News & opinion on Greater China and the even Greater Beyond: by Biff Cappuccino.

Wednesday, March 16, 2005

Ch15 Hooking up in Hong Kong (incomplete, rough, first draft)
1500wds

You and the guys meet in Hong Kong and commiserate and reflect.

See foreigners badmouthing Cantonese and demanding they speak English and otherwise be rude to the Chinese.
+++++

Michael said, “I hate foreigners badmouthing China. Make me want to whip out a can of whoop-ass.”

“Here! Here!” and we clinked cans of green Carlsberg and white Tsingdao.

“Fucking foreigners!” I squeaked.

We were on the first floor of Chung King Mansions, where the food was worse but the view better as was the likelihood of bumping into other familiar faces, fraternal ground-feeders in the English teaching food chain. The tables were fiberboard with collapsible aluminum legs, the surface had a bleached plastic finish embossed with flying pigs in light green and pink. We were in various states of repose, balancing atop three legged stools with round imperial scarlet plastic seats. The curry looked like the product of someone with indigestion: the color homogenized, the flavors subdued, the overall effect being culinary defeat. But location! Location! Location! won out as the place was full of shoppers and we were not just yapping, but also trolling for familiar faces. And for job prospects. Maybe a bit part in a movie. Maybe a smuggling run. Maybe an illicit municipal delivery. Maybe a boiler room job, purloining investment dollars from suckers that fell for confident white faces. Maybe just plain old dull workaday Engrish teaching.

Frank remarked between sucks of beer, “Noah is going to be held up as a sacred example of China’s open-mindedness and absence of racism.” We all groaned. “He’s headed for a professorship or a successful career in diplomacy. He’ll have celebrity, half a dozen hotties in the wings. He’ll be laughing all the way to the fucking bank.”

A round of half-hearted boos went around the table, none of us quite sure whether we ought to resent or envy him. Except for Michael who looked at us and grunted, “Yeah. That son of a bitch is like those foreigners you see on Japanese TV. They’re doing tea ceremony, cross-legged in kimonos, bowing and scraping. They’re out-Japping the Japs.” Seeing us frown, “Uhh… I mean out-Nipping the Nips.”

“I hear you. I know where you’re coming from.” I said to reassure him. His sort of embedded racism was so natural-born and well-suited to his personality, so sort of expected in him that you just couldn’t work up any resentment. Call it sympathy for the devil.

I pointed out the obvious, “I miss that fucking place already!” A round of sorry grunts went round. “The scalped mountains, the pariah dogs… the pariah people. The exhaust particulate, the food stall fumes, the coal smoke.” The usual deal of not cherishing something until you lost it. “The smell of cancer was never so sweet.” Lame doggerel but fundamentally true.

I lifted up my beer, and to give myself some time to suck on it, I plied Frank with “So you think we’ll get back in there? China I mean.”

He put his beer back on the greasy table, and looked off at the side, towards the blowing industrial fan which had long since heaved two generations of napkins into the aisle, “Yeah, maybe. A definite maybe. When democracy filters up or down or however it gets in. They’ll change the laws and remove the blacklists. But how long will that be?”

Later that evening, I went out to check my e-mail of the local Internet cafés. I had yet to write my parents and inform them of our disaster. I was still in the process of working up the courage and a face-saving rationalization. Then I noticed that Noah had sent something. I've never got an e-mail from him before.

Hey, fool. Hope life is treating you good.

Say, guess what? Now that you and that a-hole Frank picked up and left in such a hurry, this school turns out to be cool after all. Once you two fools left, the local boys went and got real accomodating and friendly.

Remember them arguments you picked over democracy, free speech, human rights, and all the rest of that monkey-ass jive? Well guess what fool? Now that you two be gone, it turns out they agree with what you was saying the whole dang time. Yeah, brother. They was just faking it. They love this corny Uncle Sam America apple-pie bullshit just like you do. They eat it up way more than I do and God knows I am an American. They love it even though they don't know nothing about it. So they's got questions. Lots of 'em. I got answers. So I'm the authority now. The authority figure. The Man. Ethnic Man. Yeah! Feels real good. Fool.

I can't believe you two was such chumps. You know, coming in and playing the White Man. I know you got no choice but to be a white man cause that's the way you was born. But shit you don't got to be PLAYING the White Man, you know what I'm saying? As long as you was pushing the White Man shit in they faces, they was too proud to admit that you had something they wanted. You know the story about Fox and them sour grapes, right? Well too true brother. Once yo bony asses was on the plane, everything chilled. So in the future, even if you all got to be a fool, because you're born that way and don't know how to be no other, just remember you don't got to be no chump.

Anyhow, things is going real good. Pimpin! I'm on my way to being somebody. Get me a professorship. Maybe you can write me a note sometime and I let you attend one of my classes. You be looking good as my student. Styling!

You take care of yourself. Fool.

Noah

Irritated and embarrassed, my first instinct was to cast Noah as the future Ward Churchill of China. Noah too would become the sort of well-spoken ethnic poseur with the gift of the gab, chutzpah, and the opportunity to make a big name for himself and become a hero and sex symbol to everyone but the people he represented.

But then again, there was a ring of truth to what he was saying. It was all too familiar, now that I was being pointed in the right direction. After all, the routine for guys picking up local chicks was similar. Cuties start chewing your ass about foreigners being hairy, having body odor, being aggressive, uppity, uncultured, semi-civilized and so on. If you'd put up with ten minutes of this, the girl will ask if you want to go back to her place. You've passed the endurance test. She wanted you from the get-go but on her terms. If you don’t show contrition for someone else’s sins, get lost.

In other words, in a country famous for infestation with social protocol, we'd forgotten the most basic rule of thumb: to be polite. Yet another fabulous mistake on our part. Incredible that Frank and I could have forgotten this. Noah, blessed with a less popular skin tone, wasn't in a position to forget. He had meekness forced upon him, the lucky bastard. And in China it often seems the meek shall inherit the earth.

When I brought Noah's email up with Frank the next day, he wasn't amused. In fact, he was incredulous. "He's just making that shit up. You don't really believe him do you? Even if it was true, you can't be babysitting people. I mean, c'mon Charlie. Don't wuss out! You see a bad argument, you chop it off at the kneecaps and go in for the killshot. How can you entertain being a pussy in the face of bad logic. And another thing, you know..."

That was as much as I needed to hear before zoning out into the hypnotic spin of the industrial fan. He was in denial. What happened, didn't happen. He talked it away. Much like our beloved faculty members, he was only willing to accept the truth on his own antsy terms.

Why get in the way of his delusion? He was happy with it, just as I too had once been. He would learn in his own time. Or maybe he wouldn't learn at all. It's a big enough world for all of us, so what does it matter anyway? But it was high time that I got my act together. Learned sensitivity, protocol, the niceties and refinements of cross-cultural ass-kissing. Sloughed off my personality, reinvented my values, gave up my mores, exchanged ethics for morals. It's a full time job being somebody you ain’t in order to become some new body that you are. Whole hog. Hook and sinker. It’s going to take a while, brother. But I’ve done it before. I’m in for the long haul.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino

Tuesday, March 15, 2005

Ch09 First Class (rough)
2200wds

We were up on the second floor of a new snappy snap-together plastic and blue-glass prefab. Looking straight out of a manga cartoon, it’s a bank all the same. Having walked up carpeted stairs past farmer’s almanacs, double happy posters, and huge calendars with Nepalese mountains and Taiwanese temples, the wife and I sat down at a stained fiberboard desk behind which sat a friendly 30ish female bank worker which natural blush in her cheeks, rouge in her lips, and the suggestion of a nice ass. The wife pulled out some US notes she’d filched from the wallet of a drunken customer the night before.

To pass the time I asked her and the teller about the faces on the bills. When I pointed to George Washington, my wife hunted around the bill for clues, fixed on the distinguished lineament of the sacred visage and pronounced “Lincoln.” I bit my lip and asked the teller. She fingered the dull note the hue of aquarium algae and confirmed, “Sure. Lincoln. That’s him.” Then I showed them a note bearing the portrait of the romantic Thomas Jefferson. The wife pouted, then sucked her teeth, and ventured, “Washington.” Again, the teller backed her up.

When I first got to East Asia, Flips and Japs were all the same to me. Now it was a taste of my own medicine. My wife and the teller couldn’t distinguish between one white man and the next. We’re all just cookie-cutter whitey. In all seriousness, though my wife loves me, she hasn’t the foggiest idea of what I really look like. You see the same thing with movie posters with local artists painting likenesses of Arnold that come out looking like Patrick Swayze. The glory of Arnie’s muscle is there, but then they’ll go and plant a chiseled pinhead on top.

And yet both the wife and the teller were aggressive about their choice of likenesses. George Washington was Lincoln. They were sure. They ended up pressuring me to admit that I was wrong as if by force of personality they could convert something wrong into something right. It’s a curious approach to knowledge. A sort of anti-empiricism. Faith over fact. Suspension of disbelief dragged kicking and screaming out of the theater and into real life. Anything is real as long as you have attitude. And then you learn to believe it yourself.

As a concept it was amusing; the sort of salty snack that whet your appetite for more beer and blather on a Friday evening. But in application in a school of higher learning, it was going to stick hard in my throat; in fact, it wasn’t going to go down well at all. And either it went down or I went down.

The university exam turned out to be a bit of a bird. As I settled into my appointed schoolboy's combo chair and desk, I took a deep breath to calm myself and peered at the questions. The first was about the development of international relations and required an explanation of major paradigm shifts in recent decades. The second question required distinguishing between collective security and collective defense, plus provision of examples of how both had been implemented and their effects on East Asia. The third required the student to discuss the One China Policy with regard to content, principles, assurances and guarantees. It further required a description of significant gray areas, internal contradictions, and the goal of this policy. Last but not least we had to come up with definitions for flexible response, the Bush doctrine, ASEAN +3, and the bureaucratic politics model.

Dry but simple stuff and though I’d been a complete ignoramus three months prior, I was well enough versed in the material now. As I got down to work, I realized the hardest part would be scrabbling out Chinese characters fast enough to write my answers. Stretching my neck, I handed my paper in ahead of time and emerged from the examination room confident I’d passed.

Noah, Frank and I received notices of acceptance in the mail. On the way to the first class, I told Frank about the good news. He surprised me asking, "How did Noah get into the graduate program? Not the kind of person you’d expect to knuckle down and prepare for school. Could you see this clown in a university program back home?"

He didn’t back off for a minute. He might have said ‘Well, I’ve got nothing against the dude. You know. I’m cool. Whatever, you know. Besides, it’s China. Who gives a fuck? But don’t you think it’s a bit odd, that, uh…” Nope. No chance of that.

I shrugged, made a pained smile and rolled my eyes at no-one in particular while defending Noah, "Well, let’s say it is some sort of affirmative action thing. We’re all on the receiving end of this anyway. The exam wasn't difficult. More like custom designed to get anyone in. As far as I could see, it only screened out the imbecile, the Section 8, or the applicant functionally illiterate in Chinese." I looked at him but he said nothing and glared straight ahead. "Besides, look on the bright side. He ought to be live one, with all his causes and identity politicking and championing of the victim-hood. Should be a fucking riot! I mean," trying to sound convincing, "if it was just you and me, it might be tits up for fun."

He didn’t buy it and winced at my clumsy attempt to be down with the street. A warning to watch where I placed my sympathies. Too vulgar for the groves of sapience. At times like these he struck me as seriously in need of Zanex and a lay. No chance of that either.

Speak of the foreign devil, Noah was up ahead at the campus gate and I called out to him to wait up. As we picked up the pace, Frank mumbled quickly, "Fuck affirmative action! Waters down the program and it reflects badly on people like us when we graduate. The qualified get pulled down just to pull up the unqualified. That's not fucking fair."

I was tempted to say that I was hardly qualified either and that just being a foreigner was unfair; whether banged up by unfair treatment or floating on a free ride.

But this would just get him going and the last thing I wanted was him to start sneering at me. Once that started, there’d be no end to it. He'd discover I was a dilettante sooner or later anyway. There was no such thing as ‘people like us'. If there'd been more foreigners, we'd have formed mutually exclusive cliques and bagged on each other wholesale. So I kept a lid on it.

Why speed up the inevitable disillusionment? I preferred keeping my friends for as long as they were willing to be kept, for as long as I could manage to keep them. Loneliness will do that. So I kept my mouth shut and let Noah take the heat. He could take care of himself. He was a talented chameleon. If he got hit with rejection, he could reinvent himself and give it another go. Having a second wind made for second chances. Which made for courage and fresh starts. I'd always been a once bitten, twice shy kind of stick in the mud. False pride will do that.

Noah was resting with an arm on the gate, like he was claiming it for his own and daring anyone to mess with him. Some students looked at him curiously, but all avoided him as they went in. He might be one of the masses, but he was feeling primus inter pares today. He was dressed fashionably in a blue poverty chic distinguished by hygiene: no yellow dust in his blue pants, no food stains on his blue jacket, no spittle dribblings around the corners of his red mouth. Perhaps he was angling at the droves of cuties in the periphery.

He said, “So what’s up? You mofos got into the program,” he teased, “must be slacking off on standards. Dang, any biddy foreigner can get in here. When I’m president of this school, I’m going to have to make some changes.”

Frank was silent and looking at the wall running down the campus wall while I teased Noah, “Presidents aren’t academics. They’re just jumped up PR execs.”

“Precisely my point, white boy. I was born for PR.” But when I looked at him, his gaze had settled on a tasty piece of ass in magenta jeans splashed with cancerous glo-colors, a tropical jacket in surgery green sofa fabric, her white leather and rhinestone purse at her left elbow, her arm pointing up at a 45 degree femme Nazi salute. Very doable.

“You dog.” I laughed and then pointed to the wall, “You’re going to have to plant a fresh layer of glass shards into the cement to keep the foreigners and other degenerates out.”

“Razor wire my friend.” He pointed in the opposite direction, where the glass shards had been replaced recently with curling loops of cookie-cutter razor edges like a series of distant WWI German crosses. “Yo, get with the times.” He mocked gently. “C’mon lets get going or we’re going to be late.”

“You’re right ready to get go,” I half-asked.

“Of course. This is graduate school fool. I’m here to get an education. Why else would I be here? I have a career to launch.”

When we reached the classroom for our first scheduled seminar, we found the classroom abuzz with student chatter. As we entered, things settled down rapidly and some of the students checked us out, with looks lengthening into stares. We were inured to gawking and tuned it out while checking out the large tan oval table surrounded by plywood chairs. The professor hadn’t arrived yet and we scoped the place out.

Mao was on the wall. It was the largest of several portraits of revered mob leaders and featured him doing the Mona Lisa, prim smile hiding slashing knife. Sun Yatsen was also in attendance, the Chinese do-gooder champion of the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Given that power comes from the barrel of a gun, and Sun was mostly a blank charge, it came as little surprise that former tent evangelist Mao was jumped up on the wall larger than the national rain god Sun Yat-sen.

The short of it was that any tendency to be sanguine and uncynical evaporated with these advertisements. You might as well have planted portraits of Hitler and Huston Chamberlain on the wall and expected us to celebrate by pulling out tambourines and planting flowers in everyone's hair.

I motioned for Noah and Frank to sit down first while I continued to size up the portrait pecking order. But then they threatened to sit down beside each other so I pushed them out of the way and grabbed a chair in the middle.

"What's your problem?" Noah snorted.

"I get the feeling you two might need a referee in between bouts."

Noah threw a suspicious look at Frank who was ignoring me and staring at the wall, sharing my interest in the corporate hierarchy.

The prints of Deng Xiaoping and Jiang Zimin and Hu Jintao were similar in size. The tradition of looking over your shoulder worshipfully at the national traditions seemed alive and well here. This produced a nation of patriots who never looked where they were going, walked straight into trouble, and blamed the other person for being in the way. I got a heavy feeling we were going to be in the way.

Frank got out a scratch pad and a mechanical pencil, and started doodling, assembling his thoughts, attack strategies, contingency plans. He’d kick-started the debate long before he arrived, prepping himself by running everything between his ears first. He was here to bust heads, take scalps. Noah was here to learn. He pulled out bronze designer eyewear, gaudy frames without lenses, and pulled a rechargeable 100% locally-made laptop out of his backpack, thus dodging the political problems attendant with either Japanese or American technology. He’d settled the debate long before he got here: yes sir, no sir, three bags full sir. I could hear it already.

What was my role, my stragety in this farce going to be? I scratched my head idly, searching around for something itchy. The reality of where we were was starting to sink in. Where we were going with all of this?

Outside in the street, in the marketplaces, in the shops and the factories, sweatshop bosses and wage-slaves gave up sleep, limbs and even lives in their manic ache for a future of prosperity and toys. Financial security was the new frontier. I admired them for it. They were going to make it come hell or high water.

The portraits on the wall were like Aztec hieroglyphs, indicating our profs felt the future couldn’t live up to the bloodthirsty past. Without free speech and vigorous discussion, the nation's patriots failed to connect many, many dots. In forum discussions, there was often an Alice in Wonderland quality. What lurked ahead in this classroom? We were outnumbered and playing on their home turf now. Tragedy or comedy? Probably both.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino

Monday, March 14, 2005

More lunatic debates from the Atimes.com forum...

Dude said the following: >>In reality, most of China's intellectuals complain about lack of freedom of speech. What they are reallyh complaining about is not that they can't say stuff after dinner in their houses, if they do, no one will know and they will be safe. What they are complaning about is that they don't have control of media tools such as newspapers, TV's, radios. They wish to spread their "products" to society. But they have not proven that their products have passed reliability testing.<<

More conspiracy theories out of China. One cure for this is freedom of speech. Let people openly argue ideas and most of the bad ones will become obvious to most people.

How do intellectuals gain control of newspapers, TV and radio? They can't. It can't be done in a free society because the consumer determines what's popular, not the intellectuals. Intellectuals have a well-earned record of failure when it comes to impacting the English-speaking public. The impact of PBS, the intellectual-ridden public television station in the US, is practically nil upon the public. Most of PBS is garbage and rightfully ignored by the public because most intellectuals are like most people in all walks of life: they have nothing new or special to say. Most intellectuals are blank cartridges.

Math fears intellectuals presumably because he is not one and because he believes they are smarter than him. But they're not. Most intellectuals are just blue-collar people with a diploma.

The overwhelming majority of successful novelists in the US are high school graduates. Earning a diploma seems to get in the way of literary success.

The public in China has been fooled for five thousand years by its rulers. It remains bamboozled by the Communist Party today. The intellectuals if freed couldn't do any worse. In fact I'm sure they'll do much less harm because intellectuals can seldom agree on anything. They're seldom if ever united in the way that non-intellectuals often become during times of national crisis.

As to blogs in China, show something substantial please instead of cliched humor. Show us blogs in favor of religious freedom, critizing Hu Jintao or critiquing government policy such as the Tiananmen Incident. My point is not that the US or other countries are perfect, but that the conditions there for criticism are much better.

Out of curiosity, can this Atimes forum be viewed in China?
I want things to get better in China just as much as anyone else. Increasing freedom of speech is required for people around the country to know what is going on and how to improve things. It would also prevent the appearance of such lunacy as this article:

Freedom of speech would help prevent such imbecile utterance in the Chinese state press such as, "Chinese people's unwillingness to show wealth also has a physiological reason. Scientists found more dehydrogenates in Chinese livers than westerners' through studies of intoxicated people from various countries. This explains why alcohol poisoning occurs much less frequently in Chinese even though the alcohol content of China's "white spirit" far exceeds that of foreign liquors. The existence of dehydrogenation enzymes in the human brain may have to do with the fact that the Chinese are better at controlling their moods than Westerners."

Biff Cappuccino
Chapter 08 Meeting of the Minds (rough, incomplete)

4400 wds

(I’ve rehashed a couple of my old blog articles…so this may be familiar to you)

Taking a keen interest in Frank, I decided to look into his blog. I looked at his latest article:

>> A Rushed Review of Escaping the Muddy Trap of China by Lin Zhi-Sheng.

Lin trots out the usual suspects while explaining why Taiwan should be independent from China. But there is a simple logic which he does not go into and which I've not seen raised in magazines and books so far. And that is that Qing dynasty China, which ruled Taiwan, is not at all politically speaking the China of today.

China was ruled by the Manchus from 1661 until 1911. Ergo, China was not China but was an extension of Manchuria. In other words, part of the Manchu empire. Ergo, Sun Yat-sen was not born in China, he was born in the Manchu Empire's Canton Province. Just as Benjamin Franklin was not born in the United States: he was born in the British Empire's Massachusetts Colony.

So, the Manchus ruled Taiwan during the Qing dynasty; not China and not the Chinese. After all, when the Manchus came into power in 1661 they legislated a caste system for their new empire. There were four castes: the Manchus being top-dog, the Mongolians coming second, the Chinese third, and the aborigines fourth. Marriage between Manchus and Chinese was a capital offense. (The death penalty for those who aren't sure). Chinese were forbidden from moving to the Manchu homeland until late in the 19th century. So to say that the Manchus and their empire were rapidly Sinified seems like a bit of a stretch and more like wishful thinking.

One of the first national edicts that the Manchus laid out was the banning of a mainstay of the Chinese diet and traditional Chinese pharmacology: human meat (consistently the cheapest meat for 2000 years) and human organs (Chinese traditional medicine was never just about politically correct herbs).

Even the notion of China as a nation-state is a modern invention, because the notion of nation-state is a modern one. This helps explain why Mao Zedong was first an advocate of an independent nation of Henan before becoming the Great Helmsman. Zhongguo is a term that only became popular at the beginning of the 20th century. Prior to this, terms such as Zhonghua and Hua were used and they more properly connote Chinese civilization and not the notion of fixed national boundaries.

An enduring reflection of this is the fact that about 46% of today's Chinese population does not speak Mandarin Chinese and that the Party has recently begun to ban the use of dialects in radio and television again. China traditionally was not a nation of Chinese people, but a collection of disparate provinces populated by illiterate, untraveled, and geographically ignorant peasants who spoke different often mutually unintelligible languages and who had no conception of membership within or loyalty to a nation at all. They were proud to be affiliated with Chinese culture, but their loyalties were local, to their village or hamlet, and not national. Even today there are millions and millions of school-graduated folk living in the interior and who speak and read Mandarin and who yet can't find the capital city, Beijing, on a map of China and who have yet to even discover that Taiwan is an island.

China (the nation-state of the Chinese people) never ruled Taiwan because the Japanese took over control of Taiwan in 1895 and the Manchu Empire did not fall until 1911. China did not come into existence until the civil war ended, the country was unified, and the last elements of warlordism eradicated in 1949~1950.

Chiang Kai-shek took control of Taiwan in 1945 but he himself was never in control of China the nation-state as it remained a congeries of warlords while he headed it. One of the problems that US General Joseph Stillwell had with training Chang Kai-shek's troops to fight the Japanese was that he did not dare deploy any of his troops from China proper. His leadership position was so weak that he was afraid he would be overthrown in a coup d'état by his fellow generals (a polite term for fellow warlords) were he to remove any of his troops from central China to the border with Burma.

'China' prior to the unification of the country under Mao Zedong was a loose, rubbery term akin to 'America' prior to the unification of the United States in 1776 (or 1782, depending on how you wish to define things). America, prior to the declaration of independence by thirteen of the colonies of the British Empire, referred to the land mass existing between the North Pole and the Panamá isthmus. In other words, America then is not America today, which refers to the 50 United States including Hawaii and territories such as Puerto Rico and American Samoa. Similarly, China is a term of convenience which, under the magnifying glass, turns out not to be a term referring to a fixed territory. Worse, China, if used as a term to describe the nation of the Chinese people, disappeared under the Moguls and the Manchus. What was not a nation-state was even less so while conquered and reorganized by empires administrated by alien peoples. Saying that China has existed continuously is comparable to a scenario whereby the present-day Indian nations were to throw out all of America's immigrants of the last 400 years and then claim that America has always and uninterruptedly been the nation of the Indian peoples. This could only be superficially persuasive if, as victors, they were rewriting history. Communist China, the victor, has done just this.

At this stage, anyway, the claim that Taiwan belongs to China today because Taiwan belonged to China in the past, fails to persuade me. Just as the cry of numerous Chinese patriots in Shanghai that Alaska in fact belongs to China fails to persuade me. Just as the predictable future bleating of Chinese patriots that Zhengho's discovery of America (if Gavin Menzies theory turns out to be correct) signifies that the entirety of the North American continent belongs to the sacred territory of the Chinese people will inevitably fail to persuade me.

Frank N. Frankenferter <<

While reading this, I’d felt a rush, blushed and begun to sweat. Hope against hope, was he really a doppelganger? A potential soul mate? (The non-conjugal kind.) The bastard could really think for himself? Or was he just the usual run of the mill academic, filching ideas from somebody else and repackaging them? But he didn’t strike me as the type of donkey who was inured to drudgery and competent only at the spade and shovel work of clearing through the dust bunnies and fly carcasses of library archives. I was psyched, really excited. I had to know. Creativity is so rare. Creative writers and thinkers are about as common as leprechauns and as fabulous as unicorns.

In return, I threw the following at him via email. It was one of my harsher rants, hitting below the belt, but fair as fair goes in the world of frauds. Either way, I figured that being such a harsh bastard he’d settle for nothing less.

>> Ode to Comedienne Iris Chang

The eulogies of Iris Chang have been unintentionally amusing, much like book blurbs are in general. This is no accident given that both are often written in haste by the same sort of glib, mutual back-slapping, dollar-chaser. This seedy subsection of the literatti seldom knows what it's on about and can't be bothered to check the facts as the membership ain't interested in knowing them anyway.

Exhibit A: The San Francisco Chronicle informs us that, "Born in Princeton, N.J., Chang grew up in Champaign-Urbana, Ill., where her parents are professors at the University of Illinois. Her grandparents' escape from Nanjing fed her early interest in what happened there. "

Grandparents? In the introduction to The Rape of Nanking, Iris Chang writes "I first learned about the rape of Nanking when I was little girl. The stories came from my parents, who had survived years of foreign revolution before finding a serene home as professors in a Midwestern American college town. They had grown up in China in the midst of World War II and, after the war, fled with their families, first to Taiwan and finally to the United States to study at Harvard and pursue academic careers in science.... but they never forgot the horrors of the Sino-Japanese war, nor did they want me to forget. They particularly did not want me to forget the rape of Nanking. Neither of my parents witnessed [the rape of Nanking], but as young children they had heard the stories, and these were passed onto me.

The New York Times edifies us with: "Fluent in Mandarin, Ms. Chang traveled to China, where she scoured archives and interviewed elderly survivors. What she learned would force her to describe the indescribable." In other words, she was forced by her fluency to describe the indescribable.

The same comedian alleges Chang's book contains the following, "So sickening was the spectacle that even Nazis in the city were horrified."

Hmm... But wasn't it a Nazi who took the initiative to establish and manage a safety zone in which the entirety of the Chinese population remaining in Nanking moved to when Japanese forces arrived (most of the urban population had already evacuated the city, with the rural population summarily driven off their land by frontline KMT forces which destroyed their property (and often their complaining person) as part of its scorched earth policy)? The 'even horrified Nazi' was John Rabe whose diaries have been translated and printed in English under the title, The Good Man of Nanking: The Diaries of John Rabe. His book is cited approvingly by Iris Chang. So, if she indeed did write this, it makes little sense in the context of the eulogy. If the quote has been fabricated by a lazy or indifferent reporter (is there any other kind?), then it shows that the reporter/eulogist/reviewer has not read much of the book at hand (do they ever?).

But this sort of name-dropping, bogus generalizing, and shibboleth slang-whanging is typical of panting, overworked and underpaid, free press hacks. Their main priority is that of any other professional: career advancement. This they achieve via getting on the front page of their newspaper section. Their venerable employer's main priority is stirring up the animals (by hook or by crook) to whip up circulation which in turns enables the paper to charge local businesses higher advertising rates. Dollar-chasers chasing dollars from beginning to end.

From my narrow truth-chasing perspective, however, it serves me no useful purpose to pretend that members of the Nazi Party were ipso facto devoted to massacring Jews and crushing liberty everywhere. The Nazi party, i.e. Germany's left-wing National Socialist Party (only slightly to the right of the Communist Party), was a political organization encompassing millions of people bearing, as with any other democratic political party, a grab-bag of different goals, opinions, tastes, morals, religious feeling, etc. In addition to rounding up and eventually slaughtering minorities, the Nazis, as a party, also enacted Europe's first maternity-leave legislation (i.e. women couldn't be fired just for being pregnant), enacted the first restrictions on carcinogenic food dyes, and the first legislation to regulate air safety levels in mines. It would take 30 years for the US to catch up to this sort of public policy making. The Nazis also established low-cost automobiles for the low-wage earning public, i.e. the Volkswagen - the folks' wagon, and constructed cruise ships that provided affordable cruises for the same proletariat. It goes on and on. As World War II historian John Toland wrote, if Hitler had been assassinated in 1938 he would've gone down in German history as a national hero. In the end, of course, Hitler launched a war and had to be stopped. But as the American reporter/author William Shirer reported while in Berlin, unlike WWI there was no celebrating in the streets at the invocation of WWII. It was not a war popular with the public.

So the phrase, "Even Nazis" is meaningless. It's like saying "even Republicans" or "even Democrats" or "even the French." Why not Freedom Fries for everyone?

There are other well-remunerated examples of half-witted nonsense that I could quote, but it gets depressing after a bit. One gets a sour taste in the back of one's mouth and wonders: These are the opinion makers? These donkeys?

You don't want to think about it. I know I don't. But a library card and cross-checking the 'plain facts' unluckily indicates to me that most of history, especially that known and fondly recalled by newspaper-devourers and TV-fanatics to bulwark their beery arguments, is just plain bunk. And this bunk has next to nothing to do with what happened and is thus useless as a guide to preventing mischief from recurring in future. And it was for emitting precisely such heresies, and pointing my accusations at the source - the very hacks of academe, my proud professors: the proud creators, nay fabricators, umm... embalmers and curators of history, that got me flunked out of grad school in Canada. Such is life.

But this loose playing with facts and fancy, stiffened up with a brace of fine-sounding or primitively emotive gobbledygook, is par for the course and operates at about the same level in Iris Chang's fine work. And with this realization, the heavens parted for me: truth, forever coquettish, finally revealed her naughty bits.

Ah! But of course! Reporters writing eulogies for an esteemed colleague much wanted in heaven for higher, finer work! Hacks lavishing a fellow comedian with hagiography. Scoundrels praising a fellow scoundrel, and in so doing, never busier a-back-slapping than today. The din of self-congratulation is deafening; the papers awash in a gush of bosh as punters leap-frog to get a piece of the publicity pie. Lies flash around the world light-speed via the WWW, before doddering truth has time to drop its cock and reach for its socks...

But why should I expect any better than botched facts, poll-parroting, and sophomoric rhetoric to constitute all the news fit to print now that Iris Chang has apparently topped herself?

From the second paragraph of the introduction written by Chang to her The Rape of Nanking: "Americans think of WWII as beginning on December 7, 1941..."

Really? No, of course they don't. Like any big lie, it seemed almost crazy enough to be true. I asked a couple of Yank colleagues in the translation office just be sure though. Not satisfied with just this, Chang kick-starts the Second World War with the occupation of Manchuria in 1931. This enables her to claim that the rape of Nanking is the biggest, baddest, and most worstest Holocaust of WWII. But this is only one of numerous sneaky maneuvers on her part.

Check this out: “No doubt, those 14 years of domination by the Japanese military were marked by countless incidents of almost indescribable ruthlessness. We will never know everything that happened in the many cities and small villages that found themselves prostrate beneath the boot of this conquering force. Ironically, we do know the story of Nanking because some foreigners witnessed the horror and sent word to the outside world at the time, and some Chinese survived as eyewitnesses. If one event can be held up as an example of the unmitigated evil lying just below the surface of unbridled military adventurism, that moment is the Rape of Nanking.”

Look at the awkward phrasing, the excessive trying-too-hard piling on of nastiness, the weird perspective whereby the reader becomes a member of a community called “some foreigners”.

Is this English? No. Not really. This is Mandarin. I’ve translated poor Mandarin into bad English for too many years not to smell a rat. This is a piece of filched CCP propaganda that she’s translated into English. Or maybe they were in on the game. Maybe part of it. It wouldn’t be the first time.

"No doubt?" and "Countless?" So we're clearly not dealing with history here; this is rhetoric, the primary weapon of the mentally feeble and logically impaired. What one cannot convince through logical persuasion, is perhaps doable via rhetoric. A case in point is the King James Bible, a beautifully worded tome, which, when reduced to plain English becomes idiotic and undecipherable, with its contradictions in even plainer view. Reduce the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx to the journalese of the financial page, and its tissue of absurdities are a dead-letter. It's no accident that Marx, like Chang, like Charles Hanley (the co-fabricator of the No Gun Ri incident of South Korea) was a successful journalist.

The newspaper is an excellent training ground for the unethical literatus to learn the ins and outs, the do's and don'ts, the elasticity of 'the facts', and the legal culpabilities (and more importantly their loop-holes) of their slippery trade. The whys, wherefores, howzitts, and prick-tease whodunnits required for perennially pulling the customers' noses comes easily afterwards.

"Indescribable": we've covered this mockery of information, this evasion of the facts, this camouflage for precision: this unwillingness of Chang to admit to her customers, that she, as self-appointed messiah and blue-stocking in chief, is not omniscient and privy to all the facts of the case after-all.

Could Chang possibly not have known that the Japanese military did not dominate China; that, as with most any other democracy (or pseudo-democracy), it was the civilian wing of the occupation government that did the dominating? Which was why Manchuria enjoyed the highest rate of industrialization and the highest living standards in China, outside of the western occupied zones of Shanghai. You might as well try to persuade me that as a child living in Uganda, the locals were under the boot of the English and suffered "indescribable ruthlessness." Sorry sweethearts, I was there.

Once the fighting is over, the grunts move over and the civvies come in. I'm not going to be convinced that my memories are less persuasive than the rhetoric of garden-variety anti-colonialists. No more than locally-born grandparents in Taiwan have ever been persuaded that the arrival of the KMT and the ensuing massacre of the intelligentsia, the national land grab, the destruction of the local currency and impoverishment of everyone's savings, the installation of martial law, and so forth signaled a reprieve from the Jap's boots and their "indescribable ruthlessness" of modernizing the infrastructure, eradicating head-hunting and cannibalism, upping the living standard, bringing in genuine law and order and quashing the mafia and gangsterism, establishing a national education and welfare scheme, etc...

"We will never know everything that happened." You can chase your tail all night with that one. Everything? Since when, where, or how could anyone ever know everything about anything? It’s another complete non-entity as a sentence, yet another puff of rhetoric sharply elbowing meaning out of its appointed place.

Page five from the introduction: "One historian has estimated that if the dead from Nanking were to link hands, they would stretch from Nanking to the city of Hangchow, spanning a distance of some 200 miles… Their blood would weigh 1200 tons, and their bodies would fill 2500 railroad cars. Stacked on top of each other, these bodies would reach the height of a 74-story building.

Using numbers killed alone, the rape of Nanking surpasses much of the worst barbarism of the ages. The Japanese outdid the Romans of Carthage (only 150,000 died in that slaughter)... it is certainly true that in this century when the tools of mass murder were fully refined, Hitler killed about 6 million Jews, and Stalin more than 40 million Russians, but these deaths were brought about over some few years. In the rape of Nanking the killing was concentrated within a few weeks."

Note how she leaves out the numbers of Chinese killed by the Chinese KMT (at least double the number killed by the Japs) and the numbers killed by the Chinese Communists (who in the leisure afforded by peacetime, shot and starved to death somewhere around 60 million).

In essence the problem can be reduced to this: we Chinese can kill each other, no foreigners allowed!

I’m not trying to be funny. I’m perfectly serious. Just browse the daily dose of Chinese xenophobia that Atimes.com hosts in its letters to the editor page. The language employed may be English, but the retrograde tribal sentiments are unabashedly Mainland China Mandarin-derived and cultural in origin. These people are that unenlightened. Or, to use an impolite phrase, they’re that fucking stupid.

And I like Chang’s touch, "only 150,000 died in that slaughter." You can feel Chang's palpable fear that you might otherwise be impressed with the number. You might pause to consider such a large figure. Fortunately she cuts in quick to remind us that it was ONLY 150,000. I get the feeling her editor slept right through the galley drafts. He was only there to sign his pay slip.

This kind of gaff in English would not be considered a faux pas in Chinese though, which is a much cruder medium full of hard-hitting blood-and-guts propaganda: i.e. it's a language still recovering from the pummeling that martial law on both sides of the Taiwan straits has given to freedom of speech and thought; not to mention to taste.

A case in point is "One historian has estimated that... [the massacre victims'] blood would weigh 1200 tons"

One historian eh? From the prestigious University of Hawaii East Asian Studies program, or from Stanford or UC Berkeley, perhaps? Not likely. Straight from the mouths of those innocents at the China Communist Party.

This is part of a pattern. Again, she uses the phrase "some few years." She has a thing about the word "some", as if unfamiliar with the more appropriate "several" which would handily dispose of "some few." Again, she uses the word "foreigners", when "foreign nationals" or "expatriates" would be more in keeping with modern idiom. In other words, whether or not she in fact lifted this paragraph from a crude CCP rant, she writes like a Chinese person who learned English as a second language. When speaking (C-Span.org hosts one clumsy back-pedaling interview and one angry messianic rant), she sounds American valley-girl, but I suspect, like many of the ABC candidates who've shown up looking for work at my place of employment, she's far from American - perhaps Western is what I mean here - in terms of her thinking.

This may have something to do with the following description of her in the San Francisco Chronicle. "She was doing research recently in Kentucky and ran into some problem," he said. "She got really upset, and she flew home." ... Ignatius Ding, an activist who worked with Chang for several years in seeking to have Japan acknowledge and apology for atrocities it committed during World War II...noted that she "took things to heart" and usually became emotionally involved in the tragic stories she wrote about.

I've met this sort of minority messiah in the flesh (and am a sort of reformed one myself...haha...) and they can be trying, seldom taking a vacation from their outrage and investiture of emotional capital in whatever the hell gives them a sense of meaning. Paul Theroux has mentioned the same thing and tendency to suicide in Eastern European academics in the US when they run "into some problem." The problem Theroux mentioned is usually ethical. With Chang, I do not know. But I am curious.

So many of these messiahs, hearts-of-gold to the contrary, come down with a thump.
Sun Yat-sen, after the cobwebs of hagiography are brushed away, turns out to be akin to Yasser Arafat: pocketing donations, lathering like a workhorse to establish a fascist dictatorship, complicit in assassinations, and just generally relying on his reputation as a nation-saver to make up for his serial bungling.

Pearl Buck, in an effort that ought to have christened her glowing literary and moony-Old-China-hand reputation, established a foundation to better the conditions of East Asian orphans. She got tired of the racket and turned over the management to her bisexual boyfriend who then, along with his bed-buddies, started raping orphans from coast to coast. When the story finally leaked out and became national news, she threatened the children who had ratted to the press with immediate deportation back to Korea. After she died, it took her family seven years of litigation to finagle back that part of the estate which was owed to them and which had been ripped off by her bereaving boyfriend. As with Mother Theresa, another of these dollar-hounds, where did all the money go? After Sun Yat-sen did a tour in the nineteen-teens and raked in huge donations from Japanese philanthropists (I gather they hadn't got their boots on yet and got with the national game-plan of "indescribable ruthlessness") he pocketed the funds and never again wuz they seen. I'm shocked!

I'm also tired. So, I'll end this rant here. I'm sad to see Iris go. I would have preferred the chance to destroy her reputation while she was still alive. Hopefully Professor Chomsky will remain fit and with the living, full of whimsy and vigor, the weepy old charlatan.

Charlie Chan <<

Sure Frank was a bit much sometimes, hard-headed, unforgiving, an attitude problem and low EQ. But it still felt like a meeting of the minds. And beggars can’t be choosers when there’s so few foreigners per square mile in China.

But as any author can tell you, the personality you see on the page is often far removed from the author in person. The author who keenly parses grammar and logic is often a ninny worried to death about fluoride in his water and CO2 ending the world. The writer who persuasively anatomizes personality is often a sadistic freak with delusions of persecution and ripe fantasies about the imminent police state and military-industrial complex. The writer who pens airy light comedy can be a relentless mocker of others who can’t let down his defenses for a minute and has never made a real friend in his life.

Authors, successful ones anyway, tend to be hyperbolic, pathological, dysfunctional. Who in their right mind prefers to spend more time with books than people? But this was something I had yet to learn. Frank would teach me.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino

Sunday, March 13, 2005

Ch12 Blackmail 1100wds (incomplete and very rough)

Well, after the stirring events that took place in the student lounge, something had to happen. Somebody had to give. The powers that be looked for a chink in the foreign armor, a flesh and blood weakness. They had to look no farther than Yours Truly.

+++
You’re blackmailed to help the school throw out Frank.
+++

I was outside, free from the black mood that had fallen on campus, away from the dispiriting ostracism of the Chinese students. Not that I could blame them. They were powerless by design. Mao, like Lenin and Stalin, despised the same intelligentsia that worshipped them. At a time like this, it was hard not to blame them.

News had spread quickly through gossip and the electronic grapevine. Everyone was out to protect number one now that the winds of culture war were blowing. We'd been welcomed insincerely by most of the campus, met with open arms and cardboard smiles.

Fair enough, we too were a cynical bunch: a shirker, a psycophant, and a fanatic. But as long as we were top dog, what did we care what the natives thought? But now the rules of the game had changed. We were vulnerable. We'd gone from being guests to being just foreigners again. We were expendable. Nobodies. Cogs that had got caught up in the gears of the machine. Pests. We were met with everything from hostile stares to indifference to timid glances. I felt sure there was sympathy and support for us in some corners, but it wasn't like Frank or I had done anything to earn it. We'd been riding on the good graces of our hosts and treated them like rent-a-wrecks. We were out of good graces and out of gas. Out of luck period.

I'd left the campus and gone back out on the street to lose myself in the happy hoi polloi. The sweating proletariat was independent, self-made, confident. They were weren't overeducated and over-civilized and dependent on the good word of a master to get ahead in the world. Thus they weren't weak and given to constant maneuvering in order to stay with the herd. They could be ignorant, they could be credulous, but they weren't wishy-washy and you knew where you stood with them. Their first instinct was to protect one another, not get out of the way when slings and arrows came and let someone else take the damage.

I know I sound angry. I was. Perhaps I still am. Okay, I'm pissed. We fucked up. And yet even then I half-knew we'd been playing with fire from day one. Riding high on your horse into a strange town is a dumb move at the best of times. Here it was just asking for it.

I'd run into the busy street to get away from it all. Now I was in denial. I was also in heaven, chomping on a tasty piece of General Kung's Exploding Chicken, the gelatinous gravy thick with peanut and caramelized sugar and a local condiment that freezes your gums like a dentist's injection, when I received a call on the cell from Professor Johnson, inviting me down to his office for a private talk. In China, it's taken for granted that pretty much all conversations are private. So what was a 'private talk' going to be about?

When I reached his office and knocked on his flimsy yellow panel door, he told me to come in. He was standing as I opened the door. He bowed a little and presented me with a gracious smile to put me at ease. On his best behavior as usual. I was so grateful for this gesture that if he'd kept looking me in the eye I would have wept on the spot.

He turned way from me though and began to pace, rubbing his hands in the dry air, the chafing reminding him of something better he could do with his hands to calm us both. He was silent as he went to his window overlooking the campus, and stared into one of the original student dorms, not yet torn down and replaced with something more modern. It retained the dirt floors, stools and wooden writing desks, and the hammocks for beds that were emblematic of the bad old days of the Cultural Revolution and beyond.

While he zoned out the window, I had nothing to do. Doing nothing took an effort and was fatiguing. With a feast of stir-fry and pilsner gurgling pleasantly in my belly, I had to rally hard against the temptation to call it a day and start snoozing right there and then in his office. Trying to do the responsible thing, I got up and walked over to his desk quietly, wearing the culturally appropriate expression of a serene simpleton when in the presence of authority. The good professor heard me and recalled his duties and turned around.

He said mildly, "Ahem" and then thought better of launching into his spiel and instead reached into his desk to finger a pack of cigarettes. He pulled out a Victory smoke and fired it up with a Chairman Mao flamethrower which, in his state of nerves, gushed out a good six-inch tongue of flame and threatened to put his pompadour ablaze. He was too self-involved to notice how close a call he'd had though and began inhaling rapidly, focusing on depressing his blood oxygen level.

I let the poor soul be, looked around and noticed the place was full of iconography of the Great Socialite. There was a larger-than-life poster on the wall behind his desk, the popular smiling knife portrait of Mao that was defaced during the Tiananmen protests. But there were other, smaller shots of the Great Poseur scattered about too. One was on his desk, another on the wall. The latter was a hanging portrait in black and white, the Yenan Mao, during his baggy pants and sandals free-love stage, somewhere around the time he got hitched to the infamous star-fucker, the white-boned demon as she's also known, Jiang Qing.

Hanging off his right wrist, his smoking hand, was a plastic pendant hanging off a fake gold chain. More Mao. A good luck charm in the working world, it doubled as a talisman against persecution on campuses.

Incomplete ---

You’re presented with the fact that your wife is a sex worker and feign ignorance. You blame China.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino

Tuesday, March 08, 2005

Ch 10 Lounge Lizards (sort of approaching complete, rough)
2400wds

I was just about to launch into Frank once again, when I heard the squeal of rusty hinges. I lunged around to find the party cadre cum lecturer entering the room. He entered with the tutorial instructor. A witness I thought. But to witness what?

He shut the door behind him. I tried to keep my eyes off the tutorial instructor, in tan leather heels and hip-hugging jeans. No mean feat.

"So, apparently there's been some sort of disturbance. Do you gentlemen have some sort of problem with the hand out that I gave you?"

I began to stutter a reply but he saw an opening in my quavering and waved me down peremptorily, "You need to understand that this is a university!" He began pacing in a circle, staring each of us down in his ad hoc star chamber. "You attend classes. We teach. You take exams. Maybe you graduate. If you work hard. This is not a kindergarten or a daycare center. You will act in a courteous respectful manner at all times."

Noah and I looked at each other, wondering where this was going. Frank, on the other hand, had no time for nuances. He glared at the lecturer, not giving an inch. Though he had yet to open his mouth and say anything, I had a sixth sense about what was going on behind the beady eyes and pizza face. I was seeing a pattern and slowly realizing that he was the type of sociopath who is often a hero to the intelligentsia back home. He was the sort of lunatic who focused exclusively on parsing and pulling apart your words and logic, and who dished out responses that were often rude and potentially insulting, completely disregarding your feelings. He was high IQ, low EQ. A recipe for success in the West. But dead man walking in the East.

Frank glared at the floor while his damn fool conscience forced him to mumble in English, "What if the courteous instructor is not worthy of respect?"

I held my breath. I realized for the first time that integrity could be a dirty word.

The party cadre, having been hired for his loyalty and not his work ethic, was fortunately the weakest link in the campus English proficiency chain. He leaned over and commanded, "Please repeat that."

For a patently evil bastard, you had to admit he was least polite while trying to cut you off at the kneecaps.

But before Frank had time to repeat himself, Noah interjected in Chinese, "Yes master. Of course master." And he diverted the lecturer with a deep bow which, for a second, inspired me with a panicky fear that he was going to go imperial traditional and prostrate himself, bouncing his head off the dusty tiled floor, a picture of reamed obedience.

The lecturer continued in an agitated voice, feeling us out, looking for a crack at getting some satisfaction, "You will complete the required assignments. Or, you will be expelled." He was daring us to rebuff him.

Again I admired him for taking the attack to the foreigners. He had courage, balls of steel.

The problem was that we weren't prepared. We hadn't come up with a strategy for dealing with hostiles. We were so busy being smug and flippant, or self-centered and into our own trip, that it never occurred to us that we might have enemies here. Real enemies. Capable ones.

A sense of doom loomed in my chest and a creeping panic moved into my pecs, tightening them and messing with my breathing. I blinked to upset the rhythm of fear and took my breathing off automatic pilot. But making breathing a conscious process took precious mental effort, enfeebling my ability to think on the fly.

All I could do was feel sick with worry that we were out of our element. I had no time to think. My RAM was maxing out. The bastard had us by the cohunes.

I tried to speak, but I was like Noah out in the hall, in the limbo between personas, mumbling unintelligibly, wires crossed like a stroke victim, memories inaccessible as I wheezed "Hahhooo... Azhriarrgghhh..."

The lecturer looked at me like I'd lost it. I could feel Frank trying to burn a hole through my head. Noah was reshuffling his cards now that I'd completely botched the situation.

So much for presenting a united front. But we had to stick together.

Noah hissed, "What the monkey-fuck are you doing?"

This snapped me out of my daze. I hissed in return, "What are you doing, selling out?"

"No bitch!" He whispered out of the side of his mouth, "I'm buying in."

The lecturer barked, making me twitch, saying "I will not tolerate profanity in this lounge. This is a school of big learning. Big learning. It is a center of civilization and civilized intercourse. I will not tolerate any barbaric utterance profaning these sacred walls."

Again Noah spoke out, getting the jump on Frank and I, and pretending to speaking on our behalf. He was not just our representative but also our superior, primus inter pares, "Yes master." He bleated. "We will honor your request master."

Emboldened by Noah's apposite ass-kissing the lecturer went into a lazy strut, "Let me be frank then. I have no prejudice against the white man, even if I must admit that I feel a certain repugnance instructing foreigners. I do not think it is any of your business what we Chinese do in this country." Looking out the window at the sun-dappled greenery, he relaxed further and said airily, "It was not my decision to open this department to foreigners. Frankly, I disapprove." Turning back to us, he resumed his pacing, his dwarf-beloved platform loafers clicking out the time on the tiles, "Furthermore, I think you should butt out of Chinese politics. White people have no place here." To Noah, he said respectfully, "Neither sir, do black men. I'm sorry but Asia is for the Asians. I'm sure you can all understand. You wouldn't want Asians taking over white people's countries. We don't want any new imperialists or hegemonizers here either."

Frank interjected with undisguised hostility. “What about democracy? Any room for that in your hidebound paradise?” But we already knew the inevitable answer.

“Democracy is a spiritual pollution spread by the West. Mostly by the Jews and by those masters of deceit, lawyers.”

I could already guess his sour view of rule by law. Rule by fiat was traditional, ergo moral and now sacred to patriots everywhere. “What about the Jews of the East”, I asked facetiously?

He ignored me and continued, “It is a hypocritical exercise in ignoble money-grubbing and a deceit carried out through a bought and paid for so-called free press. Your professor Chomsky has revealed all of this conclusively.”

I knew I was pushing my luck but still I blurted, “Isn’t Chomsky a Jew?”

He continued his soliloquy, looking over our heads, pushing his chest out, “Little Bush invades Iraq to establish a corrupt regime to facilitate his greed for oil. The whole world needs oil, China needs oil. Bush is a gangster. He is only concerned with the White Man. But, admittedly, moral authority means little when dealing with immoral governments when power derives from the power of a gun, as Chairman Mao said.”

“You mean chairperson?” I asked. Sure I was being stupid. I had to slow him down somehow.

He gave me an evil stare, deadpanning and locking on to my eyes for several seconds until I looked away. And in those moments, he prepped me to betray myself and my friends.

As he went back to pacing, click-clack clickety-clack, in his bourgeois pumps, “And what form of governance does Little Bush establish for his corrupt oil-soaked purposes? Democracy! Of course, the Holy Grail of corruption. The infamous blueprint for corrupt dealing. Well, we in China are not so easily fooled. While America has exhausted 200 years to become half civilized, fighting itself to free black ghosts de jure. Bah! In practice they remain oppressed by their white masters.” He went silent, as waiting for kudos and wolf-whistles.

But I had to admire the way he threw off unwanted concepts with ready tropes of glossy verbiage. Most of it was crap, not to mention filched from elsewhere, but then again most arguments are. Rhetoric was his strong point. He’d go far with the masses, democracy or no democracy.

Frank fought back, tilting at his appointed windmill, “You don’t care about your own people. You don’t want democracy because you don’t even like people. You don’t trust them. So of course you’re willing to sacrifice the lives of 100 million Chinese to take back a rock called Taiwan. Flesh and blood is worth less to you than a piece of real estate. You lecture about money-grubbing elites, cultural imperialists and corporate hegemonizers. But the simple truth is that you’re a sociopath. You’re criminally insane.”

Franks stood up as the lecturer’s cheeks ballooned and went ballistic. His face went imperial scarlet and his skin was a bright red sponge reaching into the roots of his greasy hair.

“I love your country more than you do, you fucking freak!” Frank shrieked in his ear.

“Shut your filthy hole!” the lecturer stammered, rage upsetting his bio-servomotors and giving his whole body the shakes of a Parkinson’s sufferer. His musculature fought against itself everywhere and droopy spittle began creeping out from both sides of his mouth. And yet he remained silent again, some part of his subconscious fixated by Frank’s grotesque, unthinkable, unanswerable accusation and crazy-gluing his thinking processes.

“The truth is we all do,” Frank said quietly, no longer angry, and yet his face was blushing. “You” he mumbled, while looking at the floor. “You, however, you don’t give a damn. You never cared. You never will. Did Tiananmen mean anything to you? Really? I doubt it. While people around the world shed tears for the meaningless deaths of a pack of foolish students… Do you know what I really think?” An odd question at a time like this I thought. “You’re a traitor to your own country.”

The lecturer stated firmly, in a calmer voice now. “I will have you suspended. Ejected from the country.” As usual, as was unavoidable, he missed most of the drama. He reduced the scene from a debate to a power play. As always with peacetime patriots, when push comes to shove, the argument devolves to my uncle can beat up your uncle.

This had little effect as Frank knew he’d already crossed the Rubicon. He must have made some decision early on that if it came to this, he would act in such and such a fashion. I supposed on some level we all had. And not all of us had chosen to act honorably.

He continued quietly, “In fact, you’re worse than a traitor. Because a traitor changes sides. You know where he stands in the end. But you…” and a tear dribbled down from his right eye as he jerked his head up to look the lecturer in the eye, “You never change sides. You pretend to love your countrymen while happy to send them to their deaths like so many stooges. How can you hate democracy unless you nurse a hatred for your own people?”

The lecturer looked away from Frank and with this the spell was broken. He immediately looked us over, sizing us up like a warring chieftain, looking for a sign of weakness to stamp on like a hooligan.

As his gaze fell on me, my eyes jumped in their sockets. Cowardice spread through me so fast that it overwhelmed me and I couldn’t help it as my shoulders leapt up Lurch-like and the self-preservation mechanism in the reptilian part of the brain made me suck the stale chilly air through round puckered lips. I looked around for support, strength in numbers, strength in anything. I rubber-necked, cartoon-like, like I’d farted and hoped somebody else would take the blame.

In a China sojourn enlivened by serial folly, this was my greatest blunder, the soaring climactic peak of a mountain of fuckups. Once I showed an inch of weakness, the lecturer would take a mile in backpedaling. If only I’d shrugged him off. Acted like the event didn’t happen. Acted like we didn’t care.

Acting was everything on the stage of cross-cultural interaction. If only I’d known that any botched maneuver can be excused as culturally inspired ignorance. I pissed in your beer? So solly! So solly! I screwed the pooch? So solly! So solly!

But in addition to caving in, I was an honest John. A trick who took a perverse pride in getting fucked by evildoers. It was the bad guys fault. I was comforted by my sheen of moral purity. The onus on change wasn’t on me, it was on them. Rather than ‘fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice shame on me’, my unconscious motto was that I’d ‘rather stand on moral feet, than live on morally relative knees.’ I was the perfect victim, perfectly adapted in theory for China, a nation which thrived on and cultivated political victimhood. But as the writer said, all moral victories are disasters. Victimhood was just another a cynical power play, a camouflage for nationalism which in turn was a straitjacket holding racialism, ethnic cleansing, cultural chauvinism and other political poltergeists struggling to burst out for lebensraum. I had the wrong race. I was trying to ally myself with the wrong uncle.

At this stage I was still a multicultural sucker soon to be parted from what he valued most. It wasn’t just Frank who was a self-righteous dickhead, a moving violation of cultural sensitivity. We were both accidents waiting to happen. Up till now, everything had seemed as harmless and comic as a Chinese fire drill. But all good things must come to an end. And did they ever.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino
Ch08 Classes (rough) 2700wds

Frank’s face was beet red in the throes of throbbing passion, his white-tipped pimples a deep lavender, his meaty pate glossier than usual, a quaking hand grasping the first reading assignment of the semester, care of our charming instructor for the course An Introduction to Jiang Zemin’s The Three Represents Theory. We’d all received a Xeroxed screed from the revered People’s Daily which, in the flowing Engrish favored by its political wing, states that the Three Represents Theory is “the treasure for ceaselessly increasing the combating capacity and the creativity of the Party, the latest scientific summary of the basic experience of the Party building, and the ideological weapon and guiding principle for carrying out overall Party building…” The usual murky doo-lally and multifarious malarkey and it ended with the modest claim that “History has proved that the CPC is creditably a great, glorious and correct Marxist party…” Who said the winners rewrite history? In China, so do the losers. Fair enough, I thought, given that nothing in life is fair anyway.

I tried to have a sense of humor about these things. But this, properly speaking, had vexed Frank, and truth be told I was having trouble swallowing it without gulping and heartburn. But it was the other handout which really launched Frank into a feverish outrage. Fortunately, the handouts were handed out at the end of this, our first class of the first day.

We’d sauntered in an exclusive gang of three directly out of the class, in the usual blithely disrespectful Western manner, leaving the Chinese students behind. I smiled observing them fawn over Master who stared us out of the room with glaring eyes. We meandered through the hall, exchanging opinions, shuffling and stirring up clouds of dust, chattering about the course content, the hectoring martial air of the showoffy insecure lecturer, and our prospects for the course in general. Not that we were concerned about failing grades but because this lecturer struck us, as opposed to our other professors who were far more reasonable and personable, as being the secular edition of a fire-breathing voodoo priest.

“No dude,” interrupted Noah, dressed today in an unusually clean Mao jacket, blue chinos, and cotton slippers. Even his posture had changed. He was trotting gaily in the iron rice bowl shuffle: bowed shoulders, rag-doll arms, the Chinese moon-walk which is a sort of stamping around as if trying to make sure your feet can reach the ground. All that was missing was a copy of Dr. Mao’s Red Book in Noah’s hand. “That man ain’t like no priest!” he griped earnestly, “You disrespectin’ Dr. King. This mofo, he mo’ like Hitler. Gits himself worked up, starts stepping around and sawing the air. He ain’t speakin to us no mo’. He’s addressin’ the world. He’s speakin’ to history hissef.”

“No way. The new generation of frauds are back to day one. They’re back to taking religion seriously again. Christianity is hi-tech because it’s American. It’s chic. Cool. Deep. I say he’s speaking to God Almighty. Trying to blabbermouth his way into Heaven. Wanting to slick talk his way past Peter at the Pearly Gates.”

“Jive-ass whiteman.” But he was just messing with me, enjoying the chance to let off some steam. He too realized the adjustment that was going to have to be made by all of us, one that would require us to swallow pride by the lungful.

Frank wasn’t in the conversation, ignoring our babble, in the midst of earnest concentration, fuming and scowling, bringing to life the adage that virtue is its own punishment. All three of us were ignoring the Chinese students in the course, several of whom were now following us, like we were the Three Wise Men and trying to improve their English listening skills by lending an ear to our incomprehensible slang-whanging.

I chirped “Nah. Check it out. The man’s got an apostle (Mao), a vision (a fascist utopia with him in charge), and a conspiracy theory (Marxism). Them’s the prime ingredients to that half-baked concoction folks calls religion.”

Noah snorted, “Go suck you so mo eggs, whiteboy. You just wheelin’ and dealin’; scheming and squealing, jiving and hypothesizing. Yo cain’t fool the blackman.”

“What? You’re a poet and you weren’t goin’ to let us know it?” I mocked. “You’re about as black as I am, as ebony as my bonny Scotch-Irish white-trash ass. Besides…”

“Hey dude!” while jumping in front of me and mocking a spastic walking posture ripped from middle-America.

I smiled. “Hold up a second Noah.” Catching up to him I put my hand on his shoulder, and he gave me a withering look. Which I graciously ignored. “Look, you’re dressed up in the local homeboy’s duds. Why are you copping this MTV faux Ebonics anyway?”

He must have already been thinking about this for he didn’t bat an eye before saying, “Hmm… Yo right whiteboy Bob.”

“Pardon?”

He went quiet for a second, closing his eyes, rolling his shoulders up and over, stretching his neck and relaxing full body. As if emerging from a micro-trance he opened his eyes suddenly only to look at me dully, the enlivening spark of Noah the Oreo who tried to hard was gone. He said dully and joylessly, “Okay. Back to normal. Whatever that is.” He wheezed, as if trying to force all of the old musty air out of his lungs, like undertaking an anatomical spring cleaning, and sighed, “Once you get used to being someone else, what is normal anymore, man? Don’t mean nothing. Nothing to me anyways. No way, no how.”

I was still eying his metamorphosis, wondering if it was for real or just another stunt to impress his audience of the moment. “Too true.” I opined. “The face grows to fill the mask.” I shrugged, unconsciously imitating him Pavlovian style, feeling bored, discomfited, discontented. It felt as if he willed his sudden ennui upon me, as if I’d earned it, as if boredom was the appropriate comeuppance for me being such a keener about being true to oneself. Feeling oppressed with a heavy strangling dose of ‘virtue is its own punishment’, the cold-water bath of tedium made me desperate for action of some kind, any kind. I began to obsess about our destination. To give myself time to come up with one I continued blabbering absentmindedly, “That’s what learning Chinese is all about. Picking up a stage double, a second half to the split personality required to work up the right body language and cop the right attitude to converse fluently in both English and Chinese.” Presto! “Hey! Who gives a shit? This is old, old news. But what about food, man? Hows about chowing down on some primo eats? I know this…”

Like a stroke victim operating on a time delay from reality, Noah blundered directly into my words, nuance left behind in his previous persona, “No,” he sighed.

I waited. I continued ambling down the corridor, looking over my shoulder to see that Frank, still apoplectic judging by his floral color scheme, was in tandem.

And then Noah managed with an effort, “We better go to the lounge first. Get your homeboy settled down in private. Park his ass and chill him out.”

To get a rise out of him and snap him out of this zombie personality-in-limbo nonsense, I raised my voice and attacked: “What do you care?”

This perked him up a bit, his eyebrows rising and his eyelids opening, “Who says I care, whiteboy? I got myself to look after and that’s enough trouble as it is. But your European homeboy’s going to set a bad example. He’s rough. Rude. Mean. He likes to hurt people.” Stepping closer to my ear he asked, “What’s his motherfucking problem anyway?”

“Righteousness.”

“You mean self-righteousness?”

“Is there any other kind in this day and age?”

“Bitch!” he said, but rubbing his tummy and smiling.

Arriving at the door to the student lounge, it occurred to me that Frank, in his humorless workaholic methodical fashion had been ignoring the chance to butter up the locals, to check out the cuties and horn in on some well-earned co-ed action. Instead the monomaniac had rifled through his notes and then to our assigned readings. No wonder he was in no mood for conciliation. He had no ulterior motive. Always a bad sign.

His rage, never far from the surface, was erupting again and he was frothing and raging like a... like a mad foreigner, as the locals would say, not incorrectly. Noah opened the door and I took advantage of my superior height and heft to shove Frank inside the lounge for privacy, for safety's sake in other words. Snoops might be listening. Frank didn’t resist. He was pissed off to high heaven, but also terribly demoralized.

Recent events were having an effect on me too. I was starting to heed the advice of those I'd falsely figured were my social inferiors, Michael and Noah. Lately I’d begun to suspect that they, being incurable clowns, had a superior grasp of the dumbed-down world around us. I’d been fooling myself, flattering my ego by excusing my ignorance of the demimonde as worthy, elevating, even glamorous. I hadn’t been born with a spoon either silver or plastic in my mouth and didn’t understand their violent doomed world and didn’t want any part of it. Ignorance was not only bliss, but also the gateway to class, to chic, to the refined air of the beautiful people, intellectually speaking that is. The sort of beauties who’s mantra is that beauty is only skin deep. But it seemed that everyone who was less read than myself was more competent than me. As if knowledge of the bookish kind incurred a growing deficit of know-how and wherewithal. I was confused. I was vulnerable because I didn’t know what I thought anymore. The first hustler down the pipeline could screw me upside down and backwards and I’d be thanking him for it and begging him to come back for sloppy seconds and thirsty thirds. I was in defense mode now and defensive position is usually the worst.

I closed the door behind us and rushed across the room to get first dibs on the cracked caramel vinyl loveseat next to the window facing south, where I hoped to selfishly catch a few stray rays from the sun and a glance at the greenery outside to warm myself up both physically and to the occasion. Frank scuffed across the bare yellow concrete floor and sized up what was left, hard wooden chairs with attached scratched desks, probably ripped off from a local public elementary school.

Having squeezed himself into one, he began cursing again, "I can't fucking believe it. This is the work of monkeys. Sheer primates."

I tried to slow down by asking, "Aren't humans primates?"

"Given enough time monkeys banging on keyboards can type out Shakespeare. A stopped clock is right twice a day. But this sort of foolishness. This requires, what do you American's call it again? Yes, yes! The American substitute for evolution. Yes, yes. Intelligent design."

Whenever he got mad, there was always an American to blame. Even at a time like this, when obviously we were dealing with an entirely homemade Chinese phenomenon.

"Stop calling me American. I'm Canadian." I said irritably.
"Canadian, American. What's the difference? You're all the same. You're just a watered-down milquetoast version of the Americans anyway. That's why they call it Canuckistan."

"No they don't. They call it Canuckistan because it's not like America. Jesus, if you can’t even get that much right, why pretend at all to know anything about what's going on in North American politics? On second thought, don't answer that question."

"Don't get me started on American culture. Or the ersatz substitute for American culture that is American culture."

"You're starting to sound like a Euroweenie, you know that? I should call you Frank N. Furter. Fucking perfect for you because you’re getting perfectly fucking annoying.”

“Fuck you…” he said looking at my couch enviously.

“Likewise. If you weren’t my friend and colleague…”

I had to sneak in ‘friend’ somewhere, risking the required word without losing face by acting like I really cared, like I was a real pal. Now that I think about it, friend is a much more flexible word in Chinese. Has all the right ambiguities in all the right places. Ambidextrous and sufficiently plastic to mean everything and nothing. Why can’t English be so cool?

Anyway, I went at him again with, “Now stop your bitching about Americans in the closet and under the bed. Fucking conspiracy theories. Next thing and you’ll produce a Protocol of the Elders of America. And for heavens sake, who gives a shit what the local propaganda organ spews out anyway."

I didn't mean any of this though, I just wanted to calm him down. Frank could be an annoyance sometimes, but I highly valued him as spiritual anchor. At least we agreed that things were pretty fucked up, almost beyond saving, and that we had to retain a critical mass of integrity if we were to operate as civilized human beings.

But maybe I should show you the article and let you make your own decision. Fresh ripped from the People's Daily on February 8th of this year, I made sure to save a copy for posterity. This is the real McCoy. You're going to love it.

Why are Chinese disinclined to show wealth?

Not only are most Chinese inclined to hide their wealth, they even insist they do not have money.

The disinclination to show wealth has been ingrained in the Chinese culture since ancient times. People today are becoming even more private about their income. Psychologists believe this attitude derives from China's thousands of years of cultural tradition, evidenced in proverbs like "a prominent bird gets shot" and "a blossoming tree will be eventually destroyed". They summarize the essence of Chinese social experience, and reflect certain characteristics of Chinese society to some degree.

Exerting a profound influence on Chinese culture for thousands of years, Confucius' doctrine of the Golden Mean promotes a humble, calm way of life. Thus formed the Chinese people's unique psychological quality of disliking self-publicity.

Since Qin Shihuang, the first Qin emperor (248 BC to 206 BC), unified China 2000 years ago, China has mostly been a unified country. In this relatively stable society, there was little competition and no basis for comparison. In this environment, ancient people did not need to reveal their wealth at all.

Chinese people's unwillingness to show wealth also has a physiological reason. Scientists found more dehydrogenates in Chinese livers than westerners' through studies of intoxicated people from various countries. This explains why alcohol poisoning occurs much less frequently in Chinese even though the alcohol content of China's "white spirit" far exceeds that of foreign liquors. The existence of dehydrogenation enzymes in the human brain may have to do with the fact that the Chinese are better at controlling their moods than Westerners.

Cultural traditions and life styles can also have an impact on brain structure. The cultural traditions, conventions, living habits and attitudes that Chinese have inherited through generations cause gradual genic and neural changes. The accumulation of such quantitative changes eventually leads to qualitative changes, or gene mutation. When the mutated genes were inherited, the disinclination towards wealth exposure passed on.

Modern scientific studies find that only the brain's left hemisphere is active in speaking foreign languages made up of alphabets. However, since the Chinese language combines sound and shape, both hemispheres are used in speaking Chinese. Therefore, it is true that the disparity between people's personalities in the East and West has a physiological basis.

Of course it was loony, a short comedy sprung from the Red Asylum and now out on the loose, foot and fancy free. It botched physiology, genetics, philology, common sense, you name it. It was back to the drawing board, scratched out in crayon: volk myths, eugenics, the master race, lebensraum.

It couldn't fool a foreigner; it wouldn't even fool the Chinese. Or would it? Who was it fooling? Whoops! Whoops, indeed. That was the question which inspired the fear which grew into terror and bloomed as Frank’s psychotic rage.

Copyright Biff Cappuccino
Killing time at the Atimes.com forum:

++++++++
I wrote:

I caught up with this debate a bit late so I've got some catching up to do. I'll start with yojimbo's previous post.

>Please answer me. What is the history of USA all about?<
What does this question even mean?

>I simply ask you what exactly is US history's all about? What kind of ethnic History can you gather form a bunch of "Migrants"[ Germany, Franch, Italy...etc }?<
What on earth does this reply mean? Now I'm even more confused...

>How old is USA anyway?<
You already know the answer. We all do, so why ask the question?

>US's history is about 300 years old<
It is? The US declared independence in 1776. The Mayflower got to America in 1620. Do the math. What does 300 years have to do with anything. Like most loud patriots, when pushed, it turns out you don't know your history. Because, of course, you don't care about history. Loud patriots seldom, if ever, do.

>Don't presume that I know nothing about USA history.<
You first ask an unintelligible question, then give an unintelligible reply, and then inform us you know how old the USA is but get the number wrong. You seem to require a very low standard for being knowledgeable about US history. I presume you hold the same low standard for your knowledge of Chinese history.

>What curriculum are you talking about?<
>Looting? The famous Indian Massacre? Slavery[the true account]?<
This must be the curriculum for Chinese and American history? Looting? 5000 years of looting is part and parcel of Chinese history. All countries looted in the old days. Most still do. If you really knew history you would know this. Indian Massacre? True. Both non-Indians and Indians massacred Indians. Both non-Indians and Indians massacred non-Indians. How about the Tiananmen Massacre? How about the massacres of the Taiping revolution? How about the massacres that accompanied every Chinese dynastic change? All countries with lengthy histories have massacres. Slavery? China had 5000 years of institutionalized slavery. China also had 2000 years of institutionalized cannibalism. Taiwan had slavery too. And cannibalism too. And Taiwan had white slaves as well as Chinese slaves in the 19th century.

>White man still claim that they discovered America...but how on earth did they discover something which has already been discovered? Don't tell me that each state have a different version of such claims....<
Who is White man? A friend of yours? Why don't you learn history instead of just talking about it. Look up Kennebec Man and who found him and why several native Indian activists and the US Department of the Interior want his discovery suppressed. Who knows who first got to America, but it wasn't the white man, nor the Chinese, nor the American Indians. It was probably either Polynesians or Negritos or the same people who first populated Australia 50,000 years ago.

Some Chinese patriots claim that their countrymen discovered Taiwan..."but how on earth did they discover something which has already been discovered?" That's a beautiful line. Unfortunately, the aboriginal peoples were here long before the Chinese. Or perhaps you believe that Taiwan's aborigines are guests of the Chinese? So Taiwan belongs to the aborigines according to your logic (not according to mine: it belongs to whoever lives here or moves here peacefully, not to those who propose to invade by force).

>Your flaw lies in the attempt to compare Chinese History to the US's.<
No. That's your flaw. You don't know Chinese history or US history.

>You dig?<
I dig baby, but you need to keep digging into your own history and that of the US before you start pontificating.

++++++++
Other dude wrote:

Almost all Whites claimed that they discover something.
They claimed to have discovered Singapore...and etc.

You don't even need a patroit say those things...just get a Whiteman...any.

What about Tienanmen incident?
I thought it's already discuss somewhere in the forum?

Is "massacre" a common cliche to be put in anything alien to your kind. So, what about Taiping revolution? Care to start an new thread of discussion?
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How about the massacres that accompanied every Chinese dynastic change?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You mean civil war? I think your "double-talking" is getting too obvious..

Slavery was practised in China? You mean the during Biblical time? So is the birth of acupuncture. But US abolish that practises not too long ago...there is huge time difference..civilisation mature through time and space...apparently US[ Base on US history ] is moving a bit too slow. Does it not reflect the mental maturity of whites....in general?

Don't get me wrong...I'm not a racist. I'm only quoting facts..base on observation. And worried not...you have every right to deny.

++++++++
I wrote the following regrettably uncivil reply:

Yojimbo: You keep asking questions which indicate that you're not serious about getting answers. You don't know Chinese history as evidenced by your glib replies to my and other posts. I would guess that your unhappiness about the change in Taiwan's curriculum is caused by primarily by your fear of people who are educated. You don't know much at all about China's history nor US history. What you think you know comes from reading newspapers, not books. I imagine you're just as intimidated by educated people in China and what really intimidates you is people who can think for themselves. This is why you don't like democracy. This is why you don't like the Taiwanese doing what they want. You have no respect for others. You don't even like people. You prefer nations. Essentially, you are a gangster.

++++++++
Another dude:

Aren't you the Cappuccino guy from the Atime's letters column? I would suggest anyone who plans to reply to this guy would first read his non-sense letters there first.

++++++++
I wrote:

>>Every angle you look at it, culturally, linguistically and religously, Francophones and Englophones in Canada are much more different than Chinese Mainlanders and Taiwanese.<<

You sure about this? 46% of mainlanders don't speak the national language of putonghua, which is why China's national government has recently yet again banned the use of Cantonese and Shanghainese on radio and television. South of Taipei County, many people speak two or three languages, with Mandarin trailing badly in second or third place. Since I only speak Mandarin, in addition to English, this doesn't benefit me at all. Religiously, the Taiwanese are substantially different from the Chinese since they not only were not cut off from their religious roots for forty years, and thus developed a myriad cults and preserved many superstitions that mainlanders would find ridiculous, but also because there is a substantial minority of Christians here as well. Culturally, the Taiwanese are no more like mainlanders than Americans are like Brits. Oil and water. They quite often don't get along and look down on each other. Mainlanders are much more aggressive, decisive, and courageous. But also crude and obsessed with money to a degree no longer pervasive in Taiwan. Taiwanese are more docile, sensitive, knowledgeable, mild-mannered, and cultured.

>>If Quebec could be an integral part of east Canada, there is no reason why Taiwan cannon be an integral part of China. I cannot see how you are trying to defend Taiwan is not part of China while crying out Quebec is part of Canada.<<

Quebec's voters chose twice to stay in the federation, Rene Levesque et al notwithstanding. If Taiwan's voters decide to unite with China, then so be it. But only if they vote for it. I can see advantages (and disadvantages) to uniting with China, but only when it becomes a stable democracy.

>>Haven't you conveniently forgotten other people living in Quebec, such as the Natives? Since when did they vote to join the Confederate?<<

Haven't you forgotten the Tibetans, the Dai, the Miao, etc.? When did they vote to join China? When did the Cantonese vote to join China? They didn't. Like most of China's people, they were conquered. As is the case with almost all countries historically. It's not good nor bad. It's human nature. It's part of all of our ancestor's past.

The point is: Taiwan is a democracy owned by its voters. China is a dictatorship which owns its citizens. The people of Taiwan can and will choose their own curriculum in the manner they want. Someday, hopefully soon, the citizens of China will be able to do the same.

++++++
I wrote again:

>>Says who? It's my knowledge that 70% of the Han Chinese speak dialects that are based on Mandarin.<<

I guess I need to know what you mean by a dialect based on Mandarin? Cantonese, Shanghainese, Fukkienese? Or one of the Szechuan or Yunnanese dialects? All of these 'dialects' are as unintelligible to the Mandarin speaker as the Latin based 'dialects' of French and German are to the English speaker.

I couldn't find the original article through google, but located a blog carrying it (or something like it) here: http://pinyin.info/news/index.php?m=200412

Scroll down the page a bit and you'll find it.

>>The Cantonese? The Cantonese are much Chinese as the Beijingers, Shanghaiese and other Chinese.<<

I agree. I didn't dispute this. And American Indians and the descendants of American slaves are Americans too. My point is that historically speaking they were once separate people. Just like the original language of Hong Kong was neither Cantonese nor Mandarin and yet the local patriots fight over which of these two non-native languages should be paramount. (http://www.inmediahk.net/public/article?item_id=15151&group_id=16)

I get the feeling few Chinese take an interest in their own nation's history. Most Americans take little interest in their nation's history either for that matter. Same goes for every other country I'm sure. This is one of the reasons I find this debate rather odd. TKT is the only one of us who takes the issues seriously. I haven't followed the Taiwan curriculum issue either. I'm just as ignorant of the issues as the rest of you. But when some of you don't seem to know much about your own nation's history and yet pretend that national history curriculums are critically important to student development, you'll forgive me if I doubt your sincerity. And you'll forgive me if I again doubt your preference for, or understanding of, democracy. Some of you seem to think that democracy is just a scam or a hustle, just another unethical way to get around what the public wants in the old-fashioned communist or dynastic imperial way.

But if you're genuinely pro-democracy, then you respect how people vote. You don't try to make far-fetched excuses by finding other nations who have (or only appear to have) failed to operate in a democratic manner in the past. If you're pro-democracy for China, then you should be pro-democracy for Taiwan (What's more important to you? people as individuals, or people as a concept?). Thus of course I agree the people of Quebec have the right to vote themselves into independence. Just as I agree that North Carolina should have had the right to leave the US in 1831 and the Southern Confederacy should have been able to become independent of the US in 1861. It's not democracy for me when it's convenient and fiat rule for you. It's democracy for everyone. Again, once China becomes a democracy, then perhaps Taiwan will vote to unite with China. It's not up to you and me. It's up to the people of Taiwan.

++++++
I wrote yet again:

>>Not by voting, but by fighting a final war. If they win, they can have independence. If mainland wins, there will be reunification. That's the deal.<<

So you're totalitarian. A gangster. No problem. But in future lets not play any games and pretend you have any genuine sympathy for democracy. Face the facts. You're not democratic in spirit.

Well, the problem with being a gangster is that those who live by the sword tend to die by the sword. As you know it won't be a war between Taiwan and China. It never has been. China has been trying to get into Taiwan since the 1950s and has failed because the US has kept it out. If there is a war, it will be with Taiwan, Japan, and the US on one side against China on the other. I suggest you read up on your military before you get your hopes up. Try David Shambaugh's "Modernizing China's Military". Those who don't learn history are doomed to repeat it. And some of you guys sure don't know your history. The place that really needs educational curriculum reform is China, gentlemen. As you already suspect, I'm sure.

+++++++
And yet again I wrote:

Yojimbo: Presumptuous? Perhaps. But it's hard to get your attention. Now you're serious. Good. Finally. You usually prefer to be flippant.

>>Since you mention about Taiping Rebellion, please tell me who are those involved in the rebellion. Was it a religious thing, what religion? Where have all them flee to?<<

With all due respect, I'm not your office-boy. I've already demonstrated my devotion to history and my desire to make an earnest argument for what I think. It's time for you to do some legwork and assemble some arguments of your own that are apposite to this thread. I'm happy to debate with you as long as you're sincere. If you make a good argument, I'll be happy to concede. But straw white-man ad hominen arguments don't carry any water. As you already know.

++++++
jzhang wrote:

Have I touched your nerves by saying it bluntly how this issue is going to be resolved if Taiwan refuses reunification? Also I have no idea what a "totalitarian" is supposed to be, because it's in my opinion a non-existing word and not applicable in this context. I'm insulted you call me a gangster. Taiwan separatists and their foreign aides are gangsters instead. Also I'm not interested in democracy. I'm only interested in China.

I am certain US won't defend Taiwan, because Taiwan has little strategic influence and the US won't be willing to pay the price China is willing to pay. Neither is Japan. It's all logic. The current peace is only maintained by the hope of peaceful reunification and the love for Taiwan compatriots (which is not returned btw). Not by the US or any other foreign interference. Without this hope, as the Cross straits future is starting to get grimmer, the prospect of war will become bigger. So take away the hope, and you get war. If Taiwan wins, it becomes independent. If mainland wins, there will be reunification. And I have no doubt what the outcome would be.

++++++
I wrote:

Actually I'm touched by your honesty...haha... If you're not interested in democracy (glad to hear you admit it!) and you don't like the word totalitarian or gangster, how would you characterize yourself? Let me guess... A patriot! I.e.: someone willing to sacrifice the lives of his people for his country because he believes real flesh and blood is less important than the sacred concept of nationhood. Very impressive. You don't like people. You don't trust them. So naturally you don't like democracy. Nor do you like education.

For those of you who approve of democracy and education this, in my opinion, is the type of person who constitutes 95% of loud Chinese patriots. Fortunately most Chinese people have better things to do with their time than be patriotic during peacetime.

Good luck jzhang: someday I think you will agree that democracy is far more important than nationalism, racism, and ethnic chauvenism. The world is a good place. You're naive to think that it is not.

++++++
I wrote:

Yojimbo: you already tried and failed to get me to do your homework for you. And then you bungle history again. You reach back to Nam because you're too embarrassed to look at US success in Iraq. And by the way, I ain't American.

And you need to lose this inferiority complex. Take a deep breath. Try to feel good about yourself. There's nothing wrong with your skin tone, man. I don't care about your ethnicity. Half my family is black. My wife is Chinese.

Do I want to be a cyber-thug? No yojimbo. You do.

I'm leaving this thread. You guys should stop worrying about China's future. China's going to do just fine. And stop worrying about what white people think. It doesn't matter.

Good luck to you all.