News & opinion on Greater China and the even Greater Beyond: by Biff Cappuccino.

Sunday, April 03, 2005

Bernard Goldberg's Bias: A CBS Insider Exposes How the Media Distort the News.

This book opens up with an excellent quote: When it comes to arrogance, power, and lack of accountability, journalists are probably the only people on the planet to make lawyers look good. - Steven Brill

Bernard Goldberg put in 27 years as a reporter with CBS News where he flew his own television investigative journalism series.

I learned the hard way how unreliable the media can be via researching the AIDS epidemic which seemed oddly absent here in Taiwan. Goldberg does a whole chapter on how the media cynically magnified AIDS into a best-selling welter of fear, completely unwarranted by the facts. Remember the media frenzy over SARS, the latest incarnation of the 1917 flue epidemic? Many if not most of the SARS victims in the Free World died due to the botched immune-suppressant therapy prescribed by the World Health Organization. Of course death by bungled injection didn't scrape up much news, nor did the many pathetic victims in Hong Kong who died slow deaths over the following several months due to unstoppable bone deterioration caused by the WHO's very same therapy.

After running a news website for a year, and watching reporters consistently highball statistics, botch even the simplest addition of figures, play up victimization at every possible turn (the BBC has the worst tear-squeezer of them all, a female with a great vocal impression of the Adam's Family's butler Lurch) write advocacy journalism whose articles included facts that clearly defeated the reporters opinion on the issue at hand, I grew annoyed and eventually quite contemptuous of reporters as a class. Naturally there are must be some reporters who shine, but outside of David Brooks and Chris Hitchens, none other come racing to mind.

The following is a grab-bag of self-explanatory quotes from his chapter on the calculated fumbling of the homeless issue:

(Page 65~71) No one knows exactly how many homeless there were in America in the 1980s and early 1990s, but there were researched, educated estimates. For example, the US Census Bureau figured it was about 230,000. The General Accounting Office of Congress put the number between 300,000 and 600,000. The Urban Institute said that there were somewhere between 355,000 and 462,000 homeless Americans. These numbers weren't state secrets. Reporters knew what they were. They just didn't care.

Meanwhile, the homeless lobby was putting the number of homeless in the millions. No matter how bad a problem really is, advocates think they need to portray it as worse.

We have come to expect this of advocates. They know their cause is worthy, so what harm can a little exaggeration do? But reporters - when they also see the cause as worthy - buy into it. They also become advocates. They take the numbers as gospel. They have no desire to look too deep, because if they do, God forbid, they might find something they'd rather not find. There's an old saying in the newsroom: don't let the facts stand in the way a good story!

So in 1989 on CNN, Candy Crowley, a fine, serious reporter, said that "Winter is on the way and 3 million Americans have no place to call home."

3 million!

Not to be outdone, in January of 1993, Jackie Nespral, the anchor of NBC Weekend Today, said, "Nationally right now, 5 million people are believed to be homeless... and the numbers are increasing."

5 million!! And the numbers are increasing!!!

Charles Osgood of CBS news, one of the most talented journalists in all of broadcasting, reported, "It is estimated that by the year 2000, 19 million Americans will be homeless unless something is done, and it done now."

19 million homeless by the turn-of-the-century!!!!

And Ray Brady, one of the best in the business, who was reporting for the CBS evening news, found homeless people who actually lived in homes. These were - ready for this? - the "hidden homeless."
Who are they? People who aren't homeless at all, but, because they can't afford their own places, are living at home with Mom and Dad, often in cushy houses in the suburbs with big-screen TVs and three squares a day.

"Of all the lies that are swallowed and regurgitated by the media, the ones that hurt the most come from the good guys," Kathryn Dunn wrote in the New Republic in 1993. "The grassroots do-gooders, the social work heroes, the nonprofit advocacy groups battling for peace, justice, and equality."

Did anyone, least of all seasoned reporters who pride themselves on their skepticism, really believe that the vast majority of the homeless - the addicted and the mentally ill - would virtually disappear from America's streets if only Ronald Reagan hadn't cut housing programs?

Scott Schuger, a Washington journalist who wrote a piece in the Washington Monthly - "Who are the Homeless?" - certainly didn't. In a monument to common sense and politically incorrect wisdom, Schubert wrote, "There can be all the low-cost housing in the world and an untreated paranoid won't set foot in it, and an untreated schizophrenic might burn it down... and a drug addict will spend the rent money on crack."

When the "proper" victims are involved, we become journalists/social workers. And we live by the journalist/ social worker motto: afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted.

We know who our viewers are. We know what they look like. And we know that they would be drawn more to stories about homeless people who looked just like their mothers and fathers and sons and daughters than homeless people who look like, well, homeless people.

But to do that we first need to go to central casting and get just the right kind of homeless people on the news. White was better than black. Clean was better than dirty. Attractive was better than unattractive. Sane was better than insane. And sober was better than addicted. So when the TV people went looking for just the right kind of homeless face to put on the news programs, they went to people like Robert Hayes, who ran the National Coalition for the Homeless in New York.

In 1989, Hayes told the New York Times that when congressional committees in TV news producers contact him, "They always want white, middle-class people to interview."

Walter Goodman, who writes about television for the New York Times, came up with a name for what we in the media were doing. He called it the "prettifying of reality."

[He wrote] The reasons for the choices are not obscure. If you want to arouse sympathy for the homeless, you cannot put forward offputting specimens. Television news producers can count on advocacy groups to supply them with model victims for viewing purposes, people who may even be untouched by the other afflictions discovered in...[a] survey of the homeless: mental illness, AIDS, domestic violence, and lack of education and skills. And why should a producer focus on one of the 50% of single homeless people who have served time in jail when he can just as easily find someone without a record.... the result is a prettifying of reality.

Saturday, April 02, 2005

Parting comment on Ian Buruma's excellent Inventing Japan

MacArthur’s remark in 1951, that in terms of modern civilization the Japanese were like a 12 year old boy, was typical of his thinking. The context of this remark, made to a joint committee in the US Senate, is worth repeating. MacArthur is comparing Japan to Germany. The Germans, he said, where a “mature race.” The Japanese were still in “a very tuitionary condition.” Science, culture, and religion were as highly developed in Germany as in other Western nations. The Nazi poison could be drained from German society without changing German culture, which had after all produced Luther, Beethoven, and Goethe. The Nazi regime had been a perversion of German culture, its leaders had acted brutally in a deliberate attempt to dominate the world. The Germans did not have to be tutored in the ways of another civilization. (MacArthur did not mean this as a complement; in his view the Germans were all the more despicable because they should’ve known better.) The Japanese, on the other hand, had behaved like the children they were. They had, in MacArthur’s version of events, “stumbled” into militarism because they didn’t know any better. This also implied that the Japanese, in the immature state, were still flexible enough to improve under firm and fair guidance. (Page 133)

Ian Buruma does not seem to agree with this assessment of Macarthur’s, perhaps due to multiculturalism, but I have to wonder if there’s not actually quite a bit that Mac got right. One doesn’t emerge from feudalism into a modern, fully developed democracy overnight has in Buruma has plainly demonstrated. The sort of sincere pure-spirited suicidal assassins that he mentions seem like something out of the dark ages or out of an early Muslim era whose zealots gave the English language the word assassin. This plus the barbarism of the war, the factionalism, emperor worship, etc. Unless we play politically correct games and accept that my ancestors in skins worshipping druid gods and torching human sacrifices in wicker cages were mature civilizations on par with the maturity of the developed nations of today, then we might as well call a spade a spade. As such, I don’t have any problem with Mac’s saying the Japanese were immature as a civilization then. No doubt, this remains accurate even today. As it is with regard to China which is held together by the PRC regime (thus preventing a potentially dreadful civil war and economic collapse) but also held back by the regime intellectually and institutionally thus keeping the nation’s civilization in a state of enforced immaturity.

An example of this in modern day Japan is the decision-making by consensus, a feature that appeals to the peaceably minded as civilized and harmonious. But actually it’s a reflection of retarded (i.e. immature or undeveloped) decision-making skills. Thus, the seemingly endless series of Japanese prime ministers over the years faulted for being spineless and incapable of either forming decisions or sticking to them. Surely this is the product of a socio-cultural construct: a traditional responsibility-dodging slave mindset (Taiwan has this in spades) featuring the remarkable absence of its opposite in the political sphere, the master mindset. It would appear (and I claim nothing but ignorance about Japanese elections) as if Japanese voters do not support Alpha male candidates and, given that the national culture produces an overwhelming majority of citizens with a slave mentality (a comment the more perceptive Chinese writers have labeled the Chinese with for a century or more), Japanese democracy is incapable of functioning efficiently. This I would guess is perhaps because the elected representatives of the majority slave-mentality citizenry are themselves too timid and herd-like to forge decisions. I suspect that consensus is never forged either. Too active a verb. Too aggressive a word-picture. More like consensus appears by default by virtue of the players giggling or peeking at everyone else and playing a game of political musical chairs, trying not to be the odd one out; like fish shoaling or sheep flocking together, correctly presuming that for the meek to inherit the earth, safety lies in numbers. I’ve seen this in action first-hand in Taiwan. And I’ve been guilty of it myself. It puts a new spin on Mencken’s definition of a politician as an animal that sits on a fence and yet has both ears to the ground.

Friday, April 01, 2005

Part three of my never ending review of Inventing Japan, by Ian Buruma

In China, Chiang Kai-shek's army was moving north in an attempt to unify the nation under a nationalist government. The Chinese saw Manchuria as part of China; the Japanese, despite earlier treaties to that effect, did not. They preferred to see it as a kind of lawless no man's land, to which Japan would bring order. Since Manchuria had been part of the last Chinese empire, which lasted for almost three centuries, the Chinese had a legitimate claim. The fact that large parts of China were lawless did not give Japan a right to take them over. (Pages 88, 89)

Manchuria had been part of the last Chinese empire, that I can go with, but the last Chinese empire was not run by the Chinese but by the Manchus. The Manchus were not Chinese, despised the Chinese as cannibal scum, and established a caste system making the Chinese literally third-rate citizens of their own country. Chinese were banned from marrying Manchus on pain of death. Chinese were banned from moving into Manchuria until the last decade of the 19th century.

As to Japan not having the 'right' to take over parts of China, this presupposes that there is a body adjudicating and enforcing sovereignty. For otherwise, there's no point in talking about rights. Rights can not exist outside of enforcement. It would be like getting hot and bothered talking about your rights with a burglar pointing a crowbar at your brainpan. It's pointless unless there are cops around. Given that there was no body to adjudicate and enforce sovereignty, then talk of rights is futile. Whoever could take over the lawless territories did take over the lawless territories. End of story.

And Chiang Kai-shek was hardly a representative of China as he had yet to conquer the territory from the present legal owners, various warlords. What distinguishes his rights from theirs? Force. Might is right. At the end of the day, it always has been and always will be. (Democracy survives not because it is just, but because it produces the strongest economies and most powerful military force. In other words, democracy is an excellent example of how might is right in the political sphere.) Chang Kai-shek even as the unifier of China was not representative of the Chinese given the fact that he was not a democratic ruler. You might as well pretend that any of the emperors ever represented the Chinese people. (We’re back to people’s emperors again…haha…) The people were owned by their emperors. Chiang Kai-shek enjoyed the most promising run at becoming the new emperor at the time, vying with Mao the eventual usurper of the throne.

Had the Japanese taken over Manchuria and retained it, the present day occupants of Manchuria would be living under Japanese democracy and enjoying a very high standard of living indeed. It seems to me to be a prejudice arising from victor's justice to imagine that the colonization of Manchuria by the Chinese was somehow preferable to the colonization of Manchuria by the Japanese when clearly Manchuria was doing much better under Japanese rule prior to the second world war (it enjoyed the highest industrialization rate within 'China' and the highest standard of living, leading to a huge flood of immigrants (for lack of a better word)) and given that the situation would have no doubt continued that way had Manchuria either remained Japanese territory or somehow remained a province of the Republic of China. Unfortunately it is part of the People's Republic of China. I do not doubt Ian Buruma’s bona fides. But he appears inadvertently to believe that the present day Manchurian population is properly the property of the People's Republic of China, what he would probably call citizens of the PRC. After all, a democracy is owned by its citizens as opposed to authoritarian regimes which own their citizens. (You can imagine how well that last sentence went over when I presented it to a bunch of PRC forum participants a week or so ago...haha...)

Within six months, much of Manchuria was in Japanese hands. The Chinese complained to the League of Nations. And the Japanese duly cranked out propaganda at home about Japan being victimized by the rest of the world. (Page 90)

Isn't that a beauty? The Japanese propagandized the Japanese. This is the kind of slippery doublespeak that rightfully belongs to the oeuvre of my latest ethnic impersonating hero, the late Eddy Said. Who the hell are ‘the Japanese’? What on earth is ‘Japan’?

You probably think I’m nitpicking, but this is just the sort of prose hell from which so much sulfurous patriotic bologna emerges. Ex: We Chinese were humiliated by England. That’s a classic line of peacetime patriots with poor social skills and angry with the developed world because they have a McDonalds but not a girlfriend. Most of the Chinese population lived right through the Opium War without ever knowing it took place. They sure didn’t watch it on television. Most of the population consisted of illiterate peasants living in medieval boondocks. No newspapers. Nadda. And how can ‘we’ be humiliated by events that took place before ‘we’ were born? Etc, etc, etc…


Following the maddening quote above, the book continues with: The prime minister at the time of the Manchurian incident, Wakatsuji Reijiro, was still a party politician who favored a conciliatory policy toward China. He was in the state of panic. The Kwantung Army was pushing Japan toward war, and there was nothing he could do about it, since military affairs were beyond his brief. The Army and Navy ministers in his cabinet were answerable to the Emperor as the supreme commander of the armed forces, but not to a mere civilian prime minister. The foreign minister, Shidehara Kijuro, was also an internationalist who tried to maintain good relations with China and the West. He was now in the invidious position of having to defend a fait accompli in Manchuria, caused by military officers over whom the civilian government had no control. The Emperor was advised by nervous courtiers and chiefs of staff not to antagonize his armed forces, lest they rebel and create disturbances at home. In a complete abdication of responsibility, the opposition party, the Seiyukai, criticized the government for not being belligerent enough. Meanwhile, Japanese troops began to move into Manchuria from Korea. The prime minister resigned.

His successor, Inukai Tsuyoshi, was no more successful in disciplining the military in China. He tried in vain to withhold official recognition of Manchuria as an "independent" state… Inukai, like his predecessor, was a pathetic bystander in these events. He appealed to the Emperor to intervene, but nothing happened. After one more attempt to stop Japanese reinforcements from escalating violence in Shanghai, Inukai was gunned down by Navy fanatics in his own house.

This is the sort of irony which makes history so fascinating for me and so frustrating for peacetime patriots who want to pretend that Japan is a person which beat up on another person: an old lady called China.

…Many of Japan's problems were the result of weakness and divisions at the pinnacle of the system rather than strength. Far from being a united nation, Japan was ruled by factions, in the courts, the military, the bureaucracy, and the diet, which fought one another with almost as much zeal as they displayed toward external enemies. (Page 91)

And this appalling infighting is typical of authoritarian regimes. According to Victor Davis Hanson’s Carnage and Culture it’s one of the reasons why authoritarian regimes, despite their typical appearance of strength during peacetime, are usually fragile and quite inferior in battle against democratic regimes which tend to look weak during peacetime but which unite during war and become much stronger.

Ian Buruma frequently talks about the purity and sincerity that various young men, assassins usually, were obsessed with and how it was usually met with a very positive response from the public. I'm wondering whether purity and sincerity have to do with animism. Purity and sincerity are reminiscent of British and Amierican Puritanism, bluenoses and bluestockings. Such morons believe there is a right way to do everything. All other options are morally wrong, i.e. heretical, and their proponents heretics. That’s were the witch burnings and assassinations come in.

Animism and Christianity are both conspiracy theories positing imaginary armies of good against imaginary armies of evil. Buruma mentions that most of these morally pure assassins were from the countryside, thus it's understandable that they’d view simplicity of mind as a virtue as opposed to the modern view of simplicity as a weakness as a sign of a simpleton. In developed countries one aims not for purity, but for impurity by way of multiculturalism and cosmopolitanism. The goal is to become urbane (i.e. of the city). Not rustic. Quite the difference.

From page 105: An American chaplain in Tokyo's Sugamo prison, where Japanese war criminals were held after the war, concluded from his many interviews that they 'had the belief that any enemy of the Emperor could not be right, so the more brutally they treated their prisoners, the more loyal to the Emperor they were being.'

Anyway this book is a great read and if I keep stopping to comment on it I’m never going to finish reading it. So that’s it.
Review of Inventing Japan, Ian Buruma, Part II

Little more than a year after that [1930], Prime Minister Inukai Tsuyoshi, who was trying desperately to keep radical Army and Navy factions from going to war with China, was murdered by a group of naval officers, called the Blood Pledge Society, in an attempted coup d'état. Two business leaders were killed as well, while other fanatics were bombing such symbols of right-wing hate as Inukai's party offices and the Bank of Japan. By then, the experiment with party government was over. Manchuria had been turned into a puppet state. And the war in China was only just beginning. (Page 76)

I quote this in passing because I'm often frustrated by patriotic morons on Internet forums who blame Japan for invading China. Given that Japan is not a person, but instead a block of real estate or a social collective or what have you, 'Japan' cannot be blamed for invading 'China'. Various individuals in Japan orchestrated various actions against various individuals or the collective masses in China. Call it an invasion if you want, but at least don't clog up the conversation by blaming an entity that lacks the ability to make choices and thus can't be blamed, i.e. 'Japan.' You might as well blame clouds for raining or ants for the architecture of their ant hills.

Kita's family background was neither xenophobic nor particularly romantic.... from an early age, Kita was seized by the ideal of absolute individual freedom. But the question of people's rights was too tame for him. In fact, he wasn't interested in peaceful politics at all. He was after absolutes and violent acts of will. As it did many Japanese idealists of his age, individualism confused him. (Page 77-78)

That last sentence sounds like comedy, and yet in contemporary China this is commonly the case. In part it's because idealism and patriotism usually results in the opposite of individualism: fascism. After all, all idealism is essentially a function of ignorance and stupidity as idealism is ipso facto the desire to bring into reality desires which are not pragmatic. Most peacetime patriots are simply unsuccessful lonely men with inferiority complexes who can't get laid. Such people are relatively easy to deal with because at least their patriotism is cynical. When the wind blows in the wrong direction, they scatter like quail, looking for a new cause such as victimization, reparations, entitlement, etc. You can often follow the money trail to the blank where their conscience should be found.

A different problem is people who take patriotism to heart, true believers blessed with handsome mugs and untroubled well-adjusted souls. For these natural-born messiahs, individuals are never as attractive as the people as a whole. Concepts being more attractive than touchy, persnickety unmotivated wrong-way individuals who tend to be imperfect, uncooperative and to get in the way.

Revolutionary violence, for Kita, was not so much political as religious, an act of personal, spiritual liberation.... the state, he argued, had been hijacked by corrupt oligarchs, bureaucrats, bankers, and industrialists. What was needed was a coup d'état that would give the "People's Emperor" absolute power. ... Kita’s cause had a particular appeal to junior officers in the Army, were mostly from poor rural areas and, like Kita Itte, blamed capitalist city slickers for corruption and degradation of the nation. A number of these men, burning with violent idealism, staged a coup in February 1936, aiming to give absolute power to the Emperor and purge...traitors and corrupt officials. (Pages 78-79)

People’s emperor? Truth odder than fiction yet again. Seems China tried that concept with Mao. Let One Hundred Flowers Bloom, The Great Leap Forward, The Cultural Revolution…hmm. Jiang Zemin’s MBA-sounding “The Three Represents” lacks the rhythm and timbre of a good Little Red Book slogan, but then it’s bound to do much less harm. A dumb politico is usually the safer bet if you have the best interests of the nation's people in mind.

While reading Gavin Daws Prisoners of the Japanese I had the sneaky feeling that a herd of bumpkins were running the Japanese military. This helped explain the peculiarly childish cruelty of the various wanton mass slaughters, the romantic desire of young soldiers to emulate samurai by butchering defenseless people with swords (i.e. becoming comic book heroes via slashing everything that moved with glorious traditional weapons), the often fabulously amateurish nature of the medical experiments (transfusing horse blood into people), and the almost laughable (if it wasn't so tragic) traditional boorishness of Japanese officers chowing down on the livers of white POWs. Again, if you ask yourself what frame of mind it would take for you yourself to willingly do the above, surely it would be the frame of mind of an eager child with a yearning to dress up in adult roles such as hero, doctor, etc.

Not to mention that China's Guanxi Province saw Communist mucky-mucks chewing on the livers of upwards of 600 political prisoners during the Cultural Revolution. "Samo, samo!" as Japanese POW prison guards used to say.
Call me a slow-learner but it turns out that Edward Said was the Rigoberta Menchu of the Middle East. His parents were American, not Palestinian. He grew up in Egypt, not Palestine. His folks property was burned by an Egyptian mob and what was left was stolen by the Egyptian government, not the Israelis. Etc, etc, etc...

Well, Judd and I could never go for the master's inscrutable meandering prose. He's as patent a fraud as Michel Foucault. No one smart writes that poorly without good reason: the defensibility that elastic prose provides. Great camouflage. When writing is so deliberately clumsy that you can't nail the writer's meaning down as A without risking the real possibility that he might have been coyly hinting at B or providing an allegory for C or playing charades to indicate D and possibly the rest of the alphabet, with the Zodiac thrown in, then you have a style that's so loopy that you can reinvent meaning and intent whenever the growling of the critics gets too close for comfort. I smelt a rat right from the get-go of Orientalism.

Not sure which is worse: right-wing US politicians pretending to be racial supremacists (Lyndon Johnson, George Wallace, and Strom Thurmond) or left-wing intellectuals (Farley Mowat, Ward Churchill, and Noam Chomsky) goading us to feel guilt and pretending to suffer like Jesus on the Cross for sins that none of us could have committed unless one believes in guilt by association, psychic transportation, and is a Buddhist and believes in reincarnation and responsibility for former lives.

There are links to the two excerpted articles below. Enjoy.

The headmaster showed me the pre-1948 student enrollment records, and I spent hours going through three leather-bound enrollment ledgers, page by page. To my astonishment, I found no mention of Edward Said. A second time page-by-page through the same records, and I found no evidence he was ever enrolled there. ...Several months of extensive research made clear that there was something fundamentally wrong with the picture Said presented of himself - that of a Palestinian exile/refugee deserving of reparations from Israel. (link)

Is it not curious in the extreme that Said, while on record as remembering the "rooms [in this house] where as a boy he read Sherlock Holmes and Tarzan, and where he and his mother read Shakespeare to each other,"[65] has nowhere brought to mind the presence upstairs of the Yugoslavian consulate, the comings and goings of visa-seekers, diplomats, and politicians, including for a time the king of Yugoslavia himself, or the arrival of limousines and their elegantly attired occupants for official functions like the annual Yugoslavian independence-day reception? On November 29, 1947, the very night the UN voted in favor of the partition plan for Palestine, and a couple of weeks before he has told us the Saids were forced to leave for Cairo, this reception was attended by no lesser figures than the British-appointed mayor of Jerusalem;[66] Golda Meir, then director of the political department at the Jewish Agency;[67] Hussein Haldi, the secretary of the Arab Higher Committee;[68] and most of the city's social and political elite.[69] (link)
A special C-SPAN program features conversations with three Army soldiers and a Marine about their personal experiences in Iraq and at Walter Reed Medical Center. Additional conversations take place with the Commander of Walter Reed and a we take a look at physical and occupational therapy for injured soldiers. Almost four thousand patients from Operation Iraqi Freedom have been treated at Walter Reed since the war began.

Thursday, March 31, 2005

Inventing Japan, by Ian Buruma (incomplete)

An excellent book of Japanese history written in an accessible novelistic style, offering distilled concepts, facts that stick to your ribs, and stimulating word pictures that bring the old days back to life.

The prologue closes with: "Overconfidence, fanaticism, a shrill sense of inferiority, and a sometimes obsessive preoccupation with national status - these have all played their parts in the history of modern Japan... but one quality has stood out to serve Japan better than any other: the grace to make the best of defeat." (Page 7)

He doesn’t write this but to me the arrival of Perry's Black ships in 1853 was not just the forcing open of Japan's economic doors but the kick-starting of free trade. In other words, not a nasty imperial incursion but instead a liberation of the marketplace which benefited everyone (by which I mean the average man on the street) but the authoritarian regime which, like all authoritarian regimes, preferred monopolies and big trusts. Like China’s Opium War, this was the beginning of the end for the bad old days of feudalism, caste, and summary capital punishment and the first baby step towards democracy, egalitarianism, and rule by law.

During the glory days of racialism "Once a year Dutch merchants were summoned to Edo, where the Shogun and his entourage would pump them with questions and, for their amusement, ask them to sing songs, dance, kiss one another, and generally perform like circus animals." (Page 16) "The popular image of the Dutch was that of exotic beasts, who lifted their legs, like dogs, when they relieve themselves. Their hair was red and their eyes a devilish blue." (Page 15) "... a faint suspicion of treachery hung over those who show too keen interest in foreign matters. The authorities - and most scholars, too - took the line that although Western science might be a useful tool to rule Japan more effectively, foreign thinking should be kept far from common minds, lest the people get "confused" and forget to obey their rulers." (Page 17)

All of the former sounds much like contemporary China. So does the following: "Von Siebold received a map of Japan, and Globius (a Japanese scholar of Dutch learning) was given a naval map of the world. As soon as news of this exchange leaked out, von Siebold was arrested for spying and later expelled, while Globius died in prison three years later, possibly by his own hand.
Another unfortunate scholar was young man named Yoshida Shoin, who was so desperate to learn more about the Western world that he begged Commodore Perry to take him back to America on his ship. Perry refused. Yoshida was arrested for embarking on this adventure and locked up in a cage. His teacher, Sakuma Shozan, who had developed theories, based on his Western knowledge, on the best ways to defend Japan against foreign incursions, was imprisoned for encouraging his people to study overseas. He wrote a famous treatise, entitled Reflection on My Errors. After his release, he was murdered by anti-Western fanatics for riding his horse on the European-style saddle." (Page 18)

"A popular saying in the late 19th century was "Chinese learning for the essential principles, Western learning for the practical applications." In fact, it never really worked in China. Western learning couldn't be reduced to mere technology without gross distortion, and the old Sino-centric principles were hard to reconcile with scientific inquiry. This is why Chinese thinkers since the 19th century have tended to lurch from selling conservatism to violent iconoclast. Either the Chinese tradition, whatever it was supposed to be, had to be defended against the merest speck of foreign pollution or every vestige of it had to be smashed in the name of science. The history of Communist China is an illustration of both." (Page 20)

An excellent example of a description masquerading as an explanation. What better explains the swing to me is that the Chinese worldview was never underpinned by much logic. Given the lack of free speech and free debate, research was near non-existent, talking points few, and critical thinking skills very poor. There was no broad and deep body of empirical findings underpinning the conclusions that scholars arrived at. Thus, it became easy to swing from one school of thought to the next.

Take racism Chinese-style. The strong prejudice against blacks can be overcome with a smile and a few words of Chinese. I've seen it happen again and again. A western racist would have a logical framework underpinned by evolutionary theory and a myriad of talking points and counterpoints to fend off arguments for equality. He would have scientific literature dating from the antebellum south on to the Bell Curve of the 1990’s at his disposal to quote from and make his case. Such a person would take time to persuade, if they could be persuaded. The average Chinese racist on the other hand if asked why they don’t like black people will tell you that it’s because they’re black. You say, “What?” They say, “Because they’re so dark.” If you probe further, you find peer-pressure. That’s it. No science to debunk. No urban legends to refute. No conspiracies to explode. That person can be persuaded or dissuaded of racism rapidly. And not just racism.

This also helps explain the success of fascist dictators in Italy, Germany, Japan, Russia (Stalin) and China (Mao). Illiterate ignorant mass populations lacking liberty and freedom of speech, and thus lacking the ability to form intelligent decisions on their own were naturally susceptible to conspiracy theories (racism, xenophobia, and religion being just three of a large and fertile population) and used to turning over decision-making to Great Man frauds, in part given that they formerly were habituated to turning decision-making over to sundry Great Mojos in the sky and their temporal agents, the various priesthoods.

Another historical parallel with China is on page 70: "The Japanese rioters [of 1905 protesting the Portsmouth Treaty which concluded the Russo-Japanese war and which gave various concessions to the Russians at the behest of the European powers], in fact, behaved very much like their Chinese counterparts in 1919, who protested against their government for letting Japan take over the German concessions. When governments rule without popular representation or even consent, one form of rebellion is to be more nationalistic than the rulers. If the rulers are traitors to the nation, they should be overthrown. It is a pattern that has occurred over and over again in East Asia, and it is not very conducive to liberal democracy. It also shows that demands for political rights at home can exist quite happily with imperialist demands abroad. But this is a game that both sides can play; the authorities can turn nationalistic sentiments against the Liberals, too, and frequently did."

From page 74: "One of the worst instances of Japanese brutality toward Koreans came in the aftermath of the earthquake that devastated Tokyo and Yokohama in 1923. The whole city began to lurch violently around lunchtime. Within hours, much of Tokyo was burning. Wild rumors spread as swiftly as the fires: foreigners had attacked Japan with an earthquake machine; Koreans had gone around poisoning the wells. There was nothing much people could do against "foreigners," since they were comparatively few, but mobs did go around killing Koreans, drowning them in the Sumida River or beating and trampling them to death amid the smoldering ruins. One person who tried to protect them was Yoshino Sakuzo. He also did his best to revise the low official estimates of the Korean death toll and arrived at a figure near 2000."

Amazing the power of primeval conspiracy theories in Japan as late as the 1920’s, which helps explain the primitive savagery of the Japanese Army in China and WWII. And of course the 'poisoning the wells' business is right out of the European Middle Ages and the Black Death when some populations blamed Jews for doing the same. Reinventing the wheel historically speaking. Another spin on Santayana’s ‘those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it’.

C-SPAN recently aired a special on U.S. soldiers wounded in Iraq and the treatment that they're getting for their injuries. You can access the video for the full show on our Iraq page. And each night this week, we're airing the full interviews we taped with each of these soldiers - one each night through Friday night. (Biff: Worth checking out here)

Wednesday, March 30, 2005

Shitbird (another practice session in third person narrative)

Verne Wedeatter looked around his room, wondering if things had improved with the move. He was all set, but lonesome.

The pad they’d given him was three floors, fully furnished. But it was cheap-jack playschool furnishings in mini-sizes most of it. He’d already replaced the day-glo banana vinyl sofa that stuck to a sweaty back like a leech and made a sucking slurpy noise as you got to get up. It had had these acrylic tables that looked alien, outer space, like the Jetsons or Captain Kirk. And the concrete wept in the top floor when it rained, the paint peeled in the stairwell, rebar was bloating like a rust sponge and pushing out of all the walls like tree roots. Darg Yotsfah, his construction engineer buddy blamed it on salt in the concrete. “Like dressing salt into a wet wound, ain’t going to come to no good.” He’d said.

At times like these, a-wondering and a-whimpering to himself, he farted in defense. Something to build his confidence. To set him right again and put his old world back in order. A gush of greasy gastric essence was getting pumped into the cushions of his new cloth and cushion love seat to mingle and ferment with the clusterfuck of flatulence he’d injected into all the seated furniture around the room. An inoculation of sorts was how he thought of it, one that kept ratbags and uppity vermin at bay. And if a man had gas, well he might as well put a talent like that to good use.

He picked up the phone and hit a button, angling with his thumb to get it right. Boink!

“Yar?” someone drawled lazily. “That you Bass?”

“Don’t call me that no more. Shit dude!” in his best attempt to be firm.

Verne wasn’t a fun name, so his friends did the next best thing and started calling him Weed Eater or W E and still did when he got something right. The rest of the time it was Big Ass Shit Sucker, a walking-talking four on the floor verbal testimonial to his God-given endowment. It was Bass for short. Weed Eater thought they were dissing him, but actually they were hiding their envy behind mockery. W E (pronounced ‘Double E’) didn’t go for low-class stuff like firing up butt-farts with a lighter. He had discipline. Timing. Panache. He was a class act and they knew it. Double E was lonesome and jonesing for pals today so he went back to whimpering, “So what up? You boys doing what for this afternoon?”

“Bass, yo, like I don’t know. Whatever. Like, I’m still on the job. Got some slopes out on the wire, hooking up some high tension cable. They’re up in the basket. I got no time to think. I got jaundiced baboons making my life a mother, you know what I’m saying? I got my hands full as it is. I’m too tired to think about what to do when I get off.”

“Your brain’s tired? It sure don’t take much.”

“Yeah.” He wheezed. “How about you, Bass? You sound like your hair’s gone and git tired again. Or what can I do for you boy?”

“I don’t know. I don’t got me no more teaching for today. Just bored I guess.”

“You need a woman. You know that?”

“You ain’t saying nothing that I don’t already know.”

“Yeah, alright. Well, you still teaching at that cow town college? What kind of shit for brains is they hiring that they take you under their wing? Sympathy for the devil.”

“The foreign devil. Yeah you said it. But I don’t mind. Money’s good. Easy.”

“They even speak English there?”

“Yeah. Not bad. I was worried they might even learn me a few things and get wise. But so far so good. Riding the China gravy train baby.”

“Huh!”

Yackety-yackety-yak.

Later that afternoon, having whacked off to what pitiable soft porn he could find this side of the Great Firewall of China he found himself exhausted. Pin-ups needed imagining to work and imagining wasn’t one of his strengths, not part of his job requirement. He was five-finger shagged and fagged and not getting no satisfaction.

He wiped himself up, the smell of yellow-bean oil making him nauseous. There was something wrong about the smell of fried food dripping off your pecker and trying to get off. Couldn’t figure that one out.

He meandered in the direction of the shower, cold feet on colder tiles, naked and trying not to drip nor put his polluted hands on anything. The moist air of this crazy place wrapped him like a blanket, like one of them punky diseased blankets they gave the injuns to wipe ‘em out. Sympathy made him think he could use some firewater himself right about now, but first he had a damn itch to scratch. Dang it all! But if he didn’t break out in the itchy-scratchies when he went and whacked a good one. A good one being a couple of hours searching around for today’s just-right hottie with a familiar sort of face, down on her knees looking at a loving meat machine with shock and awe. He peered south and saw that he had hives around the base of his tool, but he could feel his butt-crack going for broke too, and the skin between his baby toe and the camper next door was just ripe with heat. He pulled them apart and looked closer and beside the skin peeling like surgical gloves he saw a welt rising out like a red flower, round like a Mickey Mao good luck coin and the color of one of his momma’s Christmas poinsettias. Shoot dog! Not again! “I gotta give this shit up,” he muttered as he turned the hot water on and reached for the carbolic soap. “Owe!” he whined as he rubbed it in.

When he came out he fired up a smoke. He liked his air filtered. The doorbell rang. He opened it to find Darg and Buddy Dorckbagg. Happy and Happier. He beckoned them in and walked back to his couch flatfooted. He dropped his towel to dry himself and said, “You two faggots aren’t going to get excited are you, or do I got to call the pole-lease.” He farted a tight one, squeezing it slowly to make it last, to make a good impression.

His two guests frowned, trying not to smile. Impressed yet again with Bass’s natural gift.

“Yeah like them crazed gorillas is going to do nothing.” said Buddy, swaggering with a sharp eye to make sure it was approved. “You remember what happened last time? Shit that was something.”

“Well yeah a-hole, it was something. ‘Cept you wuzn’t neven there.” He stared hard at Buddy from across the room. “You been telling my story ain’t you and lying to say it was yours, ain’t that right?”

“That aint true! You cain’t prove it! And even if you could, well…”

“Well what Dork?” asked Darg, getting a rise out of Buddy’s dumb-assed try at defending his-self. Dumb Ass.

“Well, a feller might as well get some extra mileage out of it. I’d share stories with you if I had any. Aint’ nothing wrong with that.” He was sheepish but friendly. Like a cuddly house pet he won them over. Just like he always did.

“So what was this story anyways?” asked Darg.

Bass had been drinking and driving, common enough and on a bicycle he wasn’t going to kill nothing more than time. But there he was and there they was, on the street corner waving him over with a beating wand, the pole-lease. Snatched him down rough and fetched him over rough to the station without so much as a please and thank you. The chief came to the door to see him in person, smiled sweetly and said “Hello American.” And then whipped out a pig sticker and whacked him a good one on the Thai kick boxer’s sweet spot, that nerve running down the outside of the thigh, dropping him faster than a cow-tipper dropping Holsteins on Halloween. Bass was begging for mercy and caterwauling for Jesus while the chief was hee-hawing to the high heavens. The chief put his mean stick back on his belt and pointed to a couple of his men to haul the fat foreigner inside.

But Bass got up on his own and released a foul burst, a gusher, silent but deadly. He felt better already. The cops had gripped him warmly but then getting a whiff thought better of it and pulled out their sticks and prodded him like a ripe bull into the chief’s office. There were the usual utility bureau and leather chairs, the cork-stoppered hot water bottles and jam jars with floating tea-leaves like trapped kelp, but there was also a ledge of sports trophies and a couple of American university pennants.

The chief spoke, “So my friend. My American friend. This illegal in America no?” His English was shockingly good for Guanxi, provincial backwater of the Chinese boondocks.

“Sorry?” Bass was standing.

“You beg my pardon?”

Cold-cocked by the question, he didn’t know what to do but agree with whatever the chief said, “Yes” he said, and bowed and flatulated a squeak.

The chief glanced in the direction of the lobby. Seeing nothing, he began again, “Okay. I tell you. Drunk driving is criminal offense. You no drunk drive in America. Why you drunk drive in China?”

“But I was on a bicycle,” he stammered

“You have no respect for China law! Behave! Insult China and we give you buggar all! You want buggar all?” asked the chief, coming closer and looking up into Bass’s eyes and screwing up his scariest smile.

Bass was about to wet himself when instead he parted with another blast of methane. The chief sniffed and asked, “You shit your pants, mister?” But this West wind seemed to knock the East wind out of the chief’s sails and he said, “American! My friend! You wait a minute.”

One of his compatriots said to the chief in Chinese, “I heard Westerners smell like shaggy dogs, but now I know it’s not true. He’s fat and white like a harvest pig but smells like a water buffalo.”

“This one is particularly foul. Too much red meat. Milk products. Freedom fries.”

“Didn’t the Japanese dwarves eat Western prisoners of war in the Great War for Emancipation? How did they stomach the rough smell?”

“Japs are a coarse crew of mad monkeys.” Patting his tummy, “Everyone knows that Chinese liver is the best. It’s written by the ancestors. In the old days, the cannibals hated the whites and blacks and loved the Chinese.”


Darg frowned, “You’re putting me on. They didn’t really say that?”

Pointing just his middle finger at his temple, Bass said, “Scouts honor. They didn’t know I speak the Chinese.”

“How good?”

“Near good as my English.”

“Huh!”

“Hey! You got any beers around here?”

Yadda-yadda-yadda.


He met her teaching English, spelling out words on the blackboard that he’d just been practicing himself right before class started. He was up mashing a black ink marker against a white plastic board and she was seated in the back by her lonesome, an empty ring of seats about her like a wooden garden around a bronze statue. She was pretty, long dark tresses, clear skin, shapely, all packaged in a white outfit like a nurse’s uniform. She was a noisy one, kept asking questions, making him nervous.

Why couldn’t they just be like kindergartners, not asking no nosy-parker questions except ‘can I go to the bathroom mister?’ Childrens learned fast. He taught them ‘mister’. He learned them ‘kids’, saying it ‘keeyids’ to make it down home and authentic. And when they came at him, squealing with feral joy and running headers at his balls, he was ready for them with a perfume that kept the little grifters at bay.

So he was surprised when she stayed behind after class to ask a few questions and in between his stammering discovered that she had an eau de toilette of her own. He felt safe now. He cut the cheese with a buzzing wheeze that fluttered his pants and she snapped out a hanky for him fast and proper, figuring he was suffering a nasal malfunction of some kind. It was a tender moment, one preserved in mental amber for the rest of their natural born lives. She said her name was Little Plum. He said his name was Weed Eater. Verne Weed Eater.

They wined and dined. He took her home.

She was a nurse after all. Working in the geriatric ward. That explained the ripe aroma. Bed pans and 24/7 rip-roaring wind gusting out of human pipes. Oily Chinese stir fry made flatulence stick like crazy glue to anything with pores in it. She couldn’t scrub it out her skin in less than 24 hours. Couldn’t rinse it out of her hair in less than three days. Clothes were best burned. He’d traveled twelve time zones and found someone else that smelled like shit. It was a miracle, a great day.

They moved in together. They made plans for the wedding. He invited the boys over.

He opened the door for Dork and Darg. Happiness and Ha-Penis. Dork asked, “So where’s the pretty lady?”

“Yeah. Where you hiding her, you devil dog?” followed Darg.

Bass motioned for them to sit down while he fell back into his loveseat. He said, “She’s getting dressed for work, boys. In a bit of a rush. My fiancé is a working woman, don’t cha know.”

Dork nodded and said, “Well them Chinee is that way.” He was being respectful now. He’d arrived shaven, was sitting upright, on his best behavior.

She rushed out of the bedroom, saw the boys. She pulled, looking concerned. She said, “Hi. Heard lots about you.” She gave a little nod, a smidgen of a bow.

“Howdy m’ am,” Dork tipped a non-existent hat. Darg nodded at her and then cuffed him.

“Your friends are here early. I got to go soon.” She looked hesitant, needy.

“Sure honey.” Bass was wondering what was up and smiled blandly, getting comfy, pulling his newspaper off the table and to himself like a security blanket.

She looked at them and then dived under his newspaper and pulled it down behind her. She started snuffling about his private parts. She sucked and sucked, pulled and squeezed, coaxing his seed out of him. He gave it up willingly, huffing and puffing behind his newspaper, the boys across on the sofa, eyes popping, trying to keep still, to keep the evaporating sofa aromas, somewhere between raw liver and road kill, in their place.

Little Plum looked out from the bottom of the newspaper, like checking that the coast was clear. She came out fully now, wiping the back of her hand across her mouth. She went to kiss Bass, red and splotchy porky in the face. He met her with a peck on the cheek, the touch football of love. She grinned. He didn’t want the boys to think he was queer.

“See you later. Got to go. Nice to meet you.” And she was off, the Florence Nightingale of the crypt ward, the dead beat, the geriatric sayonara.

She skittered out the door, giving it an earthy slam that left their ears ringing.

Bass squinted and said, “I’m training her about that. She’s learning not to slam stuff.”

Darg barked, “What the hell else you been training her?”

Dork was incredulous, awed, “What in the great jeewillikers was that which I just seen?”

Bass patted his forehead with the newspaper, leaving a grey patch behind, but what he felt he really needed was a great body wipe in the shower. He said, “You know how the locals want jet black hair. Auburn means you is tainted. Maybe not pure blooded. I told her for her personal information that hair was mostly protein. A protein injection regular would give her the coal color she wanted.” He was nodding trying to get a nod reaction out of them.

Dork said while frowning, “You didn’t?”

Bass batted an eye and looked down modestly and put his hand up making the injun sign of How! and said “Don’t tell me I’m sly, ‘cause I did it out of the pure goodness of my heart. Just being helpful.”

“Landsakes alive! Hoodoggy! You devil you!” Darg burst out laughing. “This calls for a beer to celebrate. You got any beers? It’s damn drier than a West Texas Sunday.”

Bass got up and walked slowly, shaking the stickiness out of his butt cheeks, and the sound of a balloon maker swiveling high tension skinny rubber against itself came from somewhere in there. He was home. He had it made. And not lonesome no more.

Tuesday, March 29, 2005

Tentative Study Plan proposal for grad school :

I grew up in the United Kingdom, West and Central Africa, the United States and Canada. After earning a bachelor's degree in history from the University of XX, I came to Taiwan in 1987. In 1990 I began to teach myself Chinese and have worked as a translator since 1993. Over the years I have been employed primarily by XX but have also performed translations on behalf of The Golden Horse Awards, The Taipei Film Festival, and The Ministry of Education. Over the past four years I have vigorously pursued an amateur interest in writing and completed a memoir, two novels, numerous essays and book reviews. Two years ago I operated an amateur East Asian news web site (www.eastcathay.com, now defunct) for one full year, updating online news six days a week. During the summer of 2004, I served briefly as a volunteer assistant to Democratic Progressive Party Legislator, the honorable XX. In the autumn of 2004 I married R.O.C. citizen XX.

International relations is a prominent interest of mine given my residence in Taiwan and the constant friction between the Republic of China and the People's Republic of China. To facilitate my understanding of the causes of this friction, I have read up on the social and political history of Taiwan and of China, and also dabbled in military history, cultural anthropology, media studies, economics, and other fields. Naturally, having a working knowledge of these and other fields is critical to making informed decisions about developments in relations between the ROC and PRC.

If admitted to your program there are several fields I would like to study. For example, I would like to research the effect of information suppression, urban legends, and official propaganda upon the formation of PRC foreign-policy.

Restrictions upon freedom of expression lead to an absence of required information flowing through needed channels but also to a widespread ignorance of history, a dearth of open debate, undeveloped critical thinking skills, plus decision-making which is vitally out of touch with reality. Without free speech, urban legends continue unchecked and decisions are formed on the basis of everything from hearsay to traditional almanacs and cult worship. Official propaganda strives to propagate popular belief in imaginary enemy states such as Japan and the United States and actively cultivates popular racialism and xenophobia.

A February 8, 2005 article in The People's Daily claimed to scientifically prove aspects of Chinese racial superiority and reasserts the validity of Lamarckian genetics (a theory abandoned by most since the appearance of Darwinian genetics). One can laugh at this and other articles but many are taken quite seriously by many people, including presumably many foreign policy decision makers. Evidence of this is that Jiang Zemin and other leading officials pay big money to be the first to pray at temples during Chinese New Year.

Conspiracy theories, junk science, etc. are used to explain such events as the accidental bombing of the PRC embassy in Belgrade. The result is a profound misunderstanding of the democratic policy formation process in such entities as the Republic of China and the United States, not to mention the presumption of conspiracies controlling power and making policy decisions in both.

I would like to research PRC conspiracy theories with regard to their impact on international relations. I would also like to trace PRC conspiracy theory formation from its various roots (the most important of which I believe is animism) and then move up to the expression of conspiracy theories at the policy level and trace their impact upon PRC relations with the ROC and the US.

In short, this and related topics in international relations are fascinating and I believe that your program has much to teach me about the international relations field and about conducting related research. In turn through hard work, integrity, and innovation I can contribute to the good name of your program. I thank you for considering my application.

Monday, March 28, 2005

Prisoners of the Japanese: POWs of World War II in the Pacific, by Gavin Daws, 1994. (incomplete, but I got to get some zzz’s)

First of all, an excellent book that will be repeatedly pulled back off the shelf to do active service. Full of ideas, anecdotes, stories that get to the point and aren’t redundant. Fast-paced, gripping, intellectually stimulating, and despite the temptations attendant with the ripe subject matter, to his great credit he’s impartial. A less informed or eclectic writer, in a bona fide attempt to be impartial, would have been boring.

Page 21: “Psychological concepts such as post-traumatic stress disorder and survivor guilt were never in the heads of POWs in the camps, and were not available to them in their postwar lives. The way they saw things - the way they still see things - is this: as POWs and they did what they had to do, and afterwards they had to try to live with it or it would destroy them.”

There’s a parallel with today’s China where suppressed speech prevents the spread of, among other things, critical thinking concepts. This is one of the reasons there are so few common points of reference when speaking with the peacetime patriots. They don't understand sarcasm or wit, neither of which were encouraged during those knee-knocking times of political correctness known as the Let One Hundred Flowers Bloom, The Great Leap Forward, The Cultural Revolution, The Three Represents, etc. And patriots, already privy to the arcane truth, spend all of their time trying to win arguments not trying to learn anything through debate. Those in the know have nothing to learn.

One of the dizzying ironies confounding the present herd of Chinese patriots is that many aren’t in favor of democracy or free speech. They’re only in favor of some nebulous concept called ‘China.’ If China didn’t need free speech in the past to be great, why does it need it now? Free speech is a Western trick. Surf the forums where Chinese patriots lurk, like bridge trolls, if you think I’m making this up.

Living in a world of slogans, and not concepts, they’re inert and can only learn from the past that which they’ve already been taught. In other words, history has nothing more to teach them than the mind-bogglingly little (mostly cartoonish at that) which they’ve managed to absorb. Thus peacetime patriots don’t want free speech because it didn’t appear in Chinese history. Puts a new spin on the cliché that those who don’t know history are doomed to repeat it.

Their unwillingness to take free speech seriously, due to lack of Chinese precedent, prevents them from understanding the power and ramifications of free speech. They dislike western books and are thus incapable of hearing, let alone believing, that democratic armies fight better than the armies of traditional autocrats. So they pray for a war that their nation can’t win. More doomed to repeat history….

To get back on subject, what makes this book particularly good is that "when I paraphrase, when I have to compress scores of prisoners utterances on a given subject into a few lines, it is always the POWs view of the POWs life that I am trying to convey: not only what they thought of what happened to them, but their way of expressing it.... Political correctness was not in their thinking either. At the time they were taken prisoner, the Armed Forces of the United States were still segregated; African-Americans were not even blacks yet, they were coloreds, niggers. For the British, in their own famous phrase, Wogs (meaning lesser breeds with a touch of the tar brush) began at Calais.... as for the enemy, the Japanese were fucking Japs, Nips, yellow bellied bastards... crazed gorillas, jaundiced baboons, monkey men. That was the language of the racial world the POWs lived in. What was racially true for the POWs in the years of their growing up in the years of their captivity is set down here in their words, in their tone of voice.”

Both sides saw the other as uncivilized and half-human before the war began. It makes one wonder if the multicultural aspect of political correctness doesn't have its merits when dealing with people who have no first-hand experience with foreigners. It's probably better to have them mindlessly believing every culture has equal value than having them mindlessly believing all cultures are different, for the latter leads to valuating cultures and inevitably placing one’s own as most superior.

“... some of these manifestations are so clear as to register on the written page, fifty years later, as nothing but clichés. The Americans were the great individualists of the camps, the capitalists, the cowboys, the gangsters. The British hung onto their class structure like bulldogs, for grim death. The Australians kept trying to construct little male-bonded welfare states. ... I would go so far as to say that it was nationality above all that determined, for good or ill, the way POWs lived and died, often whether they lived or died.... it came as a surprise to me - indeed a shock - to find that of all nationalities who were POWs of the Japanese, only Americans killed each other in captivity.”

As to the treatment of the POWs in the camps, it was, of course, appalling. There’s plenty of gratuitous beatings, beheadings, stabbings, and shootings and so forth. The author confirms the stereotypes although he doesn’t overdo it. He’s not gunning to enrage his readers. One of the better aspects of this book is that the author’s primarily interested in concepts and cultural patterns.

For example he mentions guards took a common position such as, "You are war prisoners and should be cold, if you are sick you should die."

This is an idealistic logic that first reminded me of Confucius in its self-righteousness and blithe unawareness that there could be more than one way to do something. Outside of the Japanese warrior code, for many a Japanese officer no other existed nor could conceivably exist. Of course this is a flaw of the young everywhere and at all times. The childishness of the fundamentalist who knows that there is only The Way and all other options are heresy and a snare to be resisted. Even listening to heretics is mortally dangerous.

"You have killed many Japanese soldiers in battle. For what you have done you are now going to be killed - for revenge. You are here as representatives of American soldiers and will be killed. You can now pray to be happy in the next world - in heaven.”

Barbarism yes, but what sort of barbarism?

"The five were blindfolded and one after another they had their heads chopped off. ... when all five heads were finally chopped off, other men took their swords for the sport of trying to cut the corpses in two with a single stroke, like warriors of the old samurai times in Japan. But none of them were samurai; they were just hackers, slashing away in a welter of blood."

Clumsy feudalist barbarian wannabees. To state the obvious, it seems democracy and rule of law were not pervasive in Japanese society. Thus the reversion or perhaps continuum of old stereotypes in lieu of coming up with new mores and ethics for dealing with problems.

Another way to look at it is that the flip side to ultra-politeness is ultra-barbarism. When not terribly constrained by mores in their home country, the soldiers didn't know what to do overseas when they could let their hair and guard down. They did the natural thing with absolute power when they got it, they got absolutely corrupted. They returned to the untutored and quite natural human cruelty to strangers and to the generally wanton behavior of children (our most cruel stage because most ignorant and a stage in which we're still learning to view other people as people and not as objects). Ergo one scene the author mentions in which Japanese soldiers have fun throwing stones at the heads of POWs as they drove by. The best way to understand this phenomenon is to wonder in what state of mind you too would willingly engage in the same behavior. Throwing stones at people? Sounds like something from one's childhood, doesn't it? In part because as a child one doesn't realize how much potential harm there is in the throwing of the stone and also because one doesn't tend to really appreciate what it's like to be on the receiving end until one has been on the receiving end yourself. We grow up kicking animals, torturing bugs, shooting birds with sling shots and air rifles. And then you grow out of it when you gain a sense of community with the animal kingdom, after which guilt and the rest of the well-adjusted citizen’s emotional blackmail arrives. Many Japanese soldiers of this generation (as opposed to the previous one at the turn of the century which scrupulously avoided atrocities) once outside Japan didn’t grow up, but instead reverted to an earlier immature stage of social interaction. The stage when torturing and killing animals (in this case human ones) was still sport and sporting.

Japanese protocol emerged as result of traditionally ultra harsh behavior (ex: beheadings) when the upper classes dealt with the lower classes. In both traditional Japan and Korea summary capital punishment was in order for people who did not bow sufficiently low. At the time of WWII, the relatively recently emancipated lower classes (post-Meiji restoration, that is) seem to have taken their cues from the traditional mores of the upper classes when dealing with social inferiors. Now they had their first contact with a social inferior, a lower caste in fact, i.e. racially inferior arrogant Westerners, and their treatment of them makes their feudal era forbears seem enlightened by contrast. The Koreans were known for treating foreigners particularly badly, which makes sense as slavery ended in Korea only in 1910 (when the Japanese invaded and put an end to it).

Perhaps it’s a bit late to state the obvious but labeling Japanese mistreatment of POWs as immoral, is Chinese peacetime patriots like to do, only hinders getting a useful explanation. This explanation can only be acquired by pushing into other cultures, taking them seriously, and groping around for clues. For example, motorcycle gangs mauling innocents suddenly appearing on the scene is a phenomenon that has appeared in Taiwan (1990's scooter killers with watermelon knives), Japan (1970's motorcycle gangs with baseball bats), and the United States (1960's Hells Angels, etc.). All three instances were during times of rapid economic growth and when social mores were being shed and a generation was caught in a limbo between old mores and the absence of a replacement. Obviously there's a pattern here. And obviously labeling such violence immoral simply fogs the issue and makes getting a serious and useful explanation all the harder.

As to the US troops surrender, this is interesting as well, given the infamous capitulation of the French in the Second World War. "But here it was some Dutch general who did not even speak American ordering them to lay down their arms while they were still capable of fighting. The battery went through the astounding experience of having not the Japanese but the Dutch turn machine guns on them and threaten to shoot them if they did not capitulate." Needless to say, there was a lot of anti-Dutch sentiment throughout the British, Australian, and American troops for this and other related events in Indonesia.

In addition to Macarthur’s apparent nervous breakdown (when wars are proclaimed, every army has its officers who go clinically insane) and inability to make decisions and give orders there's also this: "The Philippine government had some crazed regulation about not moving rice from one province to another, and Macarthur never overrode it. Along the railroad's the Filipino workers were deserting, there were no crews left to run the trains, and the government would not let American troops take over - and so trainloads of food never got moved into Bataan. At Tarlac there were businesses owned by Japanese civilians, stores full of canned fish and corned beef ... yet permission to confiscate was never issued. In fact, when a colonel was about to do the obvious logical useful thing and take the lot, Macarthur’s headquarters threatened to have him court-martialed. So it went, all over Luzon."

A powerful government agency screws up powerfully. No news there. One of the problems with having national military is that like all government agencies it constitutes a monopoly. It's for this reason that the US military can spend $1000 for a toilet seat or $50 for a screwdriver. Because you can't fire it and no matter how much money it spends, there's always more where it came from: the taxpayer's pocket, because if you don't pay taxes you go to jail. It's also for the same reason that these national agencies perform so poorly. There is little incentive to perform well when you can't be fired.

With regard to Japanese cruelty, it's also worth pointing out that, "...Japanese enlisted men had a more rigorous time of things physically than Americans or Filipinos: routinely long marches, short rations, and rough discipline, including corporal punishment. In the Japanese Armed Forces, the senior officer could slap a junior officer, a lieutenant could hit a sergeant, a sergeant could beat a three-star private, three start to start, to star ones there. And the lowest of the low had to take it. But basic training in the imperial Japanese army did not routinely include hundred mile marches with Japanese privates bayoneting and shooting their own officers and burying men alive.... it was true that the Japanese army at the senior officer level was a mix of fanaticism and indiscipline, full of faction fighting taken all the way to assassination. And it was true that by the time of the Nanking massacre in China in 1937, tradition minded officers were worried about indiscipline in the lower ranks. Yet for all that, the imperial Japanese army was still a rigid structure, with a fetish for total obedience and instant physical punishment for the most minor transgressions by inferiors."

I'm with the author until the last sentence. Two problems. One, indiscipline at the top means unorthodox orders being given, which means unpredictability, which means fear in the troops as to which way the winds will be blowing each time an officer appears on the scene. Plus, it means if you get an order to abuse, you abuse, because you fear harsh summary punishment. No court-martial. On the spot punishment. An corps this devoid of democratic ways and means is a corps that does what the screwball in command says without question.

The author also points out the rather remarkable contrast between Homma Masaharu and Tsuji Masanobu. The first was in charge of the Bataan death March and gave orders to treat prisoners leniently and as to the second, "wherever Tsuji went in the war he trailed atrocities. He was one of the masterminds of the Malayan campaign, and after the surrender of Singapore he organized mass murders. He came to Bataan fresh from that. Out on the margin, along the East Road, an officer who looked like Tsuji was seen behaving like Tsuji, a Japanese lieutenant colonel killing a surrendered prisoner with his own hands. Some of Homma's staff did not like that sort of thing, and they said so. But then other senior officers were riding up and down the East Road in their staff cars, and they said and did nothing about what they saw, except that one of them drove over prisoner.

Some Japanese officers demanded killing of prisoners. Some encouraged it. Some tolerated. Some opposed it; but even they endured it."

I'll end this with: "in the world according to Tsuneyoshi, the domination of the white man in Asia was over, but the prisoners were still the eternal enemies of Japan. They were an inferior race, in fact worthless. They owed their lives to the benevolence of the emperor. Tsuneyoshi himself would just as soon see them dead; he regretted that he could not destroy them all, but unfortunately the spirit of bushido forbade it."

Here you have, among other things, the eternal Chinese peacetime patriot's confusion with and denial of inconvenient reality. Angry that the inferior dares upset the traditional moral order. And of course there is the underlying rage from suspecting yourself of racial inferiority. After all, racialism is a double-edged sword. If the so-called racial inferiors have defeated your nation, as was the case with both China and Japan, then you're back up the racial tree again. So one can imagine the self-doubt, plus being offended by genuine US racism and various exclusion nights per immigration. Plus the conspiracy theories about who controls the world (the Japanese would have said the White Man, the White Man would have said the Shady Jew, and so on and so forth).

One can imagine how the balderdash about Japanese racial superiority must have sounded to those who familiar with martial history. Given that 500 Spaniards overthrew more than one million Aztecs, given that the English had conquered much of India with just 2000 troops it must've been a rather awkward pill to get down into the gizzard. It reminds me of the recent scandal concerning Australian scholars who faked several scholarly histories of white massacres of Australian aborigines in order to give the aborigines a myth of their own to underpin the reinvigoration of their culture. The idea was presumably to enrage the aborigines and give them grievances and a sense of entitlement thereby making them socially well-adjusted and have them contributing to the greater glory of society. With the Japanese the idea presumably was to revive the glory and moral correctness of the ancients massacring their inferiors and thus make the common man into a faithful killing machine who loved his country and people and thus make him better adjusted to the needs of modern society. Either way, given the Japanese knowledge at the time that Westerners did so well conquering others and inventing technology, this propaganda seems doomed to produce expectations out of whack with reality. This means inferiority complexes all around and overwrought attempts to prove oneself superior, fearless, warrior-like.

Western visions of racial superiority tended to disappoint less because there was genuine superiority, though it lay not in race but in improved economic and governmental forms which in turn produced more advanced technology and more effective militaries. Even something innocuous such as Western-style team sports for kids, for example, produces an entirely different mentality (i.e. group unity, team cooperation, attention to objects lying in peripheral vision, etc.) in the young adults. On the battlefield this means in armies that desert less often, function better as teams, communicate with each other, have a heightened awareness of physical landscapes and are broadminded when it comes to potential tactical avenues.

"The standard prewar wisdom of empire was that it took only a handful of white men to run the lives of millions of yellow or brown subjects. In the Philippines, 15,000 white Americans to 16 million Filipinos. In the Indies, a quarter of a million white Dutch to nearly 60 million Indonesians. In Hong Kong, less than 20,000 white British to more than a million Chinese. In Malaysia and Singapore, less than 20,000 white British to about 5 1/4 million Malays, Chinese, Tamils, and Sikhs
. On the island of Singapore itself, whites (including women and children) were less than 0.2% of the population, and yet Britain ruled."

And then, at the beginning of the Second World War, the Japanese started to beat the whites at their own game. You can imagine what havoc that must've played upon the superiority/inferiority complex of those members of the Japanese military who have bought into the homegrown bogus propaganda. And what a mess of primeval savagery emerged. There, but for the grace of the god, go us all.

Saturday, March 26, 2005

Ch01 Busted (just the opening, incomplete, trying out third-person narrative for the first time) 1000wds

When he heard the loud clumping of the police team coming up the stairs of the short-stay hotel, he knew it was all over at last. Payback. It had been a long time in the Chinese mail. He didn't know it, but he felt it. Knew it. Like sighting a 22 rifle on a macaque and feeling the right impact, the one that's more sound than punch, when you know the bullet's going home. That was how he felt. In reverse. Like the monkey. The bullet was homing in on him, slow-mo. But instead of giving in and collapsing in fear and attempting to escape the inescapable, he continued heaving, pounding, his breathing loud, gasps escaping into the torrid stench of the barely furnished room, his hair wet and the sweat running down his face gloriously. Wet was a plus. Like perspiration making a weightlifter’s arms lighter than air, he felt empowered, stronger when wet. Not panicked. Reality not entering in because he could stave it off for a few moments more. Long enough.

He didn’t notice the heat or the sweat. She did, but it was all part of the exotic low-budget, penny-pinching English teacher experience. It was novel, queer, off. But at least it was different. Different attitude, rules, conversation, jokes, pastimes, foreplay, sex. What did it mean? What did it matter. She’d lie later and brag about how much the cheap skate had spent on her.

He’d half-forgotten the plankton smell that he’d once mistaken for a stench. It was now wafting up from the girl, his student and mistress. On arousal she gave off a seafood pheromone punch that dispersed silently like a puffball underfoot releasing an attack dose of hooked spores. She emerged from bathrooms conquering air fresheners. She left a raunchy presence in dressing closets that punished China’s line-cutters. On arousal the same pheromone punch somehow emerged from her mouth, strong-arming gum and mingling with breath mints in a mongrel raunch like week-old garbage, the vinegary tang evaporated, the rich underlying purulence still there.

He didn’t mind it. In fact he liked it. Filth was fun. Especially when it was make-believe as it was now. More comedy. She was a pretty girl spending top-dollar on knockoff tote bags, designer jeans, impregnation pumps, French skin crèmes, and loitering around expensive international restaurants offering bad food and connections to the lay-about scions of the connected. She was still unaware of her feminine odor because no one had told her. Some part of her olfactory mechanism had thrown in the towel soon after puberty. He figured he was doing her a favor by fucking her and she didn’t know it.

His focus was elsewhere. It might as well be. He knew what was coming. He'd made the mental adjustment. Thought it through. It didn't bother him now. Didn't even interest him. Just a distraction to be overcome. There was no time for thinking. Too late for action too.

So his focus remained in the room. Where his sweat was dropping down to the body below, just visible, the white skin of her narrow waist, her breasts jiggling on her rib cage just a tactile blur engaging the spread fingers of one hand, only visible in infrared, the girl whimpering in a different tone now, now that getting her man off was being pushed to the back of the priority list, now that panic was replacing it, fear reprioritizing everything.

She was starting to stiffen, unconsciously closing the scissors of her legs, her body playing out in flesh what her mind was playing out: fear. She was going frigid and impeding his plunging, his rooting ever deeper, his aiming for maximum torque. He spoke Mandarin in a soothing tone, "No, no, Sarah." Hearing her name whispered confidently, relaxed her and the rest of her softened immediately. "Chill out. It's going to be okay. I'll handle it. I always do, right?" and he gave a wheezing sardonic laugh, arched his back, concentrated on maximizing the itch that would turn into heat and then liquid fire and then waves of shut-eye white joy. He was almost there. Looking for the catalyst. Trolling for the right sensation.

Now the footfalls were stopped and hammering on the door started, "Open up! Open up or we'll kick the door in."

He was still breathing, bent over, and hard into her, slamming up to his hips to get into a narrows in her insides, to maximize his penetration, his pressure, his possession, his imaginary, hoped-for, orgasm-generating humiliation of her. Something he had never told her. Something she would not have believed about him if someone else had suggested it.

He said dreamily, trying to distract the public security officers, not realizing he wasn't loud enough to be heard, "Huh? What!"

Someone outside said crossly, "No, no, no. I have the key. A door costs money. No kicking in the door."

"Shut your mouth. Fuck your door, hotelier. The security bureau will pay for it."

Remembering his previous encounters with the high-handed officers of this agency, men who took orders from no one in the city limits, not even the mayor, the hotelier had little faith in this bureau's desire to serve the people.

He wheedled, "But it would be rude to the other guests." In his best weaseling voice, his rounded shoulders rising in impotence like a waiter pinned to the wall by a vindictive customer, "But, oh, just a minute. We'll be right there," and a tinkling of keys sounded through the door. The movement of metal was enough to distract the head simpleton, the one with the gun in hand, who now stared at the flash cockeyed like a toad fixating on a glittering bug, as if daring it to move again.

"There, there," the hotelier hissed and then chuckled self-consciously, "Almost got it," he was saying, now in a more self-effacing tone.

Friday, March 25, 2005

James R. Manchan's Paradise Raped: Life, Love and Power in the Seychelles (1983).

(To save time I'm going to edit these essays less in future and just let them run loose as they come, free and easy and disorderly maybe and perhaps even speaking in tongues sometimes, but at least without fretting over them as I used to, wasting more time in the fixing of them than in their making - which seems pretty foolish when I think about it now)

I chose this book at this time because I'm studying international relations and thought it’d be fair to have an informal introduction to the field at the hands of a former Prime Minister deposed by violent revolution in the 1970s. Manchan was the first elected Prime Minister (1976) of the Seychelles, an archipelago located approx. 1000 miles off the east coast of Africa to the north of Madagascar and which were formerly a British colonial territory, previously purloined from the French. I thought it'd be thought-provoking to have a sort of shallow politician's perspective on things as opposed to the shallow academic blather which would set out principally not to explain events but to explain the explanation of explaining events that needed explaining. The politician would be fluent in folk-speak, the familiar and undiluted tongue of the working people who read newspapers and their Bible. And being a politico, he'd probably have learned how to tell a story to an audience. His fibs would be more readily apparent and intelligible than the fabulous stretchers inserted into the waffle of the orthodox professor whose focus lays with placing nose to grindstone and ears to the ground to be both up and down with what's hot and what's not in the world of university fashions.

Manchan says he’s a loveable guy with a girl in easy reach of each arm and has several photos of famous glamorous pusses to prove it. He’s conservative, pro-business, and fights valiantly to keep the country under the aegis of the United Kingdom and yet in this morality play he’s the paleo-KTV singer, the winer and diner, the panache dresser, the people’s person with black and white blood and a hint of almond eyes from his Chinese grandmother.

The villain of the piece is Andre Rene who having failed to weasel his way into the top job by fair means, plays foul. He stridently insists on cutting the apron strings and achieving independence from the White Man yet surprises continental African supporters by turning out to be a rat-faced white dude himself. (photos back this up too) Rene strikes me as being a sort ethnic impersonator wannabee. He tries to steal the role of ethnic underdog in a country that in part because it has no indigenous population has no ethnic majority or even minorities per se. Rene seems a sort of Don Quixote fighting impossibly for the impersonator successes of Asa Carter or Ward Churchill. Instead, he succeeds by impersonating an ersatz socialist, sets up a political party, achieves a military coup d’etat after which he lets his hair down, gets some killing and looting out of his system and settles into his natural pose as the local warlord.

After the fall of the USSR, and the collapse of the Stalinist iron rice bowl, Seychelles went quasi-open and democratic in 1991 and our hero returned to the islands to lose one election and then didn’t bother contesting the next. Rene just stepped down this year, 2005, putting a crony in charge.

On page 51 there's an interesting anecdote which helps to explain the economic sloth of people who are traditionally self-sufficient. According to my favored anthropologists, farming did not become popular with its invention. Instead, farming was invented, abandoned, reinvented and re-abandoned over and over again for thousands of years. Nobody wanted the damn thing on their hands because it’s too much work. Farming, though raising the flag on economic efficiency, is no great shakes compared with hunting and gathering. Farming, where put into practice didn’t represent another clever step forward for mankind’s living standards but actually signified desperation with a relentless retreat in living standards. It was declining forest yield, overpopulation, and the threat of starvation which led to the desperate defensive move we call farming. Similarly, building the Great Wall of China did not represent the growing strength of China but its periodic decline. A strong China used offensive maneuvers such as saber-rattling and battles, brides and bribes to defeat or win over enemies. A weak China built walls when it could not defend itself in a can-do fashion and was the sort of last resort that suggested a dynastic collapse was in the mail.

Page 51: ... a banker on holiday on Mahe came into my office. He was shaking his head and grinning to himself.
"I've just been talking to a fisherman a few miles from here", he said "I'd been watching him from my room. Each morning he takes two hours to row slowly out to his one-basket trap. It seemed to me such a waste of effort that I suggested to him that he get a bank loan and buy an outboard motor, which would save time so that he could make six trips in the two hours. He looked at me as if I was crazy."'
'"Six traps?" He said. "What would I do with all the fish?"'
'"Money," I said. "With all those fish you'll get more money."'
'"But what will I do with it?" He asked.'
'"Well, once you've paid your loan off," I explained, "you will be able to save it to you have enough to relax and take life leisurely." He shrugged. "I'm doing that already," he said.'
The banker chuckled to himself. There was no answer to the fisherman's logic. It was a typical Seychellois attitude which went hand-in-hand with a gentle quality of life that over the years had caused visitors to describe the Seychellois as inhabitants of the last lost paradise, a place where paradoxically you can be poor but rich and happy, a land of little yet of plenty.

Manchan's political opponent was Andre Rene. While Manchan represented the side of tradition and political conservatism, René took the side of political revolution and international socialism. Interestingly, and perhaps typically, you can find the same sort of irresolvable debate going on in the China section of the Asia times online forum between the non-China writers (sincere and reasonably knowledgeable) and the China correspondents (insincere and unfathomably/willfully ignorant about their own country). On page 62, Manchan demonstrates how this worked in the Seychelles in 1976. The following may remind you of ongoing debates on Iraq and China.

From pages 62, 63: From the very beginning the [international socialist] paper carried articles deliberately calculated to disparage the USA and to lower the esteem of the American people in the eyes of the Seychellois. They were painted as villains in Vietnam and racialists at home.... No matter what they did, they were wrong.
[The Americans] had the only modern refrigerator system on the island and began by buying stocks of lobsters. René accused them of depriving the locals of food. They took the point and imported their lobsters from Kenya. René then accused them of failing to support the local fishermen.
The same logic might apply to fraternizing with the girls. Ignore them and you discriminate. Don't ignore them and, with your money and sports cars and offers of US passports, you inspire jealousy...
One of the conditions of the agreements between London and Washington was that the Americans could import food and provisions into the island free of duty. Rene attacked them. Here was the richest nation on earth, he said, depriving a poor island of much-needed revenue. The Americans reacted quickly. Through the auspices of the Catholic Relief Service Agency they imported tons of bulgur wheat in sacks as a substitute for the rice which was the Islanders staple diet. The trouble was that the Seychellois hated the stuff and René attacked them for dumping en masse leftovers that their cattle and pigs had not consumed.
(Recently I saw that the lessons still had not been learned. Traveling in Micronesia in the Pacific, I saw a number of islands under American trusteeship. Behind most of the thatched houses stood beautifully mounted 50 hp Johnson outboard motors, monuments to American generosity but of no practical benefit as the Islanders had no idea how to replace a simple spare [tire].)

And from page 69: people working under pressure often need an opening valve to let off steam. Some go for alcohol. Others smoke heavily. A few become the unfortunate victims of drugs. I discovered with Isabel that my strong -- or may be weak -- point was that I found great solace in the company of women, particularly those who were both intelligent and beautiful. A tête-à-tête by candlelight would normally provide a temporary and useful respite from whatever political problems and frustrations that beset me.

Indeed, over the course of the 200 plus pages of this book, the author refers discreetly but firmly to his picking up and shagging of a dozen or so celebrities in various stages of marriage or divorce. He was known as the Pierre Trudeau of the East for his swinging bag and adventures. At first this seemed a bit clownish. And association with Pierre seemed unfortunate as the late Trudeau did as much as any politician in recent Canadian memory to lead the country down the primrose path to being put out to pasture.

Then I came around to Manchan's way of dealing with an attack of low-esteem. Alcohol, drugs, and cigarettes are essentially diversions and aides to forgetting a situation. In other words, tools of someone who is passive for the moment. Picking up floozies is a power booster and confidence restorer. Particularly when you spend time with intelligent cuties, hard as such animals are to find (One of Manchan's more intelligent plants informed him one evening that she was the spirit of Nefertiti). On the other hand with even just a facsimile of intelligence, you have something to talk at, given that talking with is out of the question. Either way you can get things off your chest, debate them if you like, and come up with fresh ideas and solutions. You don't obsess because you can't: you're in the company of somebody you're trying to talk up. And sex is healthy: both more of a workout and yet easier on the body than designer pollutants. After chit-chat and love/hate sex, you don't wake up feeling removed from the situation but feeling empowered to deal with it. Gives a fine sheen to WhamBamThankYouMam.

Given the international socialist misery which gripped the Seychelles after the violent revolution of 1977, which brought in witch hunts, political prisoners, political assassinations, and at least one street massacre, I developed an appreciation for the simple happy politicking necessary to work a simple happy people.

From page 73: our party responded to Rene's political violence with restraint. I knew that the great majority, brought up under Christian ethics, abhorred violence and I knew that the way to the hearts of the people was through song and laughter.
My brother Mickey, perhaps the best vocalist the islands had produced, became a great asset to our campaign bandwagon. He wrote over 50 songs which on the whole popularized the theme of nonviolence, said 'No' to independence and called for fraternal understanding.
... we fought the election with Mickey's songs and a carnival atmosphere. The songs attracted big crowds who, in between the singing, were being educated about what we saw as the social and political consequences of breaking our links with Britain. The lesson of Zanzibar was regularly recalled. 'Think of all the dozens of political leaders who made use of emotional issues to seek popular support for independence,' we said. The result was the most gruesome type of dictatorship and the denial of human rights.

Songs and a carnival atmosphere worked, keeping the islanders away from the lunatic sub-Saharan African dictatorships that broke out after the British and French left. In the end, Andre René had to resort to machine guns and importing warriors from the Tanzanian army to get rid of Manchan who was too popular and who lived in a nation too prosperous to be overwhelmed with the usual left-wing conspiracy theories and politics of envy.

Perhaps most interesting in this book to me was evidence provided by the author for the positive aspects of colonialization. Taiwan clearly benefited from being watered and manured by the Japanese colonial regime. Americans on the other hand paid more taxes for less government benefits as an outcome of an expensive war for independence waged ironically to reduce taxes (recall the hated Stamp Tax, the Boston Tea Party, the maintaining and installing of troops in American residences after the British had paid for and successfully fought the French & Indian War).

From page 70, 76: The Gibraltarians did not want independence because of their fear of Spain; the Fijians were worried because their Indian immigrant population had exploded to an extent that it formed the majority on the islands.
... Britain, anxious to dismantle the empire, soon bought off the Fijians by offering them a constitution which assured the native minority the government mantle over the Indian immigrants. Naturally they took up the offer and became independent.

The author, who was prime minister both before and when the Seychelles became independent, never wanted independence. It was the British which forced independence upon him and the islands. One wonders how many pages of professorial dirge Noam Chomsky dictated to secretary Edward Herman on this hideous nastiness and into how many beet-red Irish rages Robert Fisk must have suffered whilst feeling their pain. Here, in the conspiracy-free zone, it appears that the colonies were too expensive for the British to maintain as a side show and the British foreign office ended up bribing colonies to leave the circus. Yes colonialism, shame that it was, was so shameful that it took years of begging and plenty of payola to get them off Britannia’s bloody teats. And, to be sure you didn't miss it, the Brits even went so far as to provide Fiji with a system that was antidemocratic to please the reigning indigenous locals (what an earlier generation of tear-squeezers and pain-feelers called noble savages). I hope you enjoyed that irony as much as I did. Well, in this world, there's plenty more where that came from.

Last but not least, let's take a quick look at how NGOs operated in the 1970's and, as far as I can tell, continue to operate:

Page 86: News that the airport project was on washed up on our shores a shoal of entrepreneurs and our difficulty was to differentiate between the snapper and the shark. We did not want any fast buck merchants and we hired Dun & Bradstreet, the international status investigators, to check every individual and company who arrived with plans and ambitions. The status reports threw up some astonishing backgrounds. Among the sharks were undisclosed bankrupts and a fair selection of wanted criminals ready to take advantage of those whom they thought were still backward islanders. They were soon told to get off the islands but fortunately there were many serious businessmen ready to risk precious capital in the name of free enterprise.

Keep in mind that the author, Manchan, studied law in London and Paris and is a Knight of the Empire who's father was a successful businessman. NGO's typically go into ridiculously corrupt countries where the Big Chief and his adjunct swamis either know nothing about the likes of Dun & Bradstreet or wouldn't want foreigners peering and nosing around in the nation’s business anyway, disturbing family and friends.

That's enough for today...

Tuesday, March 22, 2005

"The man who reads nothing at all is better educated than the man who reads nothing but newspapers," complained [Thomas] Jefferson.

Taking a break on the manufacturing of bad novels (though the next one should be much better as I'm past the self-indulgent screw-the-audience phase I think and into the healthier and more productive money-whore stage). Inspired by my latest flip-flop on the National Taiwan University grad program. Thinking of writing the required exam in English instead of Chinese (a language I can read and type, but not write by hand). Wouldn't be the craziest stunt they've seen I'm sure. They might buy it anyway, as there's an oral interview and I speak Chinese like the wind plus I've translated for plenty of respectable non-entities around town. We shall see...