did not need a fleet of 28,000 sailors to make the first announced modern European discovery of the American continents. Nor did he need 300 ships to drop maps, navigation charts, and returned to Europe to spread the news and inspire a whole new era of discovery, economic growth, national expansion, and so forth.

On the other hand, due to an inauspicious thunderstorm in Beijing, there was a change in heart with regard to exploration. The fleet was shut down and the ships destroyed. Further exploration was banned. Incredible? No. Typical. The state had been in charge from start to finish. Had the exploring been performed by private entities such as Columbus, with the state keeping its fingers out of everyone's business, there would have been other individuals who, just like Amerigo Vespucci and Captain Cook who would have continued exploring the maritime world and eventually discovered Europe and America for China.

Again, China's problem is the problem with monolithic states everywhere and key to the problem of socialism everywhere as well. When the state gets involved heavily, it squashes private initiative, directly or indirectly. The US Post Office filing legal injunctions against Federal Express when it first got going is a perfect example of how the state fights free enterprise when it finds it's own interests threatened, the body politic be damned.

Thus I'm not impressed when the author writes, "The treasure ships had luxury cabins with balconies for the top officers and for foreign princes who would be brought home, and these ships were backed by specialized vessels including horse carriers, troop transports, cargo ships, two kinds of warships, and water tankers carrying drinking water. The crews included 10 translators, five astronomers, 180 doctors and pharmacologists to treat the sick and gather foreign herbs, and even to protocol experts to ensure that Chinese treated foreigners just a proper degree of politeness.

The sophistication of the fleet underscores how far the East used to be ahead of the West."

I think he has it completely backwards. Columbus was able to sail freely, something Chinese sailors could not do. He had a whole range of legal protections that Chinese captains did not have. He had a superior tradition of record-keeping which is why we still have the records many of the early explorers had. Not so with China because the records of the voyages were deliberately expunged, wiped out. Forget freedom of speech. All that proceeded from these explorations, all that wealth of knowledge, wiped out at a word from the palace.

Also, Columbus could engage in free trade. He traveled not only for glory, but also for personal profit. And the profit motive is a very healthy one in my view. Trade outside of China's borders was highly restricted and indeed at one stage of the 17th-century all Chinese residents along the southern coast were forcibly removed and brought inland several kilometers to prevent trade with various entities deemed dangerous by the central government. Was the power of a government in a position to do so impressive, or is it a sign of how absolute power corrupts absolutely? After all, eliminating trade, also eliminated interaction, which must've held back the country's development quite a bit. Not to mention impoverishing people who had made their livelihood of the ocean for generations.

Was it important that the Chinese admiral Zhengho had luxury cabins with balconies for his top officers? Is it important that he had water tankers carrying drinking water, or is it simply important that he had sufficient water for his trip? Translators would have been useful to Columbus, though all the wealth of Europe would not have enabled him to procure one. Noone in Europe spoke the Carib language. He did not require a herd of astronomers because he was capable of piloting his ship himself. I do not know whether he had doctors onboard, but I'm sure he had people on board with a knowledge of general pharmacology as this was usually the practice with expeditions. And Columbus did not seem to need protocol experts as he and his crew managed to have a great deal of sex with the Carib Indians while he was there.

My point is not to belittle the achievements of the Chinese Empire of the day, but simply to attempt to persuade you that quantity is not a substitute for quality, and that excess quantity does not amount to an improvement over quality.

The author also gets carried away with the larger scale of Chinese cities, forgetting how many times Chinese cities were sacked and demolished due to insurrections, serial famines, and the civil wars that broke out with every collapsing dynasty. The city of Nanjing, for example, suffered large-scale massacres in 1867 and 1912, for example, not just in 1937 at the hands of Japan's Kwantung Army.

China is also alleged to be "more... cosmopolitan than any place in Europe." My grasp of European and Chinese history is weak to be sure, and yet I immediately associate cosmopolitan with the latter Roman Empire, the Carthaginian empire, Byzantium, Moorish Spain, the Holy Roman Empire, the Ottoman Empire, and so on and so forth. Sixth century England, a European backwater at the time, had an amalgam consisting of the original tribes (many of whom still spoke their original languages), Scots clansmen, Roman citizens, Angles, Saxons, Danes, Jews, Christians, and animists, and other pagans. Backward it was, but if even England has this level of mixing, I find it hard to believe that the various empires on the continent were not even more cosmopolitan. Not to mention the fact that the Chinese Empire, like other empires, was vigorous about assimilating and erasing local cultures.

Anyway, that's all for now. I've got a lot of catching up to do.

Biff Cappuccino
Thoughts on Hooligans and Thugs: Football's Most Violent Fans

"Well that's it for now. Did you learn anything? Probably not. See you later." These are the closing lines from the documentary Hooligans and Thugs: Football's Most Violent Fans. But actually, I did learn something from watching endless, to the point of boring, scenes of mob violence at soccer stadiums around the world.

It was interesting that the hooligans did not intend to hurt people, at least not seriously. In general, people gave a couple of kicks and moved onto the next victim. Once one person started kicking somebody, his friends joined in for a few dirty shots. And then they moved on like a cloud to the next victim where they swarmed and provided a similar drubbing. If anything, it looked like a video game with the object to score as many points in the shortest time as possible.

After the first shock of watching violent morons bash each other, the various mêlées started to take on a pattern, a very familiar one. After a few minutes I began to snicker, and then to laugh. I’d realized that the object was to incapacitate people, not hurt them seriously. A measure of this was that almost no one was carrying prepared weapons. The only implements of destruction consisted of junk snatched up onsite. People were ripping up the stands and throwing parts of the seats and other things at the enemy of the moment: police, bystanders, journalists, or fans of the opposing team. Seats and chairs were flying through the air as were water bottles, bits of wire fence, shoes, flags: this clearly is comedy, more the equivalent of a food fight and less mindless tragedy. And it’s quite different from smuggling in knives and black jacks and going at other people with injurious or lethal intent.

Also quite obvious was that most people didn't know how to fight. People took long crazy swings, gave gangly kicks. Rather than unify fist and body in the way that a boxer might, these people were tossing fists at the ends of arms which crumpled at the wrist, the elbow, the shoulder, and so forth. Most of the energy that they were trying to throw out was absorbed by their own bodies. The evidence for this, beyond the visible clumsiness of the pugilists, was that most people, after earning their beating, got up promptly and scampered off.

The fact that few people have died over the years demonstrates this. Massive numbers of people are involved, but serious injuries are few. The point is not to kill people, it's not even about revenge most of the time, it's simply about being a hellion, cutting loose, and having fun in the manner of a junior high school game of what my school used to call British bulldog. It's just about getting out and about with the lads, getting some exercise and getting off in a physical way, achieving that climax peculiar to sports and other physical exertion.

I suspect these mobs are populated by bored dudes holding regular jobs and who don't have much by way of hobbies. They're bored, lack much for exercise outside of lifting a beer stein to their mouths or wacking off in the shower. Here they get excitement, physical exertion, and camaraderie.

Once you've been in a fight with your friends, and your friends have stuck with you (as one sees time and time again in these videos), they become mates you feel you can really trust in a tight spot and with you have a visceral and spiritual connection, a low-budget edition of the connection that police and military people talk about. You're no longer a group of potentially and even probably fair weather friends. Friendship is no longer tentative or probationary; it's been tempered in “combat”, so to speak.

And I put worry quotes around combat because, after all, most of the soccer hooliganism seems to be more theater than anything else. Watching people bait others, shout and shake their fists, charge forward halfway to meet an enemy group and then back off to the safety of their own crowd, suggests that they are not really interested in hurting one another. What they want is the equivalent spicy naughtiness of a panty raid, a food fight, a hockey rink bout of socially approved fisticuffs.

If someone had killed a member of your family and you wished to avenge it, would you stand in the road shouting, railing your fists, charging halfway towards the object of your anger? Though this is what these mobs do, time after time, country after country. No, you would go directly for the person who killed your relative and try to kill him or her. You'd be of one mind about it, possessed. I've been in that sort of situation, although what prompted me was jealous love as a teenager. You’re blind with rage. You don't care if you live or die. You just want the other person dead. It’s ridiculous. It’s insane. And it’s not exemplified by the soccer hooliganism in this video.

Also noteworthy is the phenomenon of hooligans running so easily when pursued. They run because they enjoy being chased, not because they're cowards: in the same way that kids squeal with pleasure being chased while playing tag. The hooliganism in this video is not about cowards ganging up to feel safety in numbers when abusing individuals, it's about ganging up to maximize the ability to disperse oneself and avoid being caught once the police or the enemy crew start chasing you. It's no fun if you get caught for sure, or if you get caught too easily. It’s only fun if you get caught just once in a while for then it’s easy to maintain the façade of danger.

As a child I led a small collection of vandals, call it a gang if you will. We bought sling shots and went out and beaned construction workers and rent-a-cops around large construction sites. At one point, close to my home there was a huge drainage project being constructed which reengineered miles and miles of the local stream bed. The whole point of hurling marbles at the employees was to get them to chase us. I never hurt anyone. I wanted to be an annoyance. I took no pleasure in hurting people. As a member of this gang, I never even fought anyone. My friends enjoyed beating up people, but even then it was not about hurting anyone, simply about teaching wimps a lesson, making them stand up for themselves, getting them to act with self-respect. A sort of educational theater.

Per corollary, I would not be surprised if fans from opposing soccer teams in the UK or elsewhere, after the game, and after beating the crap at each other, could meet up in non-politicized circumstances (ex: overseas in Thailand) and be friends, respectful of one another for having the "guts" to beat each other up in public.

Furthermore, you'll notice that the crowds enjoy not only being chased by the police, but also charging the police. In other words, taking the game to their opponents.

The occasional excess where people get killed or are left in comas or are otherwise permanently debilitated is probably because some people cheat at the game. This game, like any other game, has people who will try to get unfair advantage. It is these people who come with weapons, explosives, fireworks, and who break bottles and attack people with glass and so forth. Of course you also get people who simply lose their temper and go berserk. But I would expect, although I have no forensic evidence to back it up nor any practical experience participating in soccer hooliganism, that it's probably not very common. That the occasional person being on the wrong end of real violence is what makes the news, suggests that the general tone of soccer hooliganism is playful. You just have to understand that people head butting, kicking and punching others can be a form of roughhousing that is recognized by both sides of the equation as playtime.

The pain of being struck violently is greatly overrated in the press, as anyone who's been a serial willing victim of violence (ex: boxers, martial artists, wrestlers) will attest. When the adrenaline’s running, pain functions as a measure of your tactical situation, your martial readiness, your mechanical functionability, and is not a determinant of whether you fight in itself. What matters is not pain, but are the eyes clear, are your muscles fatigued? Is your breathing relaxed and are you mentally cool and acute? Or are you charlie-horsed (temporarily incapacitated due to neural malfunction in your muscle tissue) and under stress? When people are that excited, they don’t feel much pain.

Anyway, I'm just trying to understand the phenomenon. I don't advocate it, not because it's politically incorrect, but because intelligent people surely have more interesting and productive things to do in their majority. They grow out of this stuff quickly. If you really wish to prove your manhood, get in the ring. That works fine, while guaranteeing you emerge in one piece and don’t have to spend the night in a jail cell.

Biff Cappuccino